Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Replies 1k
  • Views 46.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

They are two horrifically written Reviews.

this is mine:

 

------

 

 

Tasked with following the utterly fantastic She's A Mess is Give It To Me Now. With a Timbaland feel to the production and backing track Give It To Me Now is undoubtedly a Sugababes track. Hook 'Put your money where your mouth' is likely to be stuck in your head for weeks to come. Very well produced, the track wouldn't be out of place on Change and is a more poppy Back Down. The harmonies on this track sound brilliant and show that perhaps Jade wasn't such a bad replacement after all.

 

 

am i the only one who LOVES Give it 2 me now !!!!!!!! put ur money where ur mouth is ;)

 

-_-

 

 

 

i would find my ratings post where i rated it highly but i cba seeing as this will be ignored anyway :rolleyes:

 

  • Author
I loled when I saw the NME review. They bad mouthed Get Sexy in the album review but 6 months ago they were praising it. :rofl:
  • Author

listen to these they are quite cool.

 

 

 

 

 

 

My first post on this forum and I think I'll rate Sweet 7:

 

Get Sexy : 9/10. (Keisha version is far better)

Wear My Kiss : 8/10 (Love both, Keisha's version slightly more)

About A Girl : 10/10 (One of my faves, again, Prefer Keisha's version)

Wait For You : 9/10 (Jade's version is good but weaker than Keisha's)

Thank You For The Heartbreak : 10/10 (my fave song from the album though I prefer Keisha's version by miles)

Miss Everything 7/10

She's A Mess 9/10

Give It To Me Now 6/10 (my least fave song on the album)

Crash And Burn 8/10 (Love the new one with Heidi doing the 2nd verse)

No More You 10/10 (Adore this song, wish we could have Keisha's studio version though :( )

Sweet & Amazing 7/10

Little Miss Perfect 9/10 (I didn't like it at first, its grown on me alot, Amelle sounds great on it)

Edited by Adam92

My first post on this forum and I think I'll rate Sweet 7:

 

Get Sexy : 9/10. (Keisha version is far better

Wait For You : 9/10 (Jade's version is good but weaker than Keisha's)

Thank You For The Heartbreak : 10/10 (my fav song from the album though I prefer Keisha's version by miles)

Welcome to the forum!

 

I agree that Keisha's version is far better than the above tracks

Welcome to the forum!

 

I agree that Keisha's version is far better than the above tracks

 

Thanks, Well it's certainly visible which I prefer in the fact that Keisha's TYFTH has 119 plays for me while Jade's has 40.

Thanks, Well it's certainly visible which I prefer in the fact that Keisha's TYFTH has 119 plays for me while Jade's has 40.

Keisha has 195plays and Jade just 11 for me

Keisha has 195plays and Jade just 11 for me

 

Wow haha, what a difference! So which would you say is your fave track?

Wow haha, what a difference! So which would you say is your fave track?

Keisha's TYFTH or She's A Mess.

 

She's A Mess has 144 plays the now

 

Keisha's Wait For You is 3rd with 93 plays [Jade just 14]

IMO Get sexy and wear my kiss are the only tracks which sound better with keisha - i must be hearing something diff to everyone else
IMO Get sexy and wear my kiss are the only tracks which sound better with keisha - i must be hearing something diff to everyone else

Quite clearly.

 

I'll stick with my hearing thanks, where the utter stunnningness of Wait For You and TYFTH aren't raped tortured and then murdered by Jade

No rossyboy you're not alone. (Apart from I also prefer Jade's version of 'Get Sexy' :ph34r:) Really not understanding the hate being given towards Jade's versions. Some people are going OTT when they say Jade's murdered them or whatever. :lol: Yeah sure, they can prefer one version more than the other, but to say she "murdered/raped/tortured" and then give the tracks v good reviews and stuff, is a bit "WTF?". But whatever each to their own I guess...
No rossyboy you're not alone. (Apart from I also prefer Jade's version of 'Get Sexy' :ph34r:) Really not understanding the hate being given towards Jade's versions. Some people are going OTT when they say Jade's murdered them or whatever. :lol: Yeah sure, they can prefer one version more than the other, but to say she "murdered/raped/tortured" and then give the tracks v good reviews and stuff, is a bit "WTF?". But whatever each to their own I guess...

I've never given Jades version of either a v. good review. :unsure:

IMO Get sexy and wear my kiss are the only tracks which sound better with keisha - i must be hearing something diff to everyone else

 

Not everyone. I've seen lots of people prefer Jade's versions, myself included. :) She takes Heartbreak especially to a whole new level. Keisha's is completely mediocre IMO.

Isnt it rather inevitable though that the original Keisha versions would be better since they were written with Keisha in mind to sing them.
I think the first 6 tracks are far better with Keisha, Jade fares better on the last half of the album for me, TYFTH just screams Keisha, Jade's version has the over the top note that just ruins it for me
Jade brings a fresh energy to sugababes - Wait For You is stunningly sung by Jade - esp when you compare the accapellas above. each to their own I guess.
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.