Posted November 28, 200915 yr Put your opinions on each lady to one side, how would you rate their vocal ability? Remember, the type of music may not be suited to you...but we're talking about their vocal ability, so it doesn't matter if you like their music/tone or not. * Siobhan Donaghy - 9 * Keisha Buchanan - 8 * Mutya Buena - 9 * Heidi Range - 6 * Amelle Berrabah - 7 * Jade Ewen - 8
November 28, 200915 yr * Siobhan Donaghy - 7 * Keisha Buchanan - 9 * Mutya Buena - 8 * Heidi Range - 7 * Amelle Berrabah - 8 * Jade Ewen - 9
November 28, 200915 yr Author Y'all really think Siobhan & Heidi are the same vocal range? I think Siobhan displays a more wider range than Heidi, personally. Heidi plays it safe and sticks somewhere in the middle for the most part.
November 28, 200915 yr Siobhan / 6 Mutya / 8 Keisha / 8.5 Heidi / 7.5 Amelle / 8.5 Jade / 9 I actually really like Amelle's voice, prefer it to Mutya's
November 28, 200915 yr Siobhan Donaghy - 9/10 Keisha Buchanan - 9.5/10 Mutya Buena - 8/10 Heidi Range - 7.5/10 Amelle Berrabah - 9.5/10 Jade Ewen - 9.5/10 Vocally, I think 3.0 were the best, their voices just fitted in better imo, but all line ups are great tbh. Rank: 1) 3.0 2) 1.0 3) 2.0 I haven't included 4.0 in my rank because I have yet to hear a great deal of performances. Edited November 28, 200915 yr by SugaRush
November 28, 200915 yr This is hard. Because they all have good voices as they have parts which perfectly suit each song. Heidi's voice is perfect for the parts she has etc... /but technically Jade is head and shoulders above the rest. I actually can't stand Mutya's voice on most of their songs. It's grating and I find her overrated by 'babes fans, but that's just me...
November 28, 200915 yr * Siobhan Donaghy - 7 * Keisha Buchanan - 10 * Mutya Buena - 10 * Heidi Range - 8 * Amelle Berrabah - 7 * Jade Ewen - 7
November 28, 200915 yr I like Heidi's voice, I know she'd never be able to do the amount that Amelle/Keisha do but it has a nice quality to it imo and isnt some out of tune wailing like some of you pretend it is. Keisha, stunning voice. Amazing. Jade aswell, brilliant. Amelle, not quite up with Keisha and Jade but still very good. The kind of voice that could annoy you though, a solo Amelle album would be a bit iffy. Siobhan I dont really know, a bit like Heidi I suppose. Only with a bit more depth to it. Mutya, nice enough. A nit whiny and annoying after a bit.
November 28, 200915 yr Mutya || 10000000000000000000000000000000/10 Mutya can do no wrong in my eyes :wub: [musically] i adore her vocals, it think she has a stunning voice Keisha || 10/10 Her range is phenominal and anyone who has seen K live can attest to her sublime adlibs. Siobhan || 9.7/10 She is a fantastic singer. 1.0 was just amazingly talented. Shiv's vocals are quite versitle as well [see RFC/Overload -> Ghost/Don't Give It Up] Heidi || 8/10 for me the weakest live, but she has a great range and her voice is nice to listen to Amelle || 10/10 i love the smokey dark sinister depths to Amelle's voice. Beware is sublime because of her and i love it/her Jade || 6/10 Meh. We'll see what she's like when she stops murdering Get Sexy. i'll be better able to rate her after the tour.
November 28, 200915 yr Mutya || 10000000000000000000000000000000/10 Mutya can do no wrong in my eyes :wub: [musically] i adore her vocals, it think she has a stunning voice Keisha || 10/10 Her range is phenominal and anyone who has seen K live can attest to her sublime adlibs. Siobhan || 9.7/10 She is a fantastic singer. 1.0 was just amazingly talented. Shiv's vocals are quite versitle as well [see RFC/Overload -> Ghost/Don't Give It Up] Heidi || 8/10 for me the weakest live, but she has a great range and her voice is nice to listen to Amelle || 10/10 i love the smokey dark sinister depths to Amelle's voice. Beware is sublime because of her and i love it/her Jade || 6/10 Meh. We'll see what she's like when she stops murdering Get Sexy. i'll be better able to rate her after the tour. :wub: Amelle on Beware is probably my fave bit of Amelle.
November 28, 200915 yr * Siobhan Donaghy - 7 * Keisha Buchanan - 7 * Mutya Buena - 8 * Heidi Range - 6 * Amelle Berrabah - 8 * Jade Ewen - 10
November 28, 200915 yr * Siobhan Donaghy - 7 * Keisha Buchanan - 9 * Mutya Buena - 8 * Heidi Range - 7 * Amelle Berrabah - 8 * Jade Ewen - 9 Each have their own qualities so it's not easy to rate :unsure:
November 29, 200915 yr Jade has the most strong voice but at the same time she's the most 'classical' singer. I'd say Siobhan 8/10 Keisha 9/10 Mutya 8/10 Heidi 8/10 Amelle 9/10 Jade 9/10 I can't put less than 8/10 for any of the girl. At the same I don't think any of them has outstanding Whitney's sized voice, so all of them get 8-9/10 from me.
November 29, 200915 yr * Siobhan Donaghy - 4 * Keisha Buchanan - 7 * Mutya Buena - 8 * Heidi Range - 5 * Amelle Berrabah - 7 * Jade Ewen - 9
November 30, 200915 yr Keisha has the best overall voice IMO. I'm not sure if shes got a better vocal range than Jade(she cant be far off anyway) but her tone is much better and sounds less american than Jades. Keisha - 9 Jade - 8 Amelle - 6 Heidi - 6 Siobhan - Can't remember what she sounds like!
December 1, 200915 yr Siobhan; 6/10 - She has a pleasant voice, but it's not anything special Keisha; 8/10 - I find it really overrated, but she can hold a note Amelle; 9/10 - Best by far IMO. She's got a unique quality to it Heidi; 5/10 - She's like Siobhan, a pleasant voice, but technically she isn't a fantastic singer Mutya; 7/10 - Good voice, but gets samey Jade; 7/10 - Good voice, but not any special.
