Posted November 28, 200915 yr Do you think they could survive another line-up change? Especially if Heidi got her ass kicked out?
November 28, 200915 yr Yes as long as they keep making good music. The Sugababes will live on forever. I have worked out that the first line-up to have a man in will be Sugababes 103.0.
November 28, 200915 yr No. If/when Heidi decides to leave or gets thrown out, it should be the end of Sugababes. I wouldn't mind if Amelle and Jade joined forces and found a new member but they couldn't and rightfully shouldn't continue with the 'babes name imo.
November 28, 200915 yr It's become painfully obvious with Keisha-gate the Sugababes are no longer a band, they are a manufacturing tool of the label who make music but have no connection to fans or true loyalties. So yes, they would survive without Heidi but if/when Heidi left that SHOULD be the end.
November 28, 200915 yr I'm actually hoping Beige gets kicked out next so the group can truly become an great group. Now that they're trying to be sexy and doing more dancing Beige is holding them back even more the 2.0 or 3.0 where she mainly just held them back vocally during live performances. Amelle is pretty and Jade can pull of sexy and she has a great voice. Both of them are good dancers. They could really use a third member that can hold her own compared to them two. Beige doesn't help their sexy image at all.
November 28, 200915 yr Author Her name is Heidi Beige? For all these years, I've been thinking it's Heidi Range. Wow.
November 28, 200915 yr TBH i find Heidi the most attractive out of all 6 members unless Amelle has her hair like she does on the Sweet 7 cover or some bits during the Get Sexy video. Heidi in the AAG video it hot as fuk.
November 28, 200915 yr I wish people would stop call her Beige, grow up <_< In my opinion, Heidi is the only reason Sugababes should be allowed to keep the name. I do think Amelle has earned her right, but she's not been there for the majority of their hits. Also, Heidi is possibly the most popular with the public, she's the "sweet, blonde one". my mum loves her :lol:
November 28, 200915 yr Yeah, stfu calling her Beige now, it's not even funny. -_- Also, in relation to the original question, no. The main reason most of the fans are with them through 4.0 is because Heidi is still there and can be somewhat seen as an original in most fans' eyes.
November 28, 200915 yr Her name is Heidi Range, just some people are immature. It depends tbh, if she leaves say relatively soon then no, they probably woudlnt. But say she follows the pattern and leaves in 4 years time, after Jade's made 2-3 albums then they probably would.
November 28, 200915 yr The bands a bloody joke regardless. Heidi could leave and they could carry on with the brand name and then we could have a 2.0- reunion and finally get an album that could beat 3.
November 28, 200915 yr Author Her name is Heidi Range, just some people are immature. It depends tbh, if she leaves say relatively soon then no, they probably woudlnt. But say she follows the pattern and leaves in 4 years time, after Jade's made 2-3 albums then they probably would. Ah, I see. Why do they call her Heidi Beige?
November 28, 200915 yr Wouldn't be funny if the Sugababes 1.1 reunion (if it happens) follows a similar pattern to the Sugababes so far. :rofl:
November 28, 200915 yr Wouldn't be funny if the Sugababes 1.1 reunion (if it happens) follows a similar pattern to the Sugababes so far. :rofl: I a reuion did happen, personally, I think that's exactly how it would end up.
November 28, 200915 yr Ah, I see. Why do they call her Heidi Beige? Apparently shes bland and alot of people call it her? Anyway if Heidi left and was replaced then fair enough, obviously its a brand now but I'd be more gutted tbh since it's Heidi who I like most.
November 28, 200915 yr i'd be most gutted if Amelle left. Keisha i could have handled walking, the fact she was sacked really annoyed/hurt me. She was never really my fave but she was always this consistant figure of amazingness. The tour adlibs, her enthusiasm, her love for her fans. Amelle i would have been in tears for weeks. I've met her twice and both times she was so lovely, she barged seciurity guards out the way in Glasgow, and at Vodafone TBA as she was being dragged away by the cunty management and freddie she came back coz she had seen/spoken/photograpthed with every one at our barrier but missed one little girl. I thought it was so sweet the way she came runnin back down the hill shivering because she'd missed one person.
