January 28, 201015 yr Personally Mutya was the one i fell in love with. Looks and Vocals. Vocally, for me, no one can touch Mutya. She just does it for me, Amelle comes close because she's similar to Mut. Keisha has stunningly powerful vocals and was flawless live. I'm not gonna comment on Jade's live ability coz i haven't seen her on tour yet, but she's missing something that Keisha had.
January 28, 201015 yr Nadine :wub: I totally forgot to vote on this- but she'd deffo have got an 11 for voice and apperance. Clearly "the voice" of Girls Aloud. Love her. I agree 100%, to come below Cheryl is an absolute crime, I'm not sure I'd even have been that big a GA fan without Nadine, certainly from 2002-2005/6 when the others started getting more of a chance to shine, Nadine carried the band in my opinion vocally whilst the others were still developing without a doubt my favourite member, shame nobody in GA comes close to Cheryl in the popularity stakes now, it feels like a superstar in a band with four non-entitites and she really doesn't warrant the mass hype :(
January 28, 201015 yr WTF?!? :mellow: The only thing I can think about, that made Cheryl come out as the top GA member, is pretty much the fact she's just released her first solo album and probably looks. In the looks department, as stunning as Cheryl is, she's always been my 3rd favourite (behind Kimberley and Nadine). I didn't think Cheryl was popular enough to come Top 5 on this rate. :( For every lover that is on this site, she more than doubles in the hatahs. Ah well I guess it all just depends on who voted.
January 28, 201015 yr WTF?!? :mellow: The only thing I can think about, that made Cheryl come out as the top GA member, is pretty much the fact she's just released her first solo album and probably looks. In the looks department, as stunning as Cheryl is, she's always been my 3rd favourite (behind Kimberley and Nadine). I didn't think Cheryl was popular enough to come Top 5 on this rate. :( For every lover that is on this site, she more than doubles in the hatahs. Ah well I guess it all just depends on who voted. if I was rating them on voice it would be lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll Nadine llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll Nicola llllllllllllllll Sarah lllllll Cheryl llllll Kimberley looks; lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll Nadine llllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll Sarah llllllllllllllllllllllllllllll Cheryl llllllllllllllllllllllll Nicola llllllllllllll Kimberley personality; lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll Sarah lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll Nadine lllllllllllllllllllllllllllll Kimberley lllllllllllllllll Nicola llllllllllllllll Cheryl although I would have rated Cheryl probably higher on personality a couple of years ago but I find her a bit fake sometimes now...like you mentioned before, Nicola's a bit grumpy sometimes but still seems nice, Kimberley seems lovely, Nadine looks hilarious although comes across as diva-ish occasionally, and Sarah seems a bit wild which is a good thing as she's unpredictable, unlike Cheryl who is completely predictable these days as she has her a-lister superstar image to maintain...
January 28, 201015 yr Author I'd go like this personally - 1.Nicola 2.Nadine 3.Kimberley 4.Sarah 5.Cheryl imo she has the worst voice and worse personality, although I do still like her alot dont get me wrong.
January 28, 201015 yr I'm in agreement with putting Cheryl last. I've always prefered Nadine out of the GA members. Nadine>Sarah>Kimberly>Nicola>Cheryl.
January 28, 201015 yr Author 5. Cheryl Cole (Girls Aloud) - [364 points] http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/cherylcol.jpg So Cheryl tops out of the GA gang <_< (only getting 1 more point than Nadine) I was tempted to add an extra 2 to Nadine so she would come higher but I didnt :lol: , neways she has obviously got some appeal (just a bit overated, and this is coming from a huge GA fan, I just wish the other 4 would get recognized now and again) Appearance = 142 Personality = 123 Voice = 99 Total = 364 thXbDO0_idI 19UFRSIZPJI TGRQOCroqL4 dEBaKE_nm7M
January 28, 201015 yr it's safe to say that Kelly Rowland's done incredibly well in this :o dark horse!
January 28, 201015 yr it's safe to say that Kelly Rowland's done incredibly well in this :o dark horse! I think Keisha will be next, followed by Kelly Rowland. The battle is for number one- Beyonce or Alesha. I'm going to say Beyonce though..
January 28, 201015 yr Uch, how disgusting that Cheryl has beaten Nadine, I wouldnt have minded a few years back, when Cheryl posessed a personality and a half decent voice but now? The woman has nothing going for her other than looks. Well, and the title of dullest album of all time. Nadine definatly has the best voice out of GA. Followed by Nicola and then Sarah. Kimberley and Cheryl are probably equal really, though at least Kimberly has a relatively interesting voice, if she is out of tune half the time. Looks wise. Nicole would probably have to come last, but she's still a pretty girl imo. Nadine and Cheryl would share 1st place with Sarah 3rd and Kimberly 4th. Personality wise, Kimberley, followed by Sarah, Nicola, Nadine, a large gap and Cheryl.
January 28, 201015 yr I hope Keisha is top 3, but from a SugaLoon perspective she beat the highest member of GA so anywhere in the top4 is fine by me :heehee:
January 28, 201015 yr Author 4. Keisha Buchanan (Sugababes) - [366 points] http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/keishabuchanan.jpg So she is the top Sugababes (And I'm very glad) I love her voice, Im suprised she is this high tbh as alot of people seem to dislike her, but I'm glad she is top 5! anyways she beat Cheryl by just 2 points (looking forward for her solo effort!) Appearance = 121 Personality = 104 Voice = 141 Total = 366 ez0fmFHov4c 0MkYLU45oHQ ITh2IQLRXAQ zexzoURPdnE
January 28, 201015 yr Author So that leaves just 3 ladies Alesha Dixon VS Beyonce Knowles VS Kelly Rowland and I shall reveal the top 3 tomorrow. you do you think is Buzzjacks Ultimate Girlband Member?
January 28, 201015 yr shocked that Kelly Rowland managed top 3 having seen only one of the top three ladies live, Beyonce is stunning and her voice is flawless but her personality was a bit annoying to say the least... Alesha seems lovely, she's very attractive and has a great voice, but her voice probably won't be as highly regarded as Beyonce's so it will be close between these two I think :D Kelly will almost certainly be 3rd, nice voice, personality and looks but maybe won't score as exceptionally high as the other two will in two categories each at least
January 28, 201015 yr Author Oh and here is a quick recap of the top 20 = 4.Keisha Buchanan (366 points) 5.Cheryl Cole (364 points) 6.Nadine Coyle (363 points) 7.Jade Ewen (352 points) 8.Emma Bunton (347 points) 9.Nicole Scherzinger / Kimberley Walsh (346 points) 10.Melanie C (345 points) 11.Amelle Berrabah (344 points) 12.Sarah Harding (336 points) 13.Melanie B (330 points) 14.Vanessa White (328 points) 15.Melody Thornton / Heidi Range (321 points) 16.Una Healy (320 points) 17.Nicola Roberts (311 points) 18.Mutya Buena (304 points) 19.Natasha Hamilton (302 points) 20.Geri Halliwell (301 points)
January 28, 201015 yr 4. Keisha Buchanan (Sugababes) - [366 points] http://i9.photobucket.com/albums/a95/Lukuzz/keishabuchanan.jpg So she is the top Sugababes (And I'm very glad) I love her voice, Im suprised she is this high tbh as alot of people seem to dislike her, but I'm glad she is top 5! anyways she beat Cheryl by just 2 points (looking forward for her solo effort!) Appearance = 121 Personality = 104 Voice = 141 Total = 366 ez0fmFHov4c 0MkYLU45oHQ ITh2IQLRXAQ zexzoURPdnE *bows down* X_7yq2F56Lo That middle 8 is just so effortless for her :wub:
January 28, 201015 yr Author *bows down* X_7yq2F56Lo That middle 8 is just so effortless for her :wub: Great addition, she owns that song and its great! :wub:
Create an account or sign in to comment