Jump to content

Featured Replies

i doubt she would still be there if that were the case and anyway Frankie is a better singer than Mollie.
  • Replies 64
  • Views 8.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I know this sounds awful for a fan to say this but I think that part of the problem with The Saturdays is that the public cannot get to know each member of the band in the same way they can recognise and relate to a single solo singer. I just think with 5 girls in the band there is at least one too many. Its hard for the people who are not real fans to remember each member of a 5 piece group.

 

I know some of my friends cannot distinguish each band member.

 

This theory of mine of course does not mean the Frankie rumour is true.

 

And having followed the girls performances, interviews, tweets etc. for ages now, I have always for the feeling that Una and Frankie are not the best of friends in the group (another theory of mine).

 

So anyway apart from all this I think they were right to change management. Things were not working out before and they need to try what they can to grow the band further. I really hope it works out.

I know this sounds awful for a fan to say this but I think that part of the problem with The Saturdays is that the public cannot get to know each member of the band in the same way they can recognise and relate to a single solo singer. I just think with 5 girls in the band there is at least one too many. Its hard for the people who are not real fans to remember each member of a 5 piece group.

 

I know some of my friends cannot distinguish each band member.

 

This theory of mine of course does not mean the Frankie rumour is true.

 

And having followed the girls performances, interviews, tweets etc. for ages now, I have always for the feeling that Una and Frankie are not the best of friends in the group (another theory of mine).

 

So anyway apart from all this I think they were right to change management. Things were not working out before and they need to try what they can to grow the band further. I really hope it works out.

 

I agree with you - they never seem to really acknowledge one another that much. I don't know, I just have this feeling that they don't really click. Una is definately closest to Mollie and Rochelle, that's for sure.

 

 

I doubt the rumour is true but even so, it'll be interesting to see how things pan out from here on in. Also - a poster on Digital Spy picked up in the Missing You performance at T4OTB, Rochelle looked as though she gave Frankie a "dirty" look.. It looks to me as though she was looking out to the crowd. I don't think Rochelle's like that anyway and I don't think it's a dirty look either.. but here it is if anyone's interested!

 

It's at 0.42 seconds in the video

 

Edited by Encore

Does this mean all the digs i've been making at Frankie recently, about how the other four hate her for being a publicity whore may be true? :lol: :(

 

TBH as long as Mollie and Rochelle still love each other - nothing else matters. MOCHELLE FOREVER.

 

Oh, how I love conspiracy theories. They're probably complete bull$h!te but we can all pretend they're real :wub:

Is it true that they changed management over Frankie??

 

The rumor I heard is that the other four went to management saying they wanted frankie out because she's impossible to work with and can't sing. But management said no because she gets the group the most attention. So then they decided to sack their management.

 

Idk if it's true though...

Surely if they changed management for that, Frankie would have been long out the door once they found their new management which means she wouldn't be there now...

 

It's at 0.42 seconds in the video

 

Rochelle, clearly wasn't looking at Frankie and was getting a sneak look to see what Vanessa and Una were doing as she didn't want to come in to early with the dance routine.
I doubt Rochelle would give Frankie a dirty look considering they were friends before The Saturdays. As long as Una and Frankie stay are fine, they are the most known in my friends. Obviously Rochelle is quite well known as well.
Is it true that they changed management over Frankie??

 

The rumor I heard is that the other four went to management saying they wanted frankie out because she's impossible to work with and can't sing. But management said no because she gets the group the most attention. So then they decided to sack their management.

 

Idk if it's true though...

 

 

that doesn't even make sense

 

I'm sorry but, no-ones leaving, there's no bitch fest in the group, they're not splitting, and their new management team is there for a reason. They need a new direction, and I don't think Jayne was achieving that as well as her group could of done.
I'm sorry but, no-ones leaving, there's no bitch fest in the group, they're not splitting, and their new management team is there for a reason. They need a new direction, and I don't think Jayne was achieving that as well as her group could of done.

 

very nicely put! its amazing how one comment in here can make everyone believe its true. there would be no saturdays if frankei wasnt there imo. she is the one everyone knows despiute ebing second weakest vocally..

I think Jayne was holding The Sats togther. Without her I bet it will quickly fall apart
  • 3 weeks later...
Well their desicion to ditch Jayne looks even stupider now The Wanted are cruising to number one

I'm not entirely sure why it's #1 on iTunes :s. I mean have they been doing much promo? I haven't seen them on TV nor heard them on radio. I think it may be a 'fan' thing, just downloading it so it gets to #1 for the sake of it. I doubt it'll be #1 on iTunes in the next coming days...

 

(Unless Jayne put more work into The Wanted as revenge on The Saturdays muhahahahaha)

 

 

That rumour is untrue in my opinion, and in the performance of 'Missing You', Rochelle definitely wasn't giving Frankie a dirty look. If some of the girls aren't exactly best friends with all of eachother, I hope that Mollie and Rochelle still remain friends, like Aled said.

 

MOCHELLE 4EVER. :heart:

The saturdays seem to be falling apart already!

Miming everywhere now. They need missing you to sell over 60k on its first week i think to stand achance. Headlines is doing well on Hmv pre-order etc.

how the fcuk are they falling apart?
The saturdays seem to be falling apart already!

Miming everywhere now. They need missing you to sell over 60k on its first week i think to stand achance. Headlines is doing well on Hmv pre-order etc.

 

How are they falling apart? Oh okay, they're falling apart because they mime? HA.

 

They've been miming on TV appearances for ages, even under Jayne's management.

  • Author
The saturdays seem to be falling apart already!

Miming everywhere now. They need missing you to sell over 60k on its first week i think to stand achance. Headlines is doing well on Hmv pre-order etc.

 

 

You've just completely contradicted yourself?!

You did this in Miley's threads but don't start it up here.

Keep your conspiracy theories to yourself or at least give a better justification than "Oh they're miming, they're falling apart".

The saturdays seem to be falling apart already!

Miming everywhere now. They need missing you to sell over 60k on its first week i think to stand achance. Headlines is doing well on Hmv pre-order etc.

you make me laugh :lol:

They only time they mime is on TV performances, you know :huh: For all their tours and festivals, they ALWAYS sing live ^_^

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.