Posted October 17, 201014 yr Both songs are covered by two most famous singers in the world Britney Spears & Christina Aguilera. Both songs were released in the UK on the same day and MY has peaked @ #3, CW @ #4. CW has spent 14 weeks in top 75, MP 12 weeks. MP has sold 115,000+ CW over 100,000+. So which is ur fave song? Christina Aguilera - Car Wash aVlpy5USN-E Britney Spears - My Prerogative EXaMZ2pVZtk
October 17, 201014 yr They are both terrible and should be long forgotten. SR speaks the truth! Also I think Madonna and Mariah Carey will be surprised to learn that Christina Aguilera is in fact the most famous singer in the world.
October 17, 201014 yr 'Car Wash' is the better of the two by a mile. It's also a brilliant cover IMO (preferred it over the original).
October 17, 201014 yr I'm not bias or anything, but "My Prerogative" is better for the spoken introduction (rumored to have been written by Spears herself!).
October 17, 201014 yr Both are way much better than the original versions. My favourite is "My Prerogative", though. It is such an upturn from the original Bobby Brown version, and I love the spoken part at the beginning and the autotune used through the song suits it very well.
October 17, 201014 yr 'My Prerogative'. Not only 'coz it's Brit, but it's truly one of the best cover versions ever. (imo obvz) There's just something about it and she made it her own and it suited her both lyrically and musically.
October 17, 201014 yr At the time of their release I was in love with 'Car Wash' but looking back, it's not aged well (or maybe it was just $h!t to begin with, I dont know). But yes, as much as I do hate admitting that Britney has ever done anything better than Christina in this case her rubbish cover is slightly better than Flopie's rubbish cover.
October 17, 201014 yr :o I never know My Prerogative was a cover! Who sings the original? :unsure: Bobby Brown.
October 17, 201014 yr Car Wash was a guilty pleasure, back when Christina could do little wrong in my eyes. I never liked My Prerogative and still don't.
October 17, 201014 yr Car wash here:it should have been in her GH album Edited October 17, 201014 yr by burning up!
October 17, 201014 yr Does anyone else find it amusing that Christina Aguilera could release a truly terrible cover (of an even worse song) and score a hit back then. She can barely get her original music into the top 40 now. My Prerogative is obviously horrific too though. I do remember loving the video back in ze day. Young and perverted. Edited October 17, 201014 yr by ▲▲▲
October 17, 201014 yr Both are crap and career lowlights What rot! Car Wash was a bit of fun - never intended to be an important release in the context of Christina's career, and it was actually a decent cover - it added a new spin to the original and Missy's presence was fun if random too. The original My Prerogative was before my time and I don't think much to it but Britney's cover is an incredibly lush and sexy song - if only the quality of her music today matched that song, back when she was relatively unpredictable and daring and not churning out poop like Womawomawoma and 3. My favourite is My Prerog though, just because Car Wash, good as it is, is nothing more than a bit of fun.
Create an account or sign in to comment