1. Rebecca Ferguson - 9.5

---------------------------------

2. Matt Cardle - 8.0

3. Mary Byrne - 8.0

4. One Direction - 7.5

---------------------------------

5. Aiden Grimshaw - 6.5

6. Cher Lloyd - 6.5

7. Paige Richardson - 6.0

8. Wagner - 5.0

9. Katie Weasle - 4.0

I think Louis loves only One Direction. :teresa:

 

What does that have to do with a sing off between Katie and Paije? :huh:

 

What does that have to do with a sing off between Katie and Paije? :huh:

 

I tried to say he doesnt love Katie. Don't you remember he criticized Katie performance tonight?

LOL at Louis' dig at Kym Marsh :lol:

Edited November 13, 201014 yr by Chriss_S

I tried to say he doesnt love Katie. Don't you remember he criticized Katie performance tonight?

 

He has also said though that he still loves her, it was this particular performance he criticized not Katie herself.

 

Besides, the judges can always be so fickle.... especially Louis. I remember the first few weeks he was very negative towards Katie saying he didn't get her....then all of a sudden he saved her in a sing off and she was the best thing since sliced bread.

 

Anyway, I don't think he loves Paije more than Katie...and that's what will matter.

Edited November 13, 201014 yr by Sabrewulf

The first half of the song = poor

The second half of the song = really good

 

I'm swaying towards those who say 'overrated' though.

 

THANK GOD THEY FINALLY LET HARRY SING.

GET OUT OF MY HEAD! :drama:

 

But seriously (Bar the first three (as I missed them)) this is my rankage of tonight's performances:

 

01. Cher (She made that WORK!) 09.5

02. 1Direction (Harry getting most of the vocal is a very pleasing surprise!) 08.5

03. Matt Cardle (He's just Bono, minus the ego...) 08.0

04. Rebecca Ferguson (BOOORING! One of the most boring songs ever for me.) 07.0

05. Katie Waissel (Katie fan, however that was NOT a good performance. Flat!) 06.0

06. Wagner (He's seriously not entertaining in the slightest!) 01.5

I haven't seen rebecca's yet as it's not been uploaded onto youtube but i'm going to assume it was once again amazing and the best of the night:

 

Rebecca

Cher

Aiden

------------

Mary

Paije

------------

Wagner

------------

Matt

One Direction

Katie

 

edit: I was right :wub:

Edited November 13, 201014 yr by 152chris

I love how Simon cant name all 5 members of One Direction when asked :lol:

I am totally bored of Rebecca its the same ole same ole every single week and im really starting to hate her,and i hate saying that as she seems like a lovely person but music wise im just tired of her now.

I've come to the conclusion that they are all $h!t.

 

Except for Rebecca and at a push Matt.

 

I do have a weird fasnication with Aiden- he's so bleeding intense and ya know that he would be a hot shag.

I've got the Take That docu in the background and its not my choosing, I'm missing all the stuff on the Xtra Factor :snif:

Here's the contestants... http://celebrity.itv.com/2010/

 

No Jedward, YET.

 

I know their not in the official line up yet- but they do always have a 'surprise guest' dont they ;) or it could just be Konnie made a blunder..again -_-

I know their not in the official line up yet- but they do always have a 'surprise guest' dont they ;) or it could just be Konnie made a blunder..again -_-

I know, thats why i put YET. ;)

 

That wouldn't surprise me... BRING BACK HOLLY. :kink:

Edited November 13, 201014 yr by Chriss_S

WOW! Loved how Katie didn't disappoint me! She was even more rubbish than she usually is (her vocal that is) she still LOOKS good though. I'd say she's safe for another week.

 

 

Vocally ... there really was only one act to write home about tonight. Rebecca.

 

Kath

I'll rank One direction based on talent...

 

01 Liam

02 Harry

03 Nameless Nobody

04 Zain

05 Niall

 

? That's Louis! He is the one I can't stop looking at! :P So definitely not a nobody!

 

Rebecca stole the show tonight just unbelievable

Cher was 100% in top 3 for best performance's loved it

Matt was abit disapointed after last week to be honest just didn't do it for me this week he's amazing tho

One Direction erm i liked it didnt love it tho but hey loads girl's love tho so there fine

 

am only naming them 4 cause tonight there the only 4 i liked :)

What a dissapointment tonight was.

I've been seriously less underwhelmed.

And Louis is seriously like an attention seeking 16 year old girl :drama:

I am totally bored of Rebecca its the same ole same ole every single week and im really starting to hate her,and i hate saying that as she seems like a lovely person but music wise im just tired of her now.

 

Well if the 'same ole' equates to flawfless vocals ... I'd rather have that than sh/te attempts from Thursday Nite 'open mic'' nites that the rest of them seem to equate to ... I'm happy. Rebecca absolutey craps on the others from a great height. Apart from Cher who was also actually ... quite good tonight.

 

As far as the others are concerned ... if Elton was watching tonight ... he'd turn in his grave.

 

Kath

? That's Louis! He is the one I can't stop looking at! :P So definitely not a nobody!

 

Ok then we'll rename him:

 

Nameless Nobody except for Mattias who can't stop looking at him.

 

We can call him NNEFMWCSLAH for short (Nef-mwac-slahh)

 

It's been cleared up now though, I heard his name being mentioned during the show, his name is Louis Walsh.

My comments for tonight:

 

Paije - I didn't enjoy it as much as last week, but he did a reasonably good job I thought. Wouldn't be surprised if he was in trouble tomorrow though.

 

Aiden - Overall, I liked it. No surprise. There were moments that I really loved, but I guess it wasn't my absolute favourite performance of his. I can't decide which of his performances is my favourite though. I want to see him win and I am doing my best to support him.

 

Mary - So much better than last week! I really enjoyed this performance. The final note was great. I'm glad her daughter came to support her this week, she said it herself that it helped her.

 

Katie - It was... kinda weird. By the end, I was quite into it though.

 

Matt - My favourite performance of his since Week 1's When Love Takes Over! I think he's the winner.

 

Cher - Quite loved it! One of my favourite performances of hers and probably my favourite performance of the night.

 

Wagner - Hmm... I quite enjoyed it actually, although the first half was probably a bit better than the second half.

 

One Direction - Last week I really enjoyed their performance. This week, I didn't enjoy it as much. I can't say it was a bad performance though.

 

Rebecca - She always delivers. Every. Single. Time. Beautiful performance.