I went for Leona.

 

Singles wise - Alexandra probably $h!ts all over her (bar 'Bleeding Love', which probably would come 2nd to ANL & Bad Boys actually!)

 

Albums wise though - Leona craps over everyone. 'Echo' and 'Spirit' are both fantastic ('Echo' is probably my favourite X Factor related album) and 'Echo' shows a lot more of Leona's personality and shows she IS capable of doing something out of her "comfort zone" with ease. Some of my favourite ever Leona songs are very different to the usual MOR ballads they usually choose to put out as singles for her. 'Naked', 'Outta My Head', 'Take A Bow' etc. She's also show on her tour, that she's more than just a "girl with a big ballad voice" and that she CAN actually put on a very good performance if she needed to.

My favourite would be Alexandra...

 

I like Leona too, but Alexandra just has more personality and excitement about her.

Joe just got his FIRST vote :o Who voted for this guy to win?

Leona. no one else comes close

It has to be Alex. She was my favourite all the way through the series :wub: she tied with Laura White for a bit.

 

 

I have recently discovered that Leona is in fact very good, however she released Bleeding Love. Which is repulsive.

I chose Leona because she was the only one on that list who I actually wanted to win in their year

Alexandra for me :)

Which 7 people voted for Steve? whilst Shayne only has 5. Wth?

No competition for me here, Leona by a mile.

 

Would never purchase any material from any of the others I'd imagine.

Alexandra all the way; Leona is better vocally but I find myself far more interested in the Burke's output. Though having said that, 'Echo' is wonderful, 'Spirit' just lets Leona down :(

Shayne Ward. He's hot :heart: [/shelli]

Leona by miles with Alex second - don't like any of the others one little bit.

 

I love Leona's voice and her music - Alex is OK but she's to R&B for my taste. Most of her output has been collaborations.

Alexandra is by far the best and most people I know agree. She can sing ballads like leona and then sing uptempo songs unlike her. She has the whole package :)

Alexandra is by far the best and most people I know agree. She can sing ballads like leona and then sing uptempo songs unlike her. She has the whole package :)

I wish people (not just you Jamelia), would stop assuming Leona can't do uptempo songs. If you actually listened to her albums, you will know they're just as good (if not better) than her ballads! It's just Syco choose to play on the fact she has a fantastic voice, so they keep forcing a ballad down our throats.

Makes me laugh when people say 'leona cant do uptempo songs' just because she hasnt released any doesnt mean she doesnt have them on her two albums. Also the next album will have more upbeat songs then the last two. ^_^

So in fact, leona does both ballads and uptempos better then alex.

(recommend watching the tour to becuase she is in fact a brilliant performer as well as phenomenal vocalist)

 

In another league, and i like alex. :)

 

This poll is a bit of a joke anyway, 7 people have voted steve brookstein so this poll represents nothing :lol:

Edited December 15, 201014 yr by Let it Snow

Makes me laugh when people say 'leona cant do uptempo songs' just because she hasnt released any doesnt mean she doesnt have them on her two albums. Also the next album will have more upbeat songs then the last two. ^_^

So in fact, leona does both ballads and uptempos better then alex.

(recommend watching the tour to becuase she is in fact a brilliant performer as well as phenomenal vocalist)

 

In another league, and i like alex. :)

 

This poll is a bit of a joke anyway, 7 people have voted steve brookstein so this poll represents nothing :lol:

 

If the Poll represents nothing why are you bothering to post.I cannot think of any of Leonas uptempo songs that are better than All Night Long or even Bad Boys so not sure how Leona is better at uptempo songs.

Let it Snow(LL1, Lovestoned, Peace,ligten-up ), seriously Let it Snow you like Alex in which parallel universe,you are clearly one of Alex's biggest haters. :rolleyes:

For me:

 

1. Leona Lewis

2. Alexandra Burke

3. Joe McElderry

4. Shayne Ward

5. Matt Cardle

6. Leon Jackson

7. Steve Brookstein

Let It Snow, while Jonjo makes the point she can sing ballads well, and is arguably correct with the likes of 'Outta My Head' helping prove his point, and you say she can perform them well on tour, a statemet I also agree with to an extent, claiming she 'does them better than Alexandra' is laughable. Her video for Forgive Me and the uptempo X Factor performances she gave show that her grasp on choreography take her as far as walking forward, backwards, left and right, and moving her hips from side to side. Compare that to even the early Alexandra X Factor showings where she is singing extremely competently and pulling off complex choreography, and it's a no brainer! I know I'm a big Alexandra fan but I would agree with most of the country that Leona is a better vocalist. I think an even more significant proportion of the country though would agree that Alexandra performs uptempos much much better. I understand you have your opinions and Leona is a GREAT popstar and ambassador but I think this is a case of rose coloured glasses!

 

On another front I'd stick up for Joe here and say he's my second or third favourite, with Leona being the other challenger.

I like how Steve is in 3rd :lol:

 

The poll results:

 

1. Alexandra

2. Leona

3. Steve :lol:

4. Shayne

5. Leon

6. Joe

 

Now that Matt has won, my list would be:

 

1. Matt

2. Alexandra

3. Shayne

4. Steve

5. Leon

6. Leona

7. Joe

Its clear this poll represents nothing, and people are not voting for the right reasons or for their favourite winner.

 

1. Matt

2. Alexandra

3. Shayne

4. Steve

5. Leon

6. Leona

7. Joe

 

WTF that is a complete joke, your music taste must be awful. (no offence intended but i think most people would agree when you list these winners in this order.) :mellow:

 

If the Poll represents nothing why are you bothering to post.I cannot think of any of Leonas uptempo songs that are better than All Night Long or even Bad Boys so not sure how Leona is better at uptempo songs.

Let it Snow(LL1, Lovestoned, Peace,ligten-up ), seriously Let it Snow you like Alex in which parallel universe,you are clearly one of Alex's biggest haters. :rolleyes:

 

Get a grip marrb please, you make yourself look ridiculous. I am not as hater of alex you loon. I wouldnt say i like her if i didnt, fact.

Do not speak to me on this forum again, i've asked you so many f***ing times do not speak to me, you have issues. :angry:

Edited December 17, 201014 yr by Let it Snow