01 Sami - Sat here with such a smile on my face, sure it's a bit copycat and karaoke, but the bottom line is - she can sing it, and she can hit the notes. There's people like Janet and Sophie with quirky voices, it's refreshing to see a normal voice, who can just.. sing. 8/10

 

See, I wish she would show that she can hit the notes more often! More high notes in that song would have been amazing. (Just as I was typing the word "amazing", Gary Barlow also said that word :P)

Nu Vibe - Better than last week, but still not good. They just don't gel and the harmonies are the definition of bland. Shame as I love Ashford. - 5.0/10.0

Sami - Started off good, was outstanding by the end. The song choice was too much of a predictable Louis song though, making her irrelevant. - 8/0/10.0

 

Rates:

Sami - 8.0

Nu Vibe - 5.0

I don't know why people like Craig.

Craig is one of the strongest contenders. He will go far. I didn't like this performance as much as last week's, but still strong!

Craig Colton - Best Thing I Never Had

 

Hmm, I will admit I'm disappointed by this performance. After nailing 'Jar Of Hearts' this seems to be missing the mark slightly. Maybe it's nerves but I reckon he could sing this better than this. :( Oh well, at least he's settled into the track more from the middle 8 bit - overall, not as strong as last week. 7/10

 

Sami Brookes = 7/10

Craig Colton = 7/10

Nu Vibe = 3/10

I don't know why people like Craig.

 

He's quite an emotional performer and it's endearing.

Don't agree witht the judges, it was a brave risk but that was a poor delivery from Craig

Craig - I still don't get him. He's good but no more than that. :(

 

Rates 2011 (week 2)

7.0 Sami Brookes - I Will Always Love You

6.5 Craig Colton - Best Thing I Never Had

1.0 Nu Vibe - With Or Without You

Craig = impressive mouth movements pretty average 6/10

Wow. That was really disappointing after last week. Deviated from the melody too much, wrong vocal style for such an urban-pop song. Bad song choice.

 

6.5 Sami

6.0 Craig

4.0 Nu Vibe

Craig... wasn't as STUNNING as last week, but still, a wonderful performance, and there's so much emotion there throughout. They are doing things absolutely right with him. Now definitely looking forward to him every week!

 

Rates

9/10 Craig

8/10 Sami

3/10 Nu Vibe

The original isn't particularly interesting but Craig sucked the little life out of it. Totally pedestrian and lacking in any sort of charisma or energy.

 

5.3

Edited October 15, 201113 yr by Phaedrus Ráðúlfr

Craig - 7.0/10

 

Ok vocals but really can't see this fat guy selling millions of downloads. Please forgive my honest opinion.

 

Craig 7.0

Sami 6.5

Nu Vibe 5.5

01 Sami - Sat here with such a smile on my face, sure it's a bit copycat and karaoke, but the bottom line is - she can sing it, and she can hit the notes. There's people like Janet and Sophie with quirky voices, it's refreshing to see a normal voice, who can just.. sing. 8/10

02 Craig - A lot weaker than last week - only the last 45 seconds did him any justice. The first verse was pretty flat, but once he gets going, he is quite good. 7/10

03 Nu Vibe - Whoever thought, let's have them sing with minimal instrumental at the start, was a good idea. It wasn't, it highlighted their flaws. You can tell they're five solo singers. Weak. 5/10

 

Craig - I love his voice, I didn't really think that performance however was anything outstanding, last week was miles better. He sung it well again, but the song just didn't suit him, and it just felt a little flat in places. - 7.0/10.0

 

Rates:

Sami - 8.0

Craig - 7.0

Nu Vibe - 5.0

Craig - Disappointed after last week, this performance just wasn't anywhere near as good as his first. I thought maybe he would challenge for the win....but now I'm wondering if he's more of a Paije than a Joe. 6.5/10

 

Craig Colton - 6.5/10

Sami Brookes - 6.5/10

Nu Vibe - 5/10

Aww Miss Janet now :heart:

Wow. That was really disappointing after last week. Deviated from the melody too much, wrong vocal style for such an urban-pop song. Bad song choice.

 

6.5 Sami

6.0 Craig

4.0 Nu Vibe

 

I agree about the song choice. Last week was so much more powerful. I still liked this week's performance, but just not as much as last week's.

It's Lena Katina from tATu!

 

Sorry, Janet.

Janet's performance was just darn pretty. It's the only way I can describe it.