That was some seriously GOOD STUFF. They didn't stray too much from the original or experiment with the harmonies much but it was by far their best vocal to date and some really impressive staging.

 

9.7 Kitty - perf of the series

8.6 Misha

8.5 Little Mix

8.2 Sophie

7.6 Marcus

7.5 Johnny

5.6 Janet

5.0 The Risk

2.0 Frankie

 

Little Mix - Enjoyed the performance a lot, I think in terms of halloween Little Mix where definitely one of the better overall performances tonight. 8.5/10

 

Misha - 9/10

Little Mix - 8.5/10

Kitty - 8.5/10

Johnny - 8/10

Sophie - 8/10

Marcus - 7/10

Janet - 6.5/10

The Risk - 2/10

Frankie - 0/10

Right.. now for the performance of the night hopefully! LOVE this song, music perfection. :heart:

'For those who think he can only sing ballads ... you're in for a shock'

 

REALLY?! He's singing an ADELE song!

I fail to see what is in any way 'fabulous' about any of these 'catchphrases'. I bet if it were someone who's not a generic black female who makes BJ-friendly music no one would think that at all. Egh.

 

Not true, I would happily use a quote from a white woman too. I'm not racist. They don't even have to be a singer.

 

I'm finding myself really looking forward to Kitty each week. I still remain slightly concerned about her attitude but it's really only remnants from that first audition but she really puts it down on stage.

 

Imma downgrade Misha a point as that is what an 11 looks like. It would be a crime for her not to make it really far, great vocals and a brilliant stage presence.

 

 

Silas Rates - Week 4

 

Kitty - 11/10

Misha - 10/10

Marcus - 10/10

Sophie - 9/10

Johnny - 8/10

The Risk - 5/10

The Dull One - 0/10

The STI Riddled Cunt - Too shit to rate.

Shock, Gary? This song isn't *that* uptempo.

Oh yeah Gary, this is so different!!

Craig - 8.0

Just expecting Adele to rise dramatically on iTunes now. It wasn't that good though. I liked his clothes, very elegant young man. :lol:

 

Kitty - 9.0

Johnny - 8.5

Little Mix - 8.5

Craig - 8.0

Sophie - 8.0

Marcus - 7.5

Janet - 7.0

Misha B - 7.0

The Risk - 5.5

Frankie - 4.0

 

Also he looks ridiculous in that coat.

Yeah yeah, another good vocal from Craig, but my God he is boring, it's the same thing week in week out. 6/10

Not true, I would happily use a quote from a white woman too. I'm not racist. They don't even have to be a singer.

 

It just seems like people on this forum EXPECT generic black female singers to be 'fabulous' and falsely proclaim everything they say to be that. Kelly saying 'put it down' got boring the second time she said it.

 

-x-

 

Easily Craig's best performance to date, his vocals sounded less annoying than usual. I do wish he would sing something slightly different though.

 

2011 rates (week 4)

9.5 Kitty Brucknell - Sweet Dreams (Are Made Of This)

8.5 Janet Devlin - Every Breath You Take

8.5 Johnny Robinson - That Ole Devil Called Love

8.0 Craig Colton - Set Fire To The Rain

7.5 Marcus Collins - Superstition

7.0 The Risk - Thriller

6.5 Misha B - Tainted Love

6.5 Little Mix - E.T.

4.5 Frankie Cocozza - Should I Stay Or Should I Go

4.0 Sophie Habibis - Bang Bang (My Baby Shot Me Down)

He BROUGHT IT the most he has since the first week. Made it look effortless. Awful styling though!!!

 

9.7 Kitty

8.6 Misha

8.5 Little Mix

8.5 Craig

8.2 Sophie

7.6 Marcus

7.5 Johnny

5.6 Janet

5.0 The Risk

2.0 Frankie

 

Well, Craig's vocals weren't as strong as they have been, but he gave a good performance and it's far from the worst on tonight, so I'll give him a 7.

 

Misha 9/10

Janet 8/10

Kitty 8/10

Craig 7/10

Little Mix 7/10

Johnny 6/10

Sophie 5/10

The Risk 5/10

Marcus 4/10

Frankie 3/10

 

Decent show tonight, nothing outstanding. I'm seeing Frankie and Sophie for bottom 2 tomorrow, realistically.

I have tweeted my displesasure at Little Mix for their sexism!

 

I thought he was doing something upbeat? That wasn't! Or is the something diffrent his hairstyle? Why does he always do a female vocal?

 

Tulisa needs to stop saying ballid!

 

Also Tyla did this better on X Factor Aus a few weeks ago!

Alex, stop trying to be Kelly.

Craig Coulton - Set Fire To The Rain

 

Once again, Craig is easily the best in the boys category. It's not quite worthy of full points but this is the best he's sang since 'Jar Of Hearts' and I really think Craig is becoming a strong contender to win The X Factor.

 

Misha B = 9/10

Craig Coulton = 9/10

Kitty Brucknell = 8/10

Marcus Collins = 8/10

Sophie Habibis = 7/10

Little Mix = 7/10

Johnny Robinson = 6/10

Janet Devlin 4/10

The Risk = 4/10

Frankie Cacossa = 3/10

Kitty - I'm not going to compare it to Rebecca's performance of it last year, as they're both very different, but I really liked it! Her best performance yet, and her vocals were at their best yet during the performance. 10/10

Marcus - One of my favourite performances from his so far! A weird song choice on first glance, but his vocals and the performance made that seem pointless. He's really coming out as one of my surprise favourites of the competition. 9/10

Little Mix - My favourite performance of theirs yet. It was the most karaoke-sounding of them though, but they performed it very well, and I quite liked the staging. 8/10

Misha - I still dislike her as a person, but that was a good performance. Not the best song choice, and the rap was very cringeworthy (like all of her self-written raps), but she did it well. 8/10

Sophie - Not her best performance, but again it was very good vocally. I was just disappointed that she didn't go into the dance breakdown of the mid-noughties remix. 7.5/10

Craig - Again, not my favourite performance of his, but it was good performance anyway. His performances are starting to blend into one, for me, though. 7.5/10

The Risk - Alright performance from them - a lot worse than last week's, but that was pretty special. I also felt the chemistry seemed to dissolve with the addition of Ashford. 7/10

Johnny - I will never like a performance of his. I dislike his singing voice, although his personality is growing on me, and vocally - it was a good performance. 5/10

Janet - Very flat performance. I really liked the arrangement, but she didn't sing it well at all. Such a let down after last week's performance, which was my favourite of hers by far. 4/10

Frankie - Abysmal. 0/10

LOL I f***ing love Alexandra! Can she not just win again please?!

 

Doug & Bray can step aside.

Craig - Strong performance but probably a tad predictable. 8/10

 

Misha - 9/10

Little Mix - 8.5/10

Kitty - 8.5/10

Johnny - 8/10

Sophie - 8/10

Craig - 8/10

Marcus - 7/10

Janet - 6.5/10

The Risk - 2/10

Frankie - 0/10

 

Hmm too many 8's around the middle :/

 

Really disappointed in Janet tonight in particular, the performance just didn't live up to the standard she has set in previous weeks.

 

Risk & Frankie for the bottom please. I'm sort of wondering if The Risk got slot one because the producers want to ditch them now that they've been messed up...

Edited October 29, 201113 yr by Sabrewulf