Louis Walsh (2004-)

Gary Barlow (2011–)

Kelly Rowland (2011–)

Tulisa Contostavlos (2011–)

Simon Cowell (2004–10)

Sharon Osbourne (2004–07)

Dannii Minogue (2007–10)

Cheryl Cole (2008–10)

Edited November 7, 201113 yr by LMFAO!

dannii, there's no doubt. she's the most balanced one out of all of them.

Cheryl = Dannii (went for Cheryl on the poll :P) >>>>> Simon >> Sharon >>>>> Kelly >>>> Louis >>>>> Tulisa >>>>>> Gary

Definitely Dannii. But only her because Natalie Imbruglia wasn't on the poll. ;)

I hate to be biased, but it has to be Cheryl. She's definitely the judge who's had the most entertainment value, in my opinion.

I went for Cheryl because she made the show more entertaining and brought something special to it... something that is missing in this years judging panel.

Queen Dannii.

Easily Dannii.

Nobody brought the CUNT factor quite like Mrs O. I genuinely miss her greatly.

Oh what the hell, here's rank with SCORES ON THE DOORS because I am so inclined:

 

10 Dannii

09 Kelly Rowland

07 Louis

06 Simon

05 Sharon

03 Chewleesahr

02 Gary

00 Cheryl

Dannii for me by far.

Dannii, for me, she was easily the most sensible and constructive judge there

Edited November 7, 201113 yr by C.W

Dannii by an absolute MILE.

Dannii was boxfresh.

 

Louis is my number two though. I love everything about him. I love it when he reverts to the IQ of a six year old and starts yelling at everybody to SHUDDUP! And I love that occasionally he comes out with a GENUINE PEARL about a contestant and you realise he might just be a bit smarter than he looks.

 

01 Louis

02 Sharon

03 Kelly

04 Cheryl

05 Gary

06 Simon

07 Dannii

08 Tulisa

01 Cheryl :wub: :wub: :wub:

 

02 Tulisa :heart:

 

03 Louis :lol:

04 Sharon :lol:

05 Kelly :lol:

 

06 Dannii :)

07 Simon :)

 

08 Gary :blink:

Edited November 9, 201113 yr by Hayzayy

For me...

 

1. Danni

---

2. Tulisa

---

3. Kelly

4. Sharon

5. Simon

---

6. Louis

7. Cheryl

8. Gary

 

Dannii, she spoke the truth, even if nobody ever listened.

 

Of the current judges;

 

1. Louis Walsh (:o)

2. Kelly Rowland

3. Tulisa

4. Gary Barlow

Dannii, she spoke the truth, even if nobody ever listened.

 

Of the current judges;

 

1. Louis Walsh (:o)

2. Kelly Rowland

3. Tulisa

4. Gary Barlow

 

I agree about Danni - although it took me a long time to actually get to like her. For all her faults - Mrs O was very entertaining and her double act with Louis was always an attraction on the show. Of the current judges:

 

1st - Louis Walsh

2nd - Tulisa

3rd - Kelly

4th - Gary

 

Gary has proven himself to be possibly the worst judge/mentor imaginable. People are bigging him up because he still has two acts left - despite the fact that Marcus and Craig would have thrived with ANY mentor - or even no mentor at all! The best performance Craig gave was when he chose his own song. It is true that I've gone off Barlow massively over the last two years (I still love TT) but I honestly did think he'd be a good judge - I'm actually GLAD that he has proven me wrong.

 

Kath

 

Kelly or Simon.