Since we weren't offered a chance to vote on this in the main thread, I thought it'd be nice to have a chance to decide.

Definitely Madonna imo. Much better discography

EASILY Madonna. Kylie is just overrated - lots of good songs admittedly but only one or two amazing ones, Madonna has tons of good ones and countless amazing ones!

Madonna has a better discography, Shakira should've been there though.

I vote for Madonna, both have great songs but Madonna's got more better songs than Kylie. With songs like "Vogue" "Hung Up" "Frozen" "Like A Prayer" etc. I have to hand it to Madonna

Obviously I voted Kylie as I'm huge Kylie fan but Madonna is legendary. As already pointed out, her back catalogue is unmatched. Never really got the "Kylie vs. Madonna you MUST choose only one to like" argument that often surrounds these two.

I don't see the point of the third option?

I don't see the point of the third option?

I think it should be renamed to "Shakira" :kink: :wub:

Me neither. Although I would like to make an official complaint to the chart mods that they allowed Gezza to take this important decision away from us. Geez, who does he think he is, god or something?

I think this just takes the fun out of the other thread what happens when its the last final 4 of the best tracks of 2011 at #1, are we getting the same treatment. Vote for a third place track.

I think this just takes the fun out of the other thread

 

Bet you still voted for Kylie, though. :P

I put other and went for Kelly Clarkson. :)

Madonna with ease, should have won the whole thing with THAT back catalogue.

I put other and went for Kelly Clarkson. :)

Shit, I totes should've done that too for the 2nd best singer of all time :( The first (Queen Carrie Underwood) was SHAMEFULLY ignored :kink:

 

Oh well, voting Madonna as she has a chance makes it less likely for Kylie to win :D

Madonna with ease, should have won the whole thing with THAT back catalogue.

 

But as the title of the competiton suggests, it's not *just* about the music - and the 'granny dressing in her teenage grand-daughters clothes' look is enough to make most people cringe. :lol:

Edited April 15, 201213 yr by vidcapper

They are both grannies but Kylie is the least granniest,so Kylie.

They are both grannies but Kylie is the least granniest,so Kylie.

 

How is Kylie even remotely granny looking.

 

People are so ageist when it comes to women in music, its pathetic.

 

Noone ever even comments on a mans age or how he looks.

Kylie for me as im a huge fan. I do see Madonna's appeal but there is only a handful of Madoona songs i can truly say i like where Kylie has loads that i love. The fact Kylie is 10 times better looking helps aswell!!

They are both grannies but Kylie is the least granniest,so Kylie.

I'd love to meet the grannies that you know :P

Madonna doesn't even qualify to be a "babe".