Posted September 30, 201212 yr Thought I'd get this started with first impressions.... :wub: 01 Ella 02 Melanie 03 Jade 04 Kye 05 Carolynne :) 06 Lucy 07 Rylan 08 MK1 09 James 10 Union J :/ 11 GMD3 :puke: 12 Jahmene I won't include the wildcards; I'll just add whoever happens to get in when they get in. Actually a pretty strong final 12 for my worries about overall quality this year! Edited September 30, 201212 yr by Liаm
September 30, 201212 yr 01. Ella Henderson (01) 02. Jade Ellis (02) 03. Kye Sones (03) 04. Carolynne Poole (04) 05. Union J (05) 06. Melanie Masson (06) 07. Jahmene Douglas (07) 08. GMD3 (08) 09. James Arthur (09) 10. MK1 (10) 11. Lucy Spraggan (11) 12. Rylan Clark (12)
September 30, 201212 yr 01. Kye Sones 02. Ella Henderson 03. Carolynne Poole 04. GMD3 05. Union J 06. Melanie Masson 07. Jade Ellis 08. James Arthur 09. MK1 10. Rylan Clark 11. Lucy Spraggan 12. Jahmene Douglas
September 30, 201212 yr 1. Ella Henderson - (1) 2. Carolynne Poole - (2) 3. GMD3 - (3) 4. Jade Ellis - (4) 5. Union J - (5) 6. Kye Sones - (6) 7. Melanie Masson - (7) 8. MK1 - (8) 9. Lucy Spraggan - (9) 10. Rylan Clark - (10) 11. James Arthur - (11) 12. Jahmene Douglas - (12) Edited September 30, 201212 yr by JosephRaeJepsen
September 30, 201212 yr 01. Carolynne Poole 02. Ella Henderson 03. Jade Ellis 04. Lucy Spraggan - 05. Kye Sones 06. Union J 07. James Arthur - 08. GMD3 09. MK1 10. Jahmene Douglas 11. Melanie Masson 12. Rylan Clark I'm sure there will be some big changes after the first live shows!
October 1, 201212 yr 01. Ella Henderson [01] 02. Jade Ellis [02] 03. Union J [03] 04. Carolynne Poole [04] 05. Melanie Masson [05] 06. Kye Sones [06] 07. GMD3 [07] 08. MK1 [08] 09. Lucy Spraggan [09] 10. Rylan Clark [10] 11. Jahmene Douglas [11] 12. James Arthur [12] I haven't liked any James Arthur performance so far, so I can only conclude that I just don't get his appeal.
October 1, 201212 yr From what little I've seen so far... 01. Carolynne Poole [01] 02. MK1 [02] 03. Jade Ellis [03] 04. Kye Sones [04] 05. Melanie Masson [05] --- (small gap) 06. Jahmene Douglas [06] 07. James Arthur [07] ---- (big gap) 08. Rylan Clark [08] 09. Ella Henderson [09] 10. Lucy Spraggan [10] ------ (bigger gap) 11. Union J [11] 12. GMD3 [12] Kinda not getting what people are seeing in Ella at this point, but at least she's less annoying than Spraggan and the awful-by-blandness boybands.
October 1, 201212 yr 01. Jade Ellis (1) 02. Union J (2) 03. Rylan Clarke (3) 04. Ella Henderson (4) 05. GMD3 (5) 06. James Arthur (6) 07. MK1 (7) 08. Lucy Spraggan (8) 09. Kye Sones (9) 10. Carolynne Poole (10) 11. Melanie Masson (11) 12. Jahmene Douglas (12) 01. Amy Mottram 02. Adam Burridge 03. Times Red 04. Sweaty Betty
October 1, 201212 yr Love doing these :kink: 01. Ella Henderson [1] 02. Union J [2] 03. Rylan Clark [3] :coffee: 04. MK1 [4] 05. Jade Ellis [5] 06. Melanie Masson [6] 07. Kye Sones [7] 08. Carolynne Poole [8] 09. Jahmene Douglas [9] 10. GMD3 [10] 11. James Arthur [11] 12. Lucy Spraggan [12]
October 2, 201212 yr The following based on Judges Houses, Bootcamp and Auditions 01. Carolynne Poole (1) 02. Jade Ellis (2) 03. Melanie Masson (3) 04. MK1 (4) 05. GMD3 (5) 06. Lucy Spraggan (6) 07. Ella Henderson (7) 08. Rylan Clark (8) 09. Kye Sones (9) 10. Union J (10) 11. James Arthur (11) 12. Jahmene Douglas (12) Edited October 2, 201212 yr by Thermometer
October 3, 201212 yr FIRST IMPRESSIONS: Great: 01. Ella Henderson --- Very Good: 02. Carolynne Poole 03. Melanie Masson --- Decent Enough: 04. GMD3 05. Jade Ellis 06. Kye Sones 07. Rylan Clark --- Highly Annoying: 08. Lucy Spraggan 09. MK1 10. Union J --- Overrated Tripe: 11. Jahmene Douglas 12. James Arthur Ella is the strongest of a very mediocre bunch. She'll just be a slightly more successful Leanne Mitchell. Carolynne has potential to go far though! She's bringing something different to the UK market and with recent successes for Lady Antebellum and Taylor Swift, currently in our charts, I think we're ready for a major country star ourselves. Melanie always surprises me! She could be a dark horse for the competition. The next 4 are decent enough, but nothing particularly special so far. Lucy and MK1, I feel the more I see both of those acts, the more tired I get of them. Especially Lucy. Union J are forgettable. Jahmene is a shrieking mess. I don't get why he's so popular, he's just a screechier Joe McElderry. James is easily my least favourite though. Horrifically overrated and I really do not see the appeal in him at all! I can't understand anything he sings. He just screams his songs for "effect" or "emotion" or whatever. Ugh.
October 3, 201212 yr Really like 01 Jade Ellis 02 Carolynne Poole 03 Union J 04 Melanie Masson 05 Jahmene Douglas Like 06 Ella Henderson 07 MK1 08 GMD3 Fun enough, but hopefully he won't last long 09 Rylan Clark Matt Cardle 2.0 and the world didn't even need the first one 10 Kye Sones Kate Nash in a wig and fat suit 11 Lucy Spraggan There are no words 12 James Arthur
October 4, 201212 yr 01 Jade Ellis 02 Ella Henderson 03 Kye Sones 04 Carolynne Poole 05 Melanie Masson 06 Union J 07 MK1 08 Rylan Clark 09 Lucy Spraggan 10 GMD3 11 Jahmene Douglas 12 James Arthur The top 3 are excellent, 4-7 are good, Rylan has a nice voice and is fun to watch when he's not talking, then from Lucy it becomes gradually more meh/annoying.
October 4, 201212 yr An X Factor 2012 smilie ranking? Here goes... 01. Carolynne Poole ( :D ) ------------------------ 02. Melanie Masson ( ^_^ ) 03. James Arthur ( ^_^ ) ------------------------ 04. Ella Henderson ( :) ) 05. Jade Ellis ( :) ) 06. Lucy Spraggan ( :) ) 07. MK1 ( :) ) ------------------------ 08. Kye Sones ( :mellow: ) ------------------------ 09. Jahmene Douglas ( -_- ) 10. Rylan Clark ( -_- ) ------------------------- 11. Union J ( :manson: ) 12. GMD3 ( :manson: ) I'll also skip the wildcard act for now but depending on who it is, they're either going to be -_- or :manson: anyways.
October 4, 201212 yr Jade Ellis is easily the most marketable I think. I'd say she'd be the most successful .... maybe Ella too, or possibly GMD3 for about one single (much like 1D).
October 5, 201212 yr 01 Carolynne Poole [1] 02 Ella Henderson [2] 03 Union J [3] 04 Jade Ellis [4] 05 Melanie Masson [5] 06 Jahmene Douglas [6] 07 Kye Sones [7] 08 James Arthur [8] 09 GMD3 [9] 10 MK1 [10] 11 Rylan Clark [11] 12 Lucy Spraggan [12]
October 6, 201212 yr 01. Carolynne Poole (1-1) 02. Melanie Masson (3-2) 03. Lucy Spraggan (6-3) 04. Ella Henderson (7-4) 05. Christopher Maloney (5) 06. James Arthur (11-6) 07. Jade Ellis (2-7) 08. Kye Sones (9-8) 09. MK1 (4-9) 10. Rylan Clark (8-10) 11. Jahmene Douglas (12-11) 12. Union J (10-12) 13. District3 (5-13) Who I'd like in the bottom two: Union J District3 Who I think will be bottom two: District3 MK1
October 6, 201212 yr http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/NewRight-1.png 1. Ella Henderson - (1-1) http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/NewRight-1.png 2. Carolynne Poole - (2-2) http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/NewRight-1.png 3. District3 - (3-3) http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/NewRight-1.png 4. Jade Ellis - (4-4) http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/NewUp.png 5. Melanie Masson - (7-5) http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/NewDown.png 6. Union J - (5-6) http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/NewDown.png 7. Kye Sones - (6-7) http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/NewUp.png 8. Lucy Spraggan - (9-8) http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/NewDown.png 9. MK1 - (8-9) http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/NewUp.png 10. James Arthur - (11-10) http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/NewDown.png 11. Rylan Clark - (10-11) http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/NewNE.png 12. Christopher Maloney - (12) http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/NewDown.png 13. Jahmene Douglas - (12-13) (underline = last)
October 6, 201212 yr Week One 1. Ella Henderson 2. Melanie Masson 3. Jade Ellis 4. Kye Sones 5. Jahmene Douglas 6. MK1 7. Lucy Spraggan 8. Union J 9. District 3 10. Christopher Maloney 11. Carolynn Poole 12. Rylan Clark 13. James Arthur
October 6, 201212 yr Week 1: 01. Jade Ellis [5-1] 02. MK1 [4-2] 03. Ella Henderson [1-3] 04. Rylan Clark [3-4] 05. Kye Sones [7-5] 06. Union J [2-6] 07. Carolynne Poole [8-7] 08. Jahmene Douglas [9-8] 09. Melanie Masson [6-9] 10. James Arthur [11-10] 11. GMD3 [10-11] 12. Lucy Spraggan [12-12] 13. Christopher Baloney [13] I am fully aware that my top 2 could be the bottom 2 tomorrow :cry:
Create an account or sign in to comment