Jump to content

Featured Replies

This is really poor to be honest. I expected it to be a big ballad which could easily sell over 100k not a dull slow Ed Sheeran song like this! This will hardly sell 80k.
  • Replies 82
  • Views 10k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

What a lovely little song. It's a bit dull compared to what we're used to hearing from them but I think it's really sweet and it's definitely got the "aww" factor which can transcend the tweeny target audience if done properly. I'd compare it to 'Stickwitu' in that they're both soppy ballads from 'uncool' bands and Stickwitu was a SMASH (catchier too yes, but shush). I dislike Ed Sheeran but I think after a minute or so it's easy to forget it's an Ed Sheeran song.

 

I was expecting to like it anyway tbh after all of the negativity in this thread (because Buzzjack is ALWAYS OTT with these things). A Louis verse is welcomed too because it means we'll get more of him in the video.

I think the message to this song is a bit clunky and not very well executed. I completely understand what they're going for, but I feel they've missed the mark with some terrible choice lyrics. Especially "You still have to squeeze into your jeans, but you’re perfect to me." I wouldn't say that was particularly liberating, more that they're highlighting particular insecurities and saying "well yes you're right about the way you perceive yourself, but don't worry because I still love you in spite of these flaws".

 

Maybe I've misinterpreted it, but it all seems quite insincere.

It's not a hit but 1D fans are gonna love it cos it's romantic. Very surprising that they're not going for radio friendly songs with all the momentum and massive team behind them. Ed Sheeran b sides? Ok then.
This is growing on me the more I hear it. I am really impressed with how mature it is for them! The video does it's job and is actually a pretty nice and simple video.
  • Author
Yeah I love the simplicity of the video and how sweet it is, the black & white effect suits it too. Absolutely love the song now, moreso than 'Live While We're Young' and it's a great contrast. Hopefully it can be a bigger hit overall.

I like it WAY more than Live While We're Young, which was a massively uninspired lead single (though very catchy). This is a great winter song and far stronger than Gotta Be You. The video's nice enough. 1D singles rank;

 

lllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll What Makes You Beautiful

lllllllllllllllllllllllll One Thing

llllllllllllllllllllll Little Things

lllllllll Live While We're Young

llll (More Than This)

ll Gotta Be You

Well, this is bloody ATROCIOUS?! not even lying, Its not only massively cringeworthy, but a little bit patronising as well. Ed Sheeran's songs look extremely tame compared this.

 

So many terrible lyrics, I think these take the biscuit:

 

You can't go to bed without a cup of tea

maybe that's the reason that you talk in your sleep

you've never loved your stomach or your thighs

the dimples in your back at the bottom of your spine

 

Yeah, sorry, I've got nothing positive to say about this at ALL and I'm far from a h8r of their's.

Single rank:

 

01 What Makes You Beautiful

02 More Than This

03 One Thing

04 Live While We're Young

05 Gotta Be You

06 Little Things

 

I have decided Little Things is my least favourite song they've done thus far.

  • Author

01 What Makes You Beautiful

02 One Thing

03 Little Things

04 Live While We're Young

-big jump-

05 Gotta Be You

(06 More Than This)

01. "Live While We're Young"

02. "What Makes You Beautiful"

03. "One Thing"

04. "Gotta Be You"

05. "Little Things" (so poor)

 

Disappointing single choice, I've not yet seen the video to boost it up in my estimations due to their attractiveness in it though (Niall + Louis in LWWY :wub:).

There seems to be a whole cult of fans filming 'reaction videos' on YouTube. Think I can safely say this one which cropped up on my Facebook feed the other day is the most downright hilarious/batshit crazy one I've seen, you almost wonder if she's taking the mick!

 

01. What Makes You Beautiful

02. One Thing

03. Gotta Be You

----------------------------------

04. Live While We're Young

----------------------------------

05. Little Things

 

 

 

So yeah, basically I'm very disappointed with their second album so far.

Edited by øbscure

I'm really loving 'Little Things' at the moment, I think it's actually my favourite from them! It's just so simple and lovely.

 

01. 'Little Things'

02. 'More Than This'

03. 'Live While We're Young'

---

04. 'What Makes You Beautiful'

05. 'One Thing'

---

06. 'Gotta Be You'

I hope you know who GloZell is!

 

Not being particularly au fait with American culture I can't say I have...

Glozell >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.