Well since you all know what it is :/ I had no idea how big these artists were until someone mentioned it after i sent for confirmation. Like literally.

Don't you check to see if your entries have been sent before in the Songs of thread?

If it was as veto-worthy as people say it is then it would've been vetoed (if it's the song I think it does get over 14 veto points so would have been discussed by moderators) so don't worry, I'm sure it's not that bad!

Don't you check to see if your entries have been sent before in the Songs of thread?

 

I usually do, but I liked this so much when I heard it and didn't think to check this time around. And then someone was like oh they finished top 5 in a previous contest and then I was just hoping it didn't get vetoed.

If it was as veto-worthy as people say it is then it would've been vetoed (if it's the song I think it does get over 14 veto points so would have been discussed by moderators) so don't worry, I'm sure it's not that bad!

 

I think it got 19 points?? If I did my personal chart still it would have got 22 points and would have been automatically vetoed. If it hasn't Jamvale are very lucky! :lol:

I agree it's v. cheap but it would be great to see James finally have a BJSC hit and the song is amazing so I'm hoping that it doesn't get vetoed :( although I think it will considering loads of people on Buzzjack know the song now partly thanks to your hyping :P

I think it got 15 veto points (12 for being an artist who had previously finished top five and 3 for being in two personal charts) from what I can calculate but I may have missed something out, but at the end of the day it got more than 14 points so the moderators would've decided against it if it was such a 'bad' entry.

 

Although it has charted top 100 in Germany but only at #59 so I'm not sure if that has been counted as it is so low. Obviously not as otherwise that would be 22 points I think like you say!

The final list has been approved now (unless Yu lied to me) so it hasn't been vetoed ~

 

I don't necessarily think it's a veto worthy song but it is a little uninspired - I'm also not a fan of it at all but I kinda hope it does well as you are well overdue a hit now. (might grow on me anyway)

I think it got 15 veto points (12 for being an artist who had previously finished top five and 3 for being in two personal charts) from what I can calculate but I may have missed something out, but at the end of the day it got more than 14 points so the moderators would've decided against it if it was such a 'bad' entry.

 

Although it has charted top 100 in Germany but only at #59 so I'm not sure if that has been counted as it is so low. Obviously not as otherwise that would be 22 points I think like you say!

 

I included "The song/artist has charted, within the past 12 months, in one of the following nations: United States, Norway, Sweden, Denmark, Australia, New Zealand, Canada, France & Germany" as their album has gone top 5 in US and Canada in April.

 

Anyway yeah I agree that if they thought it should have been vetoed it would have been.

I really don't wanna be a cheap HO :(

 

And i really am oblivious to either artist cause this is the first time I've heard of either artist.

 

Back to my usual CRAP next month then. :P

okay that was mean soray

(I don't even know what his entry is)

Atleast someone doesn't :kink:

Back to my usual CRAP next month then. :P

 

No! :hitler:

Plus look on the bright side - this ~controversy~ is getting yo thread majah pageviews and non-you posts *. Jamvale never been more relevant.

I included "The song/artist has charted, within the past 12 months, in one of the following nations: United States, Norway, Sweden, Denmark, Australia, New Zealand, Canada, France & Germany" as their album has gone top 5 in US and Canada in April.

 

Anyway yeah I agree that if they thought it should have been vetoed it would have been.

 

Ah good point, I didn't think about album charts - not sure whether they are considered or not.

 

 

It did have enough points to veto it but was not deemed veto worthy. Me and Iz were alone, luckily for you!

Ah good point, I didn't think about album charts - not sure whether they are considered or not.

It's a grey area. One that is being clarified this week.

I agree it's v. cheap but it would be great to see James finally have a BJSC hit and the song is amazing so I'm hoping that it doesn't get vetoed :( although I think it will considering loads of people on Buzzjack know the song now partly thanks to your hyping :P

 

That's precisely (one of the reasons, I also thought it was too exposed with 10 million views and her previous performance) why I wanted it vetoed. :( No offence James and I love that you're a fan of the song but this makes it difficult for me to sort my votes as all the other songs are competing against the 'potential best song of the year'.

That's precisely (one of the reasons, I also thought it was too exposed with 10 million views) why I wanted it vetoed. :( No offence James and I love that you're a fan of the song but this makes it difficult for me to sort my votes as all the other songs are competing against the 'potential best song of the year'.

 

No I'm not taking offence and can I also say I'd already decided this as my entry when I saw it in your chart or I wouldn't have considered it before hand.