Based on FIRST LISTEN

 

09 | Aura

08 | Venus

10 | G.U.Y.

10 | Sexx Dreams

10 | Jewels N Drugs

09 | Manicure

11 | Do What U Want

10 | Artpop

02 | Swine

06 | Donatella

08 | Fashion

09 | Mary Jane Holland

09 | Dope

10 | Gypsy

09 | Applause

Edited November 2, 201311 yr by HausofVenus

I know it's IMMENSELY LOONY but there we go

02 | Swine

SRSLY.

 

(will post mine soon x)

It is open now again everyone, so please don't feel put off to do it (not that Bal intended to do that) after you've listened to the album. We can compare it a month from now with another rate if that's okay with everyone.

Edited November 2, 201311 yr by Tommy Gagz

Purely based on first listen

 

10 | Aura

09 | Venus

09 | G.U.Y.

10 | Sexxx Dreams

09 | Jewels N Drugs

07 | Manicure

02 | Do What U Want

03 | Artpop

07 | Swine

07 | Donatella

03 | Fashion

07 | Mary Jane Holland

08 | Dope

06 | Gypsy

04 | Applause

 

GAWD. Starts off very strong but DOWATCHAWANT ruins it all and it's all almost shit from that point on.

 

NEW SWINE IS NOT GOOD.

FIRST LISTEN

 

10 | Aura

08 | Venus

09 | G.U.Y.

11 | Sexxx Dreams

08 | Jewels N Drugs

06 | MANiCURE

10 | Do What U Want

08 | ARTPOP

09 | Swine

09 | Donatella

04 | Fashion

09 | Mary Jane Holland

06 | Dope

09 | Gypsy

07 | Applause

 

Can't really have a 10/10 song on first listen, most of the 9's will grow into them though.

06 | Aura

07 | Venus

10 | G.U.Y.

11 | Sexxx Dreams

10 | Jewels N Drugs

08 | MANiCURE

10 | Do What U Want

10 | ARTPOP

06 | Swine

08 | Donatella

06 | Fashion

10 | Mary Jane Holland

07 | Dope

10 | Gypsy

08 | Applause

 

So much better than BTW for me. That album was half amazing half shite, whereas this is FAR more consistent. I might've been a bit generous with the 10s but they're all so good. :(

Very disappointing.

 

09.5 Aura

07.0 Venus

07.0 G.U.Y.

07.5 Sexxx Dreams

03.0 Jewels n Drugs

07.5 Manicure

09.0 Do What U Want

08.5 Artpop

05.0 Swine

08.5 Donatella

07.0 Fashion!

04.5 Mary Jane Holland

07.0 Dope

11.0 Gypsy

10.0 Applause

 

Bad production/songwriting/mastering littered throughout this album. It's such a mess. That said it will make a decent 6 or 7 track EP, and Gypsy is utterly life changing. That's the real Gaga and it will absolutely slay as a single.

08 | Aura

09 | Venus

10 | G.U.Y

09 | Sexxx Dreams

02 | Jewels n' Drugs

08 | MANiCURE

11 | Do What U Want

06 | ARTPOP

09 | Swine

08 | Donatella

09 | Fashion!

09 | Mary Jane Holland

09 | Dope

10 | Gypsy

04 | Applause

06 | Aura

09 | Venus

10 | G.U.Y.

07 | Sexxx Dreams

07 | Jewels N Drugs

07 | MANiCURE

10 | Do What U Want

10 | ARTPOP

07 | Swine

10 | Donatella

06 | Fashion

09 | Mary Jane Holland

05 | Dope

08 | Gypsy

09 | Applause

First impressions can be wrong so let me tell you what's goin' on, baby she's not who you think she is. Heeeey! Not such an innocent, she's not such an innocent girl.

08 | Aura

06 | Venus

06 | G.U.Y.

08 | Sexxx Dreams

03 | Jewels N Drugs

05 | Manicure

06 | Do What U Want

05 | Artpop

06 | Swine

04 | Donatella

02 | Fashion

05 | Mary Jane Holland

07 | Dope

09 | Gypsy

07 | Applause

 

A big step backwards from Born This Way as far as I'm concerned. The 5s and below are all ones that I can't really recall a thing about immediately after the track has finished playing... it's all over the place in terms of structure but at the same time manages to almost be boring due to there being precious little difference between the stylings of the songs. Maybe it will grow.

05 | Aura

06 | Venus

08 | G.U.Y.

06 | Sexxx Dreams

00 | Jewels N Drugs

07 | Manicure

09 | Do What U Want

09 | Artpop

03 | Swine

05 | Donatella

04 | Fashion

08 | Mary Jane Holland

05 | Dope

08 | Gypsy

08 | Applause

 

Much better than BTW, though the average score works out similarly it's actually got 5/6 very good songs on it versus two from that one.

09 | Aura

10 | Venus

09 | G.U.Y.

08 | Sexx Dreams

09 | Jewels N Drugs

09 | Manicure

09 | Do What U Want

09 | Artpop

04 | Swine

03 | Donatella

08 | Fashion

08 | Mary Jane Holland

09 | Dope

10 | Gypsy

10 | Applause

Why are people giving Venus 10s? It is her first -1 moment, absolutely unlistenable.

 

I haven't listened to the album yet, will rate it when I get the chance, replete with that -1

07 | Aura

00 | Venus

09 | G.U.Y.

10 | Sexx Dreams

03 | Jewels N Drugs

09 | Manicure

09 | Do What U Want

09 | Artpop

04 | Swine

08 | Donatella

08 | Fashion

06 | Mary Jane Holland

09 | Dope

09 | Gypsy

10 | Applause

 

I've reordered it and deemed the following the album I'm BROADLY COOL WITH

 

01. MANiCURE

02. Sexxx Dreams

03. Artpop

04. G.U.Y.

05. Do What U Want

06. Aura

07. Applause

08. Donatella

09. Fashion!

10. Dope

11. Gypsy

Edited November 3, 201311 yr by Cassandra

06 | Aura - The pitched version sounds better to me now. I'm probably just bored of it after three months

07 | Venus - I only just GOT this a few days ago, not AS BAD as others have been saying.

09 | G.U.Y.

10 | Sexx Dreams

02 | Jewels N Drugs - Lets face it, it's a T.I song with GaGa on the chorus

07 | Manicure

10 | Do What U Want

10 | Artpop

04 | Swine

07 | Donatella

02 | Fashion

09 | Mary Jane Holland

00 | Dope - TURD

11 | Gypsy -

09 | Applause

 

In conclusion, too much filler and goes on for too long. An 11 tracker like this would've been a SUPERB album:

 

1. Applause

2. Aura

3. G.U.Y

4. Sexxx Dreams

5. Do What U Want

6. Mary Jane Holland

7. ARTPOP

8. MANiCURE

9. Donatella

10. Venus

11. Gypsy

 

NOW THAT^^ is an album that would be woth the hype!

...and Gypsy is utterly life changing. That's the real Gaga and it will absolutely slay as a single.

There's the RedOne melodic hand at play

So this is a bit of a mess, eh?

 

08 Aura

06 Venus

05 G.U.Y.

08 Sexx Dreams

01 Jewels N Drugs

03 Manicure

09 Do What U Want

09 Artpop

04 Swine

03 Donatella

02 Fashion

04 Mary Jane Holland

02 Dope

05 Gypsy

06 Applause

 

07 / Aura

10 / Venus Based on initial release. (10)

08 / G.U.Y.

08 / Sexxx Dreams

07 / Jewels N Drugs

06 / MANiCURE

07 / Do What U Want Based on initial release. (10)

08 / ARTPOP

11 / Swine

09 / Donatella

08 / Fashion

07 / Mary Jane Holland

03 / Dope

09 / Gypsy

10 / Applause Based on initial release. (06)

 

"Wanna Be With U" was sorta butchered. "Deauwp".