No. :P admittedly it has been growing on me when I've been listening to Take Me Home, but it's definitely one of the weakest in the whole of their discography. :kink:

 

I CAN'T

36. Na Na Na - 7.577 (highest: 10.0 - Calum, lowest: 5.0 - Lukuzz)
37. Through the Dark - 7.571 (highest: 10.0 - mango, lowest: 3.5 - LoveKiller)
38. Change My Mind - 7.433 (highest: 9.5 - Calum, lowest: 5.0 - Giselle)
39. Little Things - 7.412 (highest: 10.0 - Rossco, Jáhq, lowest: 0 - Johnkm)
40. I Wish - 7.400 (highest: 9.0 - Calum, n4yr, lowest: 4.5 - Jáhq)

http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m7w7hfIzSN1rcx5qdo1_500.gif

We reach the first major travesty of these results. Thanks to John, 'Little Things' drops out far earlier than anticipated. It's by no means one of their best songs, but of course Zayn makes it as beautiful as it is (with a little help from Harry and one of Niall's best solos (probably his only good one :kink:)). The ballads on both 'Up All Night' and 'Midnight Memories' (as well as 'They Don't Know About Us', 'Change My Mind' and 'Summer Love' on 'Take Me Home') are far superior. Speaking of 'Change My Mind', devastated to announce, it is also here. A beautiful song that is, in my opinion, driven by Zayn's beautiful and gorgeous vocals. Not quite up there with the rest of the album, but fabulous nonetheless.
'Through the Dark' remains the only weakling on 'Midnight Memories' for me - not one of their best at all, and the random performance of it on Saturday Night Live (it was that, wasn't it?) didn't help me love it any more. The obvious major travesty in this section however, failing to make the top 30, is 'Na Na Na' - the b-side to the boys' début single 'What Makes You Beautiful'. Should have been included on the main album, I reckon. Such a fantastic song and definitely miles ahead of some of the other drivel on 'Up All Night'. :lol:

The travesty is 'Na Na Na' getting as high as it has and beating out 'Little Things' in the process. :cry:

I'd have thought 'Little Things' would easily have sneaked into the top 20, but I guess it's just too boring for some people. :(

I'd have thought 'Little Things' would easily have sneaked into the top 20, but I guess it's just too boring for some people. :(

 

And the lyrics are way cringe.

And the lyrics are way cringe.

Indeed. Louis' lines in particular :lol: (at least they went to the weakest singer :kink:)

Louis' lyrics are the only ones I find quite jarring, but otherwise it's a lovely song. :wub: Should be a lot higher.

Even if the rest of the song was crap, Niall's verse would more than make up for it. My individual favourite part of any 1D track. :wub:

What happened to the rest of the results?

Coming soon. Kinda been busy with other things ~

31. Back For You - 7.667 (highest: 9.5 - Joseph, Rossco, Calum, lowest: 4.5 - AdamAloud)
32. Does He Know? - 7.667 (highest: 10.0 - Calum, lowest: 5.5 - Giselle)
33. Save You Tonight - 7.633 (highest: 10.0 - Gary, mango, lowest: 4.5 - Jáhq)
34. Heart Attack - 7.633 (highest: 10.0 - Calum, lowest: 3.0 - Giselle)
35. Over Again - 7.600 (highest: 10.0 - Joseph, Rossco, Cal Christopher, lowest: 3.0 - Giselle)

http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_md0uojl21V1rif8vxo1_500.gif

This section is diabolical - four beyond AMAZING songs (+ 'Save You Tonight' sandwiched between them; how it managed to place above 'Heart Attack' and 'Over Again', aka. two of 1D's best songs, I do not know). Starting at the bottom [/drake], 'Over Again' is a beautiful ballad, probably more a Liam song than anything else, but being as biased as I am, Zayn really shines through on this and makes it sound fantastic (as does Harry)! 'Heart Attack' is just the perfect, catchy pop song that fits in perfectly on both 'Take Me Home' and among their stellar discography. Hopefully it goes down as one of those songs they continue to perform live; not just an album track from a past album that is forgotten when they've moved on to another.
Ignoring 'Save You Tonight' (because there's not really much to say about it, I don't think - reflective in Jáhq's score :kink:), 'Does He Know?' is one of the best songs on 'Midnight Memories' and is basically 'I Would' part 2. It fits in perfectly with the whole mood of the album, and is by far the best deluxe track (although both 'Alive and 'Half a Heart' are amazing and beautiful, respectively). And finally, 'Back For You' - a definite highlight from 'Take Me Home' just misses out on a spot in the top 30 (boo!). Listening to it just now and remembering how FANTASTIC it is, and Zayn's solo towards the end of the song just completes it and makes it as beautiful as it is!

Over Again is absolutely stunning. Best non-single on Take Me Home. WHERE IS THE LOVE PEOPLE? :(

 

No Save You Tonight shade either please Calum x

'Save You Tonight' :wub:

Save you Tonight way too low . Buzzjack you disappoint me.

I think I was a tad generous on "Save You Tonight" actually. It's so completely BLEH, skip it every time.

Any chance of some more results soon? I regret not giving 'Live While We're Young' a 10 and need to know if I've ballsed up its chances of doing well.

26. Stand Up - 7.885 (highest: 9.5 - Jáhq, Calum, lowest: 5.0 - Giselle)
27. Right Now - 7.867 (highest: 10.0 - Calum, lowest: 5.0 - AdamAloud)
28. Tell Me a Lie - 7.833 (highest: 10.0 - Rossco, Johnkm, n4yr, lowest: 5.0 - Giselle)
29. Summer Love - 7.800 (highest: 10.0 - Rossco, Mango, lowest: 4.0 - AdamAloud)
30. Better Than Words - 7.750 (highest: 9.5 - Cal Christopher, lowest: 6.0 - Giselle, Gary)



So at #30 we have the final track on the standard Midnight Memories. Better Than Words is a pretty nice track, not the best on the album but not the worst. A nice album closer, once again ending on a different type of track after having a dance track in the form of Stole My Heart, and a ballad in the form of Summer Love, which is at #29. Summer Love is one of my favourites on Take Me Home definitely. Even MORE proof that they can do ballads about 10000x better than Gotta Be You. Tell Me a Lie is next, nothing much to say here, probably too high, just album filler for me, as is Right Now at #27. Don't really get the love for this even if it's *nice*. Stand Up is at #26, better than Tell Me a Lie at least so I wish it made the main Up All Night album :kink:

Edited February 9, 201411 yr by JosephStyles

'Better Than Words' has really grown on me since the album release so I'm glad it's quite high up.

'Right Now' is beautiful in every way :wub: Deserves to be higher! 'Better Than Words', much like Adam, has grown on me a lot since first listening to the album as well!

No major upsets yet and the three horrendous singles out :cheer:

 

Wasn't tracking the votes in the other thread but PRAYING 'You & I' storms it.

 

(now hurry up x)