She's the most talented in the group. She IS the group. Sort of like Esther was in Eternal.

She's the most talented in the group. She IS the group. Sort of like Esther was in Eternal.

 

You can’t be serious? She is in no way the most talented. Her voice is the weakest by some margin. Having voices like Perries and Jades in the group make it clear Jesy is not the most talented.

You can’t be serious? She is in no way the most talented. Her voice is the weakest by some margin. Having voices like Perries and Jades in the group make it clear Jesy is not the most talented.

Jesy is the strongest performer and best personality. I agree she’s not THE best in the group, but also from a technique stand point she’s a better vocalist than Leigh.

Leigh Anne’s vocals are sublime

Jesy is the strongest performer and best personality. I agree she’s not THE best in the group, but also from a technique stand point she’s a better vocalist than Leigh.

 

I’d have to disagree on both points about performance and technique tbh but that’s what life’s about, everyone is appreciative of something different which keeps it interesting.

Leigh Anne’s vocals are sublime

 

Leigh Anne is actually my favourite :cheeseblock:

You can’t be serious? She is in no way the most talented. Her voice is the weakest by some margin. Having voices like Perries and Jades in the group make it clear Jesy is not the most talented.

Perrie? All she does is yell!!

Perrie? All she does is yell!!

 

Sure Jan

Jesy is the strongest performer and best personality. I agree she’s not THE best in the group, but also from a technique stand point she’s a better vocalist than Leigh.

Exactly. I'm not a common visitor to Buzzjack, much less this forum, but was worried when I heard about Jesy. Mind you, any of the other 3 and I wouldn't have cared. But Jesy, to me has defined the essence of LM. She comes across as humble, fiesty and a very talented singer overall. If she quits (and I really pray she doesn't), LM will dissolve right there. Any of the other 3 quit, and LM will be just fine - like Sugababes, they'll find a replacement.

like Sugababes, they'll find a replacement.

 

It's as if you don't know them at all. I don't see them even sniffing the idea of a replacement personally. Why are we even going there?

 

Regardless of who is the strongest/weakest vocally (and they're all on a similar level imo), I agree it would be a lot harder for LM to work as a three, also because having three instead of four is such a different vibe for a group if that makes sense? 5 to 4 can work, but yeah it would be muy dificil.

In terms of voice, my rank is;

 

1. Perrie

2. Jesy

3. Jade

4. Leigh-Anne

 

They’re all extremely talented though!!

 

all 10s

 

but

 

jade

leigh anne

jesy

perrie

Perrie

 

 

 

Jade

Leigh-Anne

Jesy

Jade

Leigh-Anne

Perrie

Jesy

 

 

Perrie can overdo it sometimes. She’s probably the best technical singer of them all but I like Jade and Leigh-Anne’s voices more.

Personally I think Jesy has the most interesting tone.

 

The group would miss her voice big time on an album without her.

In terms of voice, my rank is;

 

1. Perrie

2. Jesy

3. Jade

4. Leigh-Anne

 

They’re all extremely talented though!!

 

Interesting. Here's my rank:

1. Jesy

 

 

<huge gap>

 

 

2. Jade

3. Leigh-Anne

4. Perrie

 

Perrie to me is the weakest link, and by far, the most generic. She's, dare I say, a mini Ella Henderson that relies too much on screaming and crying her lungs out instead of actually singing.

 

Personally I think Jesy has the most interesting tone.

 

The group would miss her voice big time on an album without her.

Agree! I love Jesy, she's the DNA of this band.

All 4 are essential to me

Perrie to me is the weakest link, and by far, the most generic. She's, dare I say, a mini Ella Henderson that relies too much on screaming and crying her lungs out instead of actually singing.

It's so unfair and predictable to label female singers 'screamers' just because they can belt and hit high, powerful notes. :mellow: