June 30, 201411 yr So glad Issues went top 50, it deserves it. It was never harshly criticized on the Sats forum until recent. Must be hated by all the new members :lol: I love the video for Change :wub: Edited June 30, 201411 yr by Cameron
June 30, 201411 yr 'Denial' should definitely be a bit higher. I feel it's one of very few songs where the third line-up really got it spot on in terms of what their sound should have been like. 'Change' is nice enough, but is pretty forgettable in the long run. I adore 'Notorious', but I completely understand why it can be quite divisive. I think it probably succeeds in what it's doing in a way poor brave 'Gentleman' never quite managed. Love the painfully middle class Mollie singing the 'I'm a gangster on the dancefloor' line though. I don't really tend to listen to 'Issues' that often, but it does the job well, and it has a charming simplistic quality to it I guess. 'Rock Steady' should be much higher. I know the album and the rest of the campaign flopped miserably, but that is how you do a comeback single.
June 30, 201411 yr The remaining number of singles for each band in the top 40 are: All Saints - 3 of 11 remaining Spice Girls - 8 of 13 remaning Sugababes - 10 of 28 remaining Girls Aloud - 11 of 23 remaining The Saturdays - 6 of 17 remaning Little Mix - 2 of 9 remaining Are there any singles that you can't believe have made it into the top 40? What are the must haves for the top 10? To put it in perspective All Saints - 27.3% of their songs left Spice Girls - 31.6% of their songs left Sugababes - 35.7% of their songs left Girls Aloud - 47.8% of their songs left The Saturdays - 35.3% of their songs left Little Mix - 22.2% of their songs left
June 30, 201411 yr Author 40. RED DRESS / Sugababes 7.69 6LPqkAyICO8 10 Insomnio, Regina, Nick F1, NiallMinogue, JosephStyles, JSG, Liam, Rob S, Ultraviolence, Jade, n4yr, Lukuzz, Jack, Jsilv, Jay, Juliano 9.5 Jonjo, Stuart25 --- 1 Eyes, Dane 0 GRIFF 39. WHO DO YOU THINK YOU ARE / Spice Girls 7.75 UMniB-HGpfE 10 152chris, Insomnio, Rabbit Heart, troylovesmusic, Leonardo, Nick F1, AdamAloud, NiallMinogue, April, pippa, Michael!, Jay, Doug 9 HausofKubrick, Chez Wombat, JosephStyles, Liam, Rob S, Stuart25, Lukuzz, AaronTM, LaLa2586 --- 2 JoeP -1 Cameron Into the top 40 and Sugababes 3.0 lose 'Red Dress' meaning they only have one song left in. The first single to feature Amelle and for me it's one of those songs that's you don't think of as a favourite but when you listen back it really is fantastic. A bit of a shock for me as at 39 Spice Girls lose 'Who Do You Think You Are'. An absolute classic, who could forget that Brits performance or the iconic Sugar Lumps music video?
June 30, 201411 yr To put it in perspective All Saints - 27.3% of their songs left Spice Girls - 31.6% of their songs left Sugababes - 35.7% of their songs left Girls Aloud - 47.8% of their songs left The Saturdays - 35.3% of their songs left Little Mix - 22.2% of their songs left Spice Girls have 61.5% of their songs left! Check yo shade maths again http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/cat_zpsa5a1f50a.png
June 30, 201411 yr Going through this thread is reminding me how superb Sugababes are. Disappointed at how badly Little Mix are doing, 'Wings' missing top 50 is ridiculous.
June 30, 201411 yr 'Notorious' is dreadful. Never understood the love for it. http://31.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_llsbysM1zi1qh3qcmo1_r2_500.gif ~ We've lost two fantastic songs there. :( 'Red Dress' is one of my absolute favourite Sugababes singles. Funnily enough I never much cared for the Mutya version when the album came out, but Amelle really lifted that track to greater heights. 'Who Do You Think You Are' is superb. :wub: Most iconic girl group performance ever: VnTRYWC_Zqc
June 30, 201411 yr Author 38. DISCO LOVE / The Saturdays 7.75 LmncQGy_7Lk 11 Nick F1 10 Martyn, Jahq, AdamAloud, Wallzus, JoeP, TheSatsLadyGaga, NiallMinogue, missingyou, JSG, Liam, Rob S, Calum Hood, pippa, CallumC97, DionTheSats123, Juliano, AaronTM, LaLa2586 --- 2 152chris 0 RabbitFurCoat, Michael!, Dandy 37. OVERLOAD / Sugababes 7.76 5dMNhXQMlHw 11 kellyannmarie, JoeP, DoggySwami, AaronTM 10 152chris, troylovesmusic, NiallMinogue, JSG, Liam, Jade, n4yr --- 3 Wallzus 0 Alex BABY BABY BABY. One of The Saturdays finest selection 'Disco Love' drops out at 38. I'd have loved this to have been higher, but who care when it's Donna Summer all year long? *.* Sugababes 1.0 are the next line-up to have all of their singles out, as debut 'Overload' is at 37. I was never mad on this at the time and I'm still not, it's certainly not the pinnacle of girl band music some people make it out to be.
June 30, 201411 yr I like "Girls" and I don't think that it deserved to be at the bottom of the list. It was one of my most airplay songs in 2008. I don't give emphasis to the lyrics though.. :P "Freedom" should be a mega hit for them but it seems that nobody loves it here (apart from a few exceptions). "Chick Fit" should be at the bottom of the list. It's very average song from a decent girl group! "No Can Do is not better though. I love "Soul Sound" and I don't get the hate about it. "Gentleman" has nice rhythm but the lyris are the worst for a girl group. I can't imagine someone to sing this song. "I Think We're Alone" is not a bad cover but we have to admit that Tiffany's version is much better than it. "Lady Marmelade" is too low in this rate!! I thought that "Holler would be much higher than this position (No.80). It's very catchy song. "Follow Me Home" is not bad but it's not something special too. It should be an album filler for them. "Beautiful Cause You Love Me" should be their lowest song in this rate. I couldn't imagine that they released this song after the exciting "Something New". "Wear My Kiss" is not bad bit it's so forgettable! "Long Hot Summer" was my most airplay song in 2005! "How 'Ya Doin? is my least favourite Little Mix song. "30 Days" is one my least favourite songs in this rate but "Forever Is Over" is one of my favourites! The Promise" is not overrated song. It deserves to be their second successful song in their discography! It's one of the best well-written songs for a girl group. "Missing You" should be higher than "Work". "Can't Speak French" was my most airplay song in 2008. The rhythm and the way of their singing are so addictive! I expected that "Wings' would be in the Top 20 based on the comments about this song in this forum. Edited June 30, 201411 yr by Insomnio
June 30, 201411 yr Author 36. GOODBYE / Spice Girls 7.78 eegDtyrSUZw 10 Insomnio, Totto, kellyannmarie, gooddelta, NiallMinogue, missingyou, Aled, SceneofSIXCrimes, JSG, Rob S, DoggySwami, Jonjo, Let Go For 2nite, Dane, Lukuzz, Mike Sugafan, Michael!, Jay, Juliano, Doug 9 Martyn, Jahq, mr_aly, Simon, TheSatsLadyGaga, Jack --- 2 JoeP 1 RabbitFurCoat 35. LOVE MACHINE / Girls Aloud 7.78 owJHNSF9bm0 11 Eyes, Chez Wombat 10 Martyn, Jahq, Insomnio, RabbitFurCoat, Rabbit Heart, kellyannmarie, Leonardo, gooddelta, NiallMinogue, JosephStyles, missingyou, DoggySwami, Ultraviolence, n4yr, Hayzayy, Michael!, Jay, Juliano, Dandy --- 2 TheSatsLadyGaga, SceneofSIXCrimes 1 jsilv The end of an era at 36 as the first Geri-less Spice release 'Goodbye' falls out. Such a beautiful song I'm surprised it didn't get any 11's. 'Love Machine' by Girls Aloud is at 35. Probably expected to do better but I for one am glad it hasn't. Really overrated song and I'm sad it's seen as their signature song. Still you can't argue with 3 11's and 19 10's!
June 30, 201411 yr Love Machine :wub: I'm astounded Disco Love has got as high as it is, very weak Saturdays song and certainly won't be as remembered as many that have passed in this list.
June 30, 201411 yr Spice Girls have 61.5% of their songs left! Check yo shade maths again http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/cat_zpsa5a1f50a.png Mess at my math skills http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v232/korn0818/ATRLSmilies/rip_zpsec10ede9.gif
June 30, 201411 yr 'Disco Love' :wub: Close second to 'My Heart Takes Over' for me in terms of fave Sats singles <3
June 30, 201411 yr Author 34. SOMETHING NEW / Girls Aloud 7.85 ZHSFTrcJYmM 11 AdamAloud, Wallzus, JosephStyles, pippa 10 GRIFF, kellyannmarie, Regina, gooddelta, JoeP, NiallMinogue, missingyou, Aled, Rob S, April, CallumC97, Jay, DionTheSats123, AaronTM --- 2 RabbitFurCoat, Eyes, Alex 1 SceneofSIXCrimes 33. SOMETHING KINDA OOOOH / Girls Aloud 7.89 Wy3SV2fvoG8 11 Jay 10 Martyn, GRIFF, Insomnio, mr_aly, gooddelta, Nick F1, AdamAloud, NiallMinogue, JosephStyles, Aled, Ultraviolence, Jonjo, Let Go For 2nite, n4yr, Lukuzz, Calum Hood, pippa, Hayzayy, Jack, jsilv, Michael! --- 2 Leonardo, TheSatsLadyGaga, Chez Wombat 0 RabbitFurCoat NO GIRLS NO NO NO NO! Girls Aloud take a battering with both their 'Something...' greatest hits singles knocked out. 2012 comeback 'Something New' really was a comeback done SO RIGHT. A shame it wasn't taken to by the public and after a respectable #2 peak quickly left the charts. 'Something Kinda Ooooh' is at 33 and really now Buzzjack, this is a top 10 track if ever I've heard one! After the disappointing singles run from 'Chemistry' Girls Aloud kicked off their first retrospective with a total BANG. Mourn with me Joseph and Jay. </3
Create an account or sign in to comment