Jump to content

Featured Replies

Posted

THE TIME HAS COME. Results will be starting imminently. Any final predictions?

 

What you were rating:

 

CHERYL COLE

http://i35.tinypic.com/212s9zb.jpghttp://i51.tinypic.com/2nbyk9w.pnghttp://i46.tinypic.com/199gdv.png

 

Heartbreaker (will.i.am feat. Cheryl Cole)

Fight For This Love

3 Words (feat. will.i.am)

Parachute

Promise This

The Flood

Call My Name

Under the Sun

Crazy Stupid Love (feat. Tinie Tempah)

 

KIMBERLEY WALSH

http://i49.tinypic.com/28altlt.png

 

Like U Like (Aggro Santos feat. Kimberley Walsh)

One Vision (Alfie Boe & Kimberley Walsh)

One Day I'll Fly Away

The Road (Alistair Griffin feat. Kimberley Walsh)

 

NADINE COYLE

http://i759.photobucket.com/albums/xx240/MarthaJonesFan/Girls%20Aloud%20Cover%20Sleeves/Unsayshubul.png

 

Insatiable

Sweetest High

 

NICOLA ROBERTS

http://i51.tinypic.com/25h06xe.png

 

Beat of My Drum

Lucky Day

Yo-Yo

 

(#poorsarah)

  • Replies 99
  • Views 4.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

'3 Words' is clearly the best so should win but obviously people are too scared of it's brilliance so that certainly won't happen.
'3 Words' is clearly the best so should win but obviously people are too scared of it's brilliance so that certainly won't happen.

 

x100.

 

I'm calling One Vision for last place.

'3 Words' is clearly the best so should win but obviously people are too scared of it's brilliance so that certainly won't happen.

 

 

x100.

 

I'm calling One Vision for last place.

 

http://img.pandawhale.com/post-30307-Madame-LaLaurie-LIES-gif-Kathy-LaBC.gif

  • Author

18 1.82 One Vision

Alfie Boe & Kimberley Walsh

Highest score: 6 (Jade)

Lowest score: -1 (Jay, Liam, JosephStyles)

 

So the worst song actually finishes last, great work guys :kink: The awful song by Alfie and Kimberley was released for the Paralympics in 2012 and completely missed the top 200, and now isn't even available to buy. Really bad song, I'd feel insulted if this beat any other song in all honesty :kink:

 

1.82!!

 

I think that's the lowest score I've seen in a rate for a long time!

To be honest One Vision is awful and never even heard of it before this rate, but Cheryl Fight For This Love to win, The Flood or 3 Words to finish bottom of her singles, also hope Beat Of My Drum to do well also...

Didn't vote but I'll be hoping for:

01 Beat of my Drum

02 3 Words

03 Fight for This Love

04 Yo Yo

05 Call My Name

 

Haven't heard any of Kimberley's solo stuff but looking at the awful average for that one it doesn't look like I'm missing out on much haha

  • Author
You really aren't missing out on One Vision :lol: so so bad and this is coming from someone who loons almost anything these girls release.
  • Author

17 4.28 One Day I'll Fly Away

Kimberley Walsh

Highest score: 11 (Mike Sugafan)

Lowest score: 0 (152chris, Joe. and AdamAloud)

 

Kimberley's first and only solo single is comfortably ahead of her collaboration with Alfie Boe, but still with a fairly rubbish average of 4.28. It was the only single released from top 20 album Centre Stage, which was good for what it was tbf but didn't interest me as a whole. One Day I'll Fly Away was, to give it credit, one of my favourite tracks on it though and I do enjoy it (although I prefer Defying Gravity).

 

To be honest I can see all of Kimberley's singles finishing as the bottom 4. :kink:
You really aren't missing out on One Vision :lol: so so bad and this is coming from someone who loons almost anything these girls release.

Just gave it a listen out of curiosity and I can see how it did so badly in this! Painful. At least it was for a good cause I guess?

 

Just had a look at the rate thread and shocked at all the low scores for '3 Words' :(

Hope it miraculously does well in this but that's obviously not going to happen!

  • Author
Just gave it a listen out of curiosity and I can see how it did so badly in this! Painful. At least it was for a good cause I guess?

 

Just had a look at the rate thread and shocked at all the low scores for '3 Words' :(

Hope it miraculously does well in this but that's obviously not going to happen!

 

:lol: Glad you agree, it's just so awful. Good cause maybe but can't have made much if it missed the top 200 :kink:

  • Author

16 4.76 The Road

Alistair Griffin feat. Kimberley Walsh

Highest score: 9 (James)

Lowest score: 0 (152chris)

 

Another Kimberley single drops out now, with the top 200-scraping The Road. It's a very pleasant track, nothing *awful* as such, but pleasant only gets so far. Quite MOR and not a lot to it. Not shocked to see it so low.

 

Will Kimberley have a bottom-4 lockout or can Like U Like place higher than 15th?

 

Literally one of the most random collabs, but it's pleasant enough, her best 'solo' single.
  • Author

15 5.04 Like U Like

Aggro Santos feat. Kimberley Walsh

Highest score: 10 (jsilv)

Lowest score: 0 (Regina)

 

And finally, the last Kimberley single to appear. Meaning she has the bottom 4 locked out. :lol: Like U Like is, bizarrely, the only non-Cheryl GA solo top 10! Feels odd that Kimberley has one and Nadine and Nicola don't. I like the chorus of this but not huge on Aggro's bits at all.

 

OK we'll have Nicola's singles (except 'Beat Of My Drum') now please. x

Lmao at all of Kimberley's songs in the bottom 4.

 

I'm going to be annoyed when '3 Words' inevitably misses the Top 10. :( I assume the next song to go will be a Nadine one?

  • Author

14 5.76 Crazy Stupid Love

Cheryl Cole feat. Tinie Tempah

Highest score: 10 (Jay, JosephStyles, Niall Minogue, Ultraviolence, James, Ryan)

Lowest score: -1 (Regina, 152chris)

 

Perhaps a shocking result now, as Crazy Stupid Love, Cheryl's most recent single, also a UK #1, crashes out only in 14th. Absolutely gutting imo as I'd rank it as her third best track, but at least it's ahead of all of Kimberley's stuff I guess. Despite all those 10s, it received two -1s and many other low scores mainly towards the end. BOO.

 

Oh, that really has surprised me! Especially since '3 Words' is not out yet considering it somehow got loads of '-1s'. VERY happy that it's out so low though because that saxophone is hideous and how it survived onto the final recording I will never know. No exaggeration, I truly think it's one of the worst parts of a song ever.

Edited by Rabbit Heart

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.