October 18, 201410 yr Author Anyone who rates Steph higher than Andrea needs a hearing test and a slap. I mean her voice is so nothing, she cant get out of one note because her voice just cracks and disappears if she does. I just enjoyed her performance more as an arrangement/song mostly... Andrea absolutely slays her vocally but I wasn't a fan of the arrangement of that song. Like Straight Up, it's a song I absolutely adore but the arrangement didn't work so well for me.
October 18, 201410 yr I hate when someone criticises a favourite and the other judges can't take it :drama: Simon was right there anyway imo. For me it is criticising someone like Andrea is fine if you use the same yardstick for everyone, if you are going to pick faults with what he just did then you should be ripping Steph a new one for the shit she did.
October 18, 201410 yr JUST PERFECT. SHE'S MY FAVOURITE BY MILES THIS YEAR :wub: :wub: 1. Jack Walton 5.5/10 2. Stephanie Nala 2/10 3. Andrea Faustini 6.5/10 4. Lauren Platt 10/10
October 18, 201410 yr Lauren sounded good, but I didn't like her version of the song. 7/10 1. Jack 7.5/10 2. Lauren 7/10 3. Andrea 6.5/10 4. Stephanie 5.5/10
October 18, 201410 yr Lauren is vocally the best girl by a mile, but she needs to have something a little more exciting than that, it was good but she is young and could have really nailed an upbeat song I feel. Her voice did crack a couple of times.
October 18, 201410 yr She needed to be vocally perfect on that version of the song, but she just wasnt
October 18, 201410 yr Stephanie Nala 9.5/10 Jack Walton 8.5/10 Lauren Platt 8.5/10 Andrea Faustini 7.5/10 I wanted to love it but her voice kept cracking? Great vocalist though and so much likeability..
October 18, 201410 yr That was REALLY good from Lauren. Next week can we hear her sing an upbeat track though? 10.0 Jack Walton 09.0 Lauren Platt 07.0 Andrea Faustini 06.0 Stephanie Nala
October 18, 201410 yr Its a stripped back version, bit boring in my view Yeah, but she can't keep going on stripping back big uptempo songs
October 18, 201410 yr Lauren needed a bit more oomph, but she slayed vocally. 8.5/10 Lauren: 8.5 Stephanie: 7.3 Andrea: 7.0 Jack: 6.3 Edited October 18, 201410 yr by *Tim
October 18, 201410 yr Lauren Platt - Really beautiful vocally, she really does have something doesn't she. Not quite as good as Drew's version on X Factor USA and her voice cracked a few times at the top but still, great. - 8.5/10.0 Lauren Platt - 8.5 Andrea Faustini - 8.5 Stephanie Nala - 5.0 Jack Walton - 4.0
October 18, 201410 yr Author Wow. I'm pretty sure nobody will beat that *.* Her voice is just PERFECT. They could make her sing The Chicken Song and I'd be the 01 Lauren Platt - What A Feeling 10/10 02 Stephanie Nala - Call Me 8/10 03 Andrea Faustini - One Moment In Time 7.5/10 04 Jack Walton - Straight Up 7.5/10
October 18, 201410 yr That was beautiful. Haven't really got the hype behind her until now. Would have put her first but there were a few oops moments. 1. Jack Walton 9/10 2. Lauren Platt 9/10 3. Andrea Faustini 7/10 4. Stephanie Nala 3/10
Create an account or sign in to comment