December 8, 20159 yr Not been much discussion of Cheryl in here since the show began, how are we all finding her this series? She's been on top form for me, so much better than last year. She seems full of energy, and her critique has been more insightful for sure. Helps that she quite clearly loves her category too, the groups were an inspired choice.
December 8, 20159 yr I think she's been good this year. I think thats down to her actually being on a panel with people she feels comfortable with. Her and Rita bounce off each other so well! I didn't appreciate that she was so obviously biased with her groups though. Although her enthusiasm for RNB is something to be admired, if only she'd shown the same amount for her other acts.
December 9, 20159 yr I have always quite liked Cheryl, I thought her peak was last year with Mel B. Loved their chemistry. Loved that two members of the biggest girl bands in UK history were there together. Cheryl comes off even better this year because of the lack of credibility on the panel. (Hey Rita. Hey Nick.)
December 9, 20159 yr For me Cheryl's got worse and worse as each year has gone on. Loved her at the start but now shes very beige for me.
December 9, 20159 yr I didn't appreciate that she was so obviously biased with her groups though. Although her enthusiasm for RNB is something to be admired, if only she'd shown the same amount for her other acts. I don't really get that criticism since to me she's always supported 4th Impact in a big way since audition 1. And Alien was voted off too early to really compare.