http://i43.tinypic.com/294thfa.jpg

 

Following on from her mother, The Doctor's wife River Song finishes in third place. A very respectable finish for a very on/off companion who travelled with Matt Smith's Doctor but originally appeared in Series 4 alongside David Tennant and Catherine Tate. This first appearance was actually her death scene. Her appearance have been roughly in reverse order compared to the Doctor's timeline, with a few exceptions. River is very much The Doctor's match. She's one of the rare people who seem to exert considerable control over him and also seems to be one of the closest to his level of intelligence. This now means it's Donna vs Rose in the battle for #1.

 

03. River Song (15 votes | 60.00%)

04. Amy Pond (16 votes | 47.06%)

05. Clara Oswald (12 votes | 38.71%)

06. Captain Jack Harkness (14 votes | 50.00%)

07. Martha Jones (10 votes | 50.00%)

08. Rory Williams (12 votes | 44.44%)

09. Mickey Smith (12 votes | 44.44%)

 

Final deadline: Friday evening

Rose for me, Donna to win :wub:

Okay Buzzjack, now's the time to redeem yourselves for Clara and Rory being forever underrated.

VERY tough for me but going to have to choose Rose as my least favourite. Donna is like no one that's really been a companion yet she showed a lot of different sides.

 

Rose will always be my childhood ultimate companion though. :heart:

Well, these results are going terribly so far :/

 

Rose cannot be equalled I swear, particularly not by bloody Donna.

Edited August 3, 20159 yr by Chez Wombat

Difficult decision because both of them are brilliant but for very different reasons. Had to go for Donna though as Rose's highs were slightly higher than hers.

Umm what, not only does Donna make the top 2 but look how close she is to winning! :o :/

 

Had to vote Donna sorry :(

My favourite has to be Rose Tyler.

 

Sorry Donna Noble.

 

 

Donna Noble for the win. Donna Noble is the best. (and repeat)

Those 2 are my least favourite companions, oh dear :lol:

Bar the succubus not being dead last (and if Donna wins) that's pretty much exactly how I would rank them.

I'm surprised at how neck and neck things are, actually. I kind of expected a landslide in Rose's favor. But I think I'm going to stick with Donna this time. Both Donna and Rose are middle of the road for me, but I think I slightly prefer Rose to Donna.

Awwww Donna getting off to a good start gave me hope! Ah well, she's still my favourite by a mile.

Rose for the win!

Rose was great and her tearjerker moments awesome, but Donna was a matey match with the most heartbreaking goodbye for a companion that is going to be hard to ever top - and she saved the universe too.

Donna's goodbye still brings me to tears. Not so much what she does (which is brilliant) but when Wilf comes out and says he will remember for her when he looks up at the sky. Oh my, I just get caught up in it every time.

It would be a tie! :drama:

 

Extending the deadline till tonight!

DONNA. Such a funny, strong, original companion and THAT goodbye. Rose is the right person to come in second place.

DONNA. Such a funny, strong, original companion and THAT goodbye. Rose is the right person to come in second place.

I don't know why I'm saying this because it might create another tie but it appears you may have voted Donna as your least favourite in the poll whereas this post suggests otherwise!