I remember on first listen I absolutely detested it, claimed it my worst ever GaGa song and so on, and now over time it has wormed it's way into my affections. Like said, on a night out it is so much fun to hear! Among her best maybe.

 

If you compare it to 'The Cure', I loved on first listen but now I find tiresome to listen to really.

I absolutely love it. I wouldn't have chose it to lead the campaign BUT I think it's an incredible and very very underrated track. At the time I remember being unsure of it but the key change for me is my favourites part of the track and I also love the video too I wish we got more live performances of the track.

 

 

Edited September 9, 20231 yr by Jord

I enjoy it on a night out (probably with Bal only) but I would never ever choose to listen to this of my own accord. A mess but not in the best sense and the video is an absolute eyesore to boot.

I've had an up-and-down relationship with this song since it was released but ultimately still think it's one of her worst singles. That's not to say it's a bad song, it's just not as good as her previous efforts. Definitely a skipper for me when it comes on at home.

I enjoy it on a night out (probably with Bal only) but I would never ever choose to listen to this of my own accord. A mess but not in the best sense and the video is an absolute eyesore to boot.

Breaking out her VMA Metallica dance moves to this in the middle of the dancefloor is a highlight of my life.

@1148962465205506048

 

I don't think this has leaked in full, has it?

Yaass what a song!

 

 

That sounds so retro. 70’s/80’s sounding and more sombre

 

Gagas version is like BAM in your face this demos less like that but the song isn’t vastly that different.

Edited July 11, 20195 yr by Jordan Lee

i like it! Might even prefer it to the final version...

 

Ma ma ma ma perfect illusion.

@1170926019341115394

 

The ICONIC Joanne era kicked off 3 years ago!!

 

The country pop songwriting and the looks with pink hat and cowboy style are now copied everywhere, queen was so ahead of the time!

Happy birthday PI *.*

 

I remember exactly where I was when it premiered and Gaga's radio 1 interview for it.

 

I look back on the era fondly - it was so classy <3

Her third best song!

 

I remember where I was - on a sunbed in turkey :cool:

I just read on the previous page how one of the Chainsmokers said it "sucks" and felt a rush of anger, considering how they were responsible for basically ruining music for quite some time.

@1176309083974053888

 

:rofl: I'm dying

 

 

wtf :lol:

!!! ffs

Certified Silver by the BPI! :cheer:

yasss, was just about to post about this. Underrated gem!

Edited October 25, 20195 yr by SKOB

Happy 4th birthday to the lead single of the Joanne era! :party:

 

What are your thoughts on this song, 4 years on?

Love it! It was so different from her at the time and still sounds unique!