29 songs, 22 votes, but what won? Will it be a sexy group song, a Nicole pop banger or will someone else snatch it (lol)?

"I Hate This Part" to sha-slay please x

What You Think About That and Right There to slay please!

29th STARS IN YOUR EYES (Kimberley w/ Her Majesty & The Wolves) 5.14

 

Highest score: 9 (Liam)

Lowest score: 1 (Theo)

 

28th CLOCKWORK (Ashley) 5.16

 

Highest score: 8 (Joseph)

Lowest score: -1 (Harry)

 

27th ON THE ROCKS (Nicole) 5.29

 

Highest score: 10 (Lukuzz, NickF1, Sean Jonjo)

Lowest score: -1 (Tawdry Hepburn)

 

26th WOMAN UP (Ashley) 5.43

 

Highest score: 8 (Liam, Zach, Kye)

Lowest score: 1 (vibe)

 

Unsurprisingly, Ashley loses both hersongs in this batch and Kimberly loses one of two! I don't think Stars In Your Eyes should be this low :( Tune. Woman Up is a bop as well. On The Rocks being this low despie 4 10s tho :o shite song so not bothered tho x

I think I probably gave "Woman Up" too high of a rating so I'm not gutted to see it out - a rather forgettable set of songs from Ashley unfortunately and just no at whatever that Kimberly song is.

Repulsed at the results so far, I agree with you Liam. SIYE deserved so much better as well as Woman Up. The other two are forgettable but still nice. I guess it speaks to how great all their material is, both solo and as a group.

I think On The Rocks gets too hard of a time on here, it's a nice song!

On The Rocks is flawless, so underrated!

25th WHATEVER U LIKE (Nicole)

 

Highest score: 10 (Jonjo, Nick F1)

Lowest score: 1 (Pensmith)

 

24th BABY LOVE (Nicole)

 

Highest score: 9.5 (Nick F1)

Lowest score:

 

23rd RUN (Nicole)

 

Highest score: 11 (Lukuzz)

Lowest score: -1 (Dobbo)

 

22nd COME TO ME (Nicole w/ P Diddy)

 

Highest score: 10 (Jonjo)

Lowest score: 2 (Theo, Joseph)

 

21st SCREAM (Nicole w/ Timbaland)

 

Highest score: 11 (Nick F1)

Lowest score: 0 (Theo)

 

Nicole starts to lose some o her more urban early material, with first UK hit Baby Love and US only single Whatever You Like both dropping out, as well as her feature on Timbaland's Scream. Her huge ballad Run from her most recent album also drops out here, and is the lowest song that got an 11. This means all of the PCD singles made top 20!

Scream is the first real loss for me

Buttons has to win this tbh.

Buttons has to win this tbh.

It won't sadly :(

 

Run made it higher than it should've. The others are about right although wouldn't have minded seeing Come To Me and Whatever U Like a bit higher.

Whatever U Like and Scream are my faves out of those!

Whatever U Like is incredible. So, so under appreciated!

 

On The Rocks remains underrated too! Ffs. :(

Forgot to vote in this. :( Stars In Your Eyes really shouldn't be last! Oops at lots of Nicole's being out already too, but happy to see that Heartbeat is yet to be revealed. :wub:

20th BOOMERANG (Nicole) 7.05

 

Highest score: 10 (Nick F1, Jonjo)

Lowest score: 4 (Vibe, Davidson)

 

I suppose this is a nice enough bip but I wouldn't have it much higher than this, bery basic. This was a stand alone single from Nicole between her first and second solo albums, and did ok in the UK but should have done way better with the momentum she had from last era and being on XF.

 

19th CANDY (Kimberley w/ Aggro Santos) 7.10

 

Highest score: 11 (Dobbo)

Lowest score: 2 (vibe)

 

BANGER, definitely too low. The only solo PCD hit not by Nicole, Kimberely scored gold on this collab with Aggro santos and got a top 5 hit out of it. It's very of its time but I LOVE it still. Have you been to visit me at aggrosantos.com *.*

 

18th WHATCHA THINK ABOUT THAT? (Pussycat Dolls ft. Missy Elliott) 7.16

 

Highest score: 11 (Harry)

Lowest score: 4 (Sean, Lukuzz)

 

The lowest PCD single on this list is Whatcha think About That :o What do I think about that? Probably about right, it's their weakest for me and is ony buoyed by Missy's rap so without that I'd have rated it lower! This was a top 10 for them following When I Grow Up though.

 

17th TRY WITH ME (Nicole) 7.17

 

Highest score: 9.5 (Liam)

Lowest score: 2 (SamJudd)

 

This is dffo too low :( Don't get the hate for this, I don't think it was a good single but it segues really well from weepy ballad to club ballad and really suits her.

 

16th WAIT A MINUTE (Pussycat Dolls ft. Timbaland) 7.20 (1 11, less 10s)

 

Highest score: 11 (Joseph)

Lowest score: 3 (Lukuzz)

 

Our first tie on this list, Wait A Minute is the second PCD song to bow out. I never really go back to it but it's a bop I guess. As a single this never properly charted in the UK, I remember seeing it a lot on music channels but download only singles weren't eligible to chart at that time iirc.

Oh no my 11 is out allready damn you Buzzjack :(

 

My solo 11 is still in though *.*

Wait A Minute has always been under appreciated. I have a feeling IDNAM will be out in the next batch sadly.

Wait A Minute is an absolute bop :(

 

I agree with Try With Me, it's always been one of my fave Nicole singles actually.

15th YOUR LOVE (Nicole) 7.20 (1 11, more 10s)

 

Highest score: 11 (Sean)

Lowest score: 3 (vibe)

 

Scraping top 15 on a tie is Nicole's most recent solo hit from 2013 (lol irrelevant queen x), the lead single to her ill fated second solo album. Bop is about the right word, I don't go back to it too much and it's no less basic than Boomerang but it's nice enough.

 

14th HEARTBEAT (Nicole w/ Enrique Iglesias) 7.23 (no 11s, less 10s)

 

Highest score: 10 (liamk97, Nick F1)

Lowest score: 4 (vibe)

 

Losing our 2nd and final tie is a collab Nicole released prior to the Killer Love campaign, a feature on an Enrique single. This lovely ballad has passion between the two of them and works really well imo.

 

13th When I Grow Up (PCD) 7.23 (no 11s, more 10s)

 

Highest score: 10 (Harry, LeeJ11, Joseph)

Lowest score: -1 (Pensmith)

 

Winning tht tussle is the Pussycats' second lead single! It received a minus 1 and a 0, but also some 10s. I's a fun pop/r&b tune, with some questionable lyrics such as groupies sounding VERY much like boobies *_*

 

12th Hush Hush (PCD) 7.75

 

Highest score: 11 (Johnkm, liamk97, Lukuzz)

Lowest score: -1 (Zach)

 

The lowest recipient of multiple 11s just misses out on top 10. This disco bop starts as a ballad but builds into an I WIll Survive homage. I can see that people might find that a bit cheesy and unneeded, but I love it!

 

 

11th Beep (PCD) 7.91

 

Highest score: 11 (Dobbo, Pensmith)

Lowest score: -1 (Lukuzz)

 

 

Just missing the top 10 is another PCD song, this time from the first album. Beep employs censored beeps to make this song cheeky and playful with a sexy vibe, and was another top 10 for the girls.