Jump to content

Featured Replies

Posted

Hey everyone, over the last few months you have all been voting for your least favourite song, video and single cover and for each round points were allocated. Its now time to see just how you all voted and to find out what song is the ultimate package.

 

The aim is to post a minimum of 1 song per day but will post more depending on interactions from forum members.

 

Lets get the discussions going, there will be A LOT of surprises, lets see what you think about where your favourites appear, are songs too high or too low based on what you expected ? how did the biggest sellers do ? how did the fan favourites do ?

 

Time to find out

  • Replies 406
  • Views 12.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author

Number 66 - Celebration - 123 Points

 

 

 

Kylie_Minogue_-_Celebration.png

 

 

Points Breakdown

 

Cover - 23 out of a possible 500

Video - 46 out of a possible 500

Song - 54 out of a possible 500

 

Personal Opinion

 

Well something had to come last and does it surprise me that it is this ? No, I don't hate it, there are very few Kylie songs that I do and even fewer that I skip. This is usually a song I skip BUT there are times when I let it play where im all "actually its not that bad" but that's probably because I rarely listen to it. It should be on a greatest hits because it is a Kylie song but I don't think it should be on when better songs aren't.

 

 

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Celebration, it never does well when it comes to results.

The song is ok in its studio version but on tour i think Kylie performs it very well and the crowd always get behind it.

  • Author

Number 65 - Kids - 139 Points

 

 

 

Robbie_Williams_Kids.png

 

 

Points Breakdown

 

Song - 17 out of a possible 500

Cover - 50 out of a possible 500

Video - 72 out of a possible 500

 

Personal Opinion

 

It doesn't surprise me this is low, very few fans like it including me, even when it came out I didn't like it and I hate that its performed on every tour. Even the look in the video :puke2:

 

 

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

I do like Kids, i think it gets a hard time from many fans.

At the time, Kylie picked the perfect person to duet with as Robbie was big at that time and it helped showcase that Kylie was back in business, bigger than ever.

 

No surprises so far. I like kids myself but think she could drop it now on the tours but it does provide kylie the opportunity to duet with various people.

Kids is quite a good track but the only thing that irritated me was that it was released too close to On A Night Like This (probably because it suited Robbie's release schedule) and then Please Stay just a few weeks after. Then parlophone decided no more singles in the UK but they easily could have released YDNY in February. So apart from the LY tour edition they stopped actively promoting it.

 

Of course Fever was massive so those 4 singles were spread out to maximise promo. Parlophone probably wanted a gap between LY and Fever too so their strategy paid off in the end to be fair!

  • Author

Number 64 - Limpido - 157 Points

 

 

 

 

Cover - 18 out of a possible 500

Song - 45 out of a possible 500

Video - 94 out of a possible 500

 

Personal Opinion

 

I don't think this is low because its a bad song because I don't think it is, I just thinks it's because its a song a lot of people don't know and haven't invested any time in. The single cover is vey meh which doesn't help.

 

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Kids is quite a good track but the only thing that irritated me was that it was released too close to On A Night Like This (probably because it suited Robbie's release schedule) and then Please Stay just a few weeks after. Then parlophone decided no more singles in the UK but they easily could have released YDNY in February. So apart from the LY tour edition they stopped actively promoting it.

 

Of course Fever was massive so those 4 singles were spread out to maximise promo. Parlophone probably wanted a gap between LY and Fever too so their strategy paid off in the end to be fair!

 

Ya the singles were rushed and in a way it paid off but a fifth single in Feb may have worked. Parlophone did manage to outdo pwl as in with pwl kylie had 13 consecutive top 10 hits and with parlophone she had 14 consecutive before the run was broke.

 

  • Author

Number 63 - GBI - 160 Points

 

 

 

 

Video - 85 out of a possible 500

Cover - 42 out of a possible 500

Song - 33 out of a possible 500

 

Personal Opinion

 

I knew this wouldn't do well but I am pleased it didn't come last. I love the video and the song, the cover is obviously not very good and deserved low points. I actually remember back in the day searching and finding the CD in Our Price and being so happy someone stocked it.

 

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

  • Author

Number 62 - Tears on my pillow - 166 Points

 

 

 

Kylie_Minogue_-_Tears_on_My_Pillow.png

 

Cover - 131 out of a possible 500

Song - 20 out of a possible 500

Video - 15 out of a possible 500

 

Personal Opinion

 

I know this is generally considered to be one of her least liked songs but I don't mind it at all, maybe its nostalgia and the whole Enjoy Yourself era overall. Were there better single options ? hell yeah but the single cover deserved way more points and I loved the B-Side.

 

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

You lot are disrespectful to kids lol
  • Author

Number 14 - Kiss me once (Album) - 143 Points

 

Kylie_Minogue_-_Kiss_Me_Once_(Official_Album_Cover).png

 

Album - 56 out of a possible 1,200

Cover - 56 out of a possible 1,200

Song Selection - 31 out of a possible 1,200

 

Personal Opinion

 

Something had to come last and it looks like its Kiss me once, do I think it deserves it ? No, do I think its a great album ? No, its a very below par average album for me, lazy album cover, very few single options. I actually prefer the bonus tracks to most of the album tracks. I also really like "Beautiful" and think its better than most of the album. The song "Kiss me once" was also a total saving grace for me but the tour was also very meh. Just overall not a great time for Kylie and her fans.

 

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

Edited by Dannyboy

  • Author

Number 61 - All I see - 222 Points

 

 

 

KylieAllISeeCover.png

 

Cover - 129 out of a possible 500

Song - 57 out of a possible 500

Video - 36 out of a possible 500

 

Personal Opinion

 

Personally, I don't get why this song gets such a bad reaction from fans, I love it, does the video song with the song ? No, does the song work with the album ? No, for some reason I just really like the song and the video overall.

 

What are your opinions ? too high ? too low ? lets discuss

I would rate All I See in the weak category for Kylie and part of the disappointing section on the X album.

 

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.