Welcome to a brand new edition of BATTLE OF THE BOYBANDS for 2019! :D

 

To keep things fresh, this time we've got One Direction going up against the following bands: 5 Seconds of Summer, BTS, CNCO, PRETTYMUCH, The Vamps and Why Don't We! And instead of a whopping rate of all discographies, this time we've got different categories where there can only be one winner! Who will come out on top victorious at the end of it all? :o You decide!

 

Vote in the poll and let us know your favourite of the bunch; and feel free to post and discuss your thoughts on each, etc.

The contenders in Round 1 for BEST DEBUT SINGLE are:

 

5 Seconds of Summer - She Looks So Perfect

 

 

 

BTS - No More Dream

 

 

 

CNCO - Tan Fácil

 

 

 

One Direction - What Makes You Beautiful

 

 

 

PRETTYMUCH - Would You Mind

 

 

 

The Vamps - Can We Dance

 

 

 

Why Don't We - Taking You

 

She Look So Perfect easily!

Another vote for ‘She Looks So Perfect’ from me too! I was a bit of a stan during their first era.

'She Looks So Perfect' easily, I loved it at the time and even more now. Quite possibly my favourite boyband song of all time in fact.

 

I really like those Vamps and PRETTYMUCH songs too. This reminded me that in late 2017 I associated PRETTYMUCH with not Why Don't We (as I do now) but MiC LOWRY as up-and-coming boybands, but MiC LOWRY have gone nowhere since oops :lol:

fjflfkfjdh yes let’s pit What Makes You Beautiful with NO MORE DREAM of all things, the one BTS song no one knows unless you’re full fledged ARMY

 

also I did not know that was WDW’s debut single

Obviously She Looks So Perfect wins this for me!

S50S :o

*technically* 1D's debut single is "Heroes" (as part of The X Factor Finalists 2010) :P

 

 

Also I'm dying at some of the comments on that video :lol:

 

"Ngl this was probably the best season of X factor they were all genuine people just go on it for the sake of it now and it's all fixed now"

Edited May 27, 20196 yr by WhoOdyssey

Taking You easily :wub: a BOP

*technically* 1D's debut single is "Heroes" (as part of The X Factor Finalists 2010) :P

 

 

Also I'm dying at some of the comments on that video :lol:

 

"Ngl this was probably the best season of X factor they were all genuine people just go on it for the sake of it now and it's all fixed now"

I don't think anyone considers that 1D's debut single

 

My ranking:

 

1. What Makes You Beautiful - possibly my fave debut single EVER??? An incredible song and one of my all time faves.

2. Can We Dance - lots of love for this too, my second fave Vamps song after All Night

3. She Looks So Perfect

4. Would You Mind

5. Taking You - doesn't really help that I didn't know this at the time and have only revisited it in the past year or so, doesn't have the memories associated with it like the four above!

6. Tan Fácil

7. No More Dream

*technically* 1D's debut single is "Heroes" (as part of The X Factor Finalists 2010) :P

No.

 

Anyway, I went with She Looks So Perfect! Such a tune. It's held up so well and still sounds very fresh even today :wub:

 

1. She Looks So Perfect

2. Can We Dance

3. What Makes You Beautiful

4. Would You Mind

5. Taking You

6. Tan Fácil

7. No More Dream

5. Taking You - doesn't really help that I didn't know this at the time and have only revisited it in the past year or so, doesn't have the memories associated with it like the four above!

Flop stan.

fjflfkfjdh yes let’s pit What Makes You Beautiful with NO MORE DREAM of all things, the one BTS song no one knows unless you’re full fledged ARMY

sorry Cody :( maybe WhoOdyssey has an alternative suggestion?

sorry Cody :( maybe WhoOdyssey has an alternative suggestion?

Why would I? :P

Why would I? :P

Also I'm dying at some of the comments on that video :lol:

 

"Ngl this was probably the best season of X factor they were all genuine people just go on it for the sake of it now and it's all fixed now"

season 7 was the best X factor season tho

One Direction followed closely by 5 Seconds of Summer.

 

how dare you :blush:

 

only one is still being played and will forever be remembered...

 

:wub:

Are 1D gonna steal the win from 5SOS at the last minute? :o More votes please! :cheer: