Welcome to the Kelly Clarkson Singles Rate.

 

You should know the drill by now, but just in case there are any newbies around here (welcome btw x) then it's this simple...

 

- Rank each song in this list on a scale of 0 (worst) to 10 (best).

- You can give out a score of 11 to your absolute favourite and -1 to your least favourite (this is optional and you don't HAVE to).

- You may give out "xx.5" scores, but no 10.5 is allowed. If anyone is rating them this, then your rate will be NULL & VOID if you haven't edited by the time I close this rate.

- The deadline will be 28th December 2019 (I may extend to the 4th depending on how many votes/interest there seems to be).

- HAVE FUN (but please respect other peoples scores).

 

THE SONGS:

xx.x A Moment Like This

xx.x Miss Independent

xx.x Low

xx.x The Trouble With Love Is

xx.x Since U Been Gone

xx.x Behind These Hazel Eyes

xx.x Because Of You

xx.x Walk Away

xx.x Breakaway

xx.x Never Again

xx.x Don't Waste Your Time

xx.x Sober

xx.x My Life Would Suck Without You

xx.x I Do Not Hook Up

xx.x Already Gone

xx.x Don't You Wanna Stay (w/ Jason Aldean)

xx.x Mr. Know It All

xx.x Stronger (What Doesn't Kill You)

xx.x Dark Side

xx.x Catch My Breath

xx.x Don't Rush (w/ Vince Gill)

xx.x People Like Us

xx.x Underneath the Tree

xx.x Wrapped In Red

xx.x Heartbeat Song

xx.x Invincible

xx.x Second Hand Heart (w/ Ben Haenow)

xx.x Piece By Piece

xx.x It's Quiet Uptown

xx.x Love So Soft

xx.x Christmas Eve

xx.x I Don't Think About You

xx.x Heat

xx.x Never Enough

xx.x Broken & Beautiful

 

SPOTIFY:

I listen to her songs daily but I’ll make a point of listening to every single so I can give a fair rate for this. I love Kelly so much :wub:

Because Of You better win this one with ease.

she has at least 5 songs that deserve an 11

she has at least 5 songs that deserve an 11

 

 

Agreed. Hard to decide which song shall get it!

06 A Moment Like This (like Kelly said, was a great song for that 'moment')

08 Miss Independent (love the bridge)

09 Low (underrated and my fave of the era)

07 The Trouble With Love Is (her vocals are great, the song just lacks a little something)

09 Since U Been Gone (my first Kelly CD. Iconic break up track but not my fave from Breakaway)

11 Behind These Hazel Eyes (SUBG was my first CD but BTHE was the song that made me a fan. Everything about this song amazes me and the video is beautifully done)

10 Because of You (Kelly really succeeds at ballads doesn't she??? One of my favourite songs of all time)

10 Walk Away (the video perfectly describes how this song just makes you want to get up and dance! SO MUCH SASS)

09 Breakaway (perfect song for staring out a window and pretend you're in a music video)

10 Never Again (one of my top Kelly songs. My December deserved better)

07 Don't Waste Your Time (I love the video. a decent enough song but Sober should've been released with a video!)

10 Sober (BTHE still gets the 11 score but Sober was close, absolute perfection of a track!)

08 My Life Would Suck Without You (her first and currently only No.1 single in the UK. A good song but have to be in the mood to listen)

06 I Do Not Hook Up (probably my least favourite single)

10 Already Gone (BEAUTIFUL SONG)

07 Don't You Wanna Stay (More country Kelly please!)

08 Mr. Know It All (lyrical genius)

7.5 Stronger (great empowering song but has been overplayed)

10 Dark Side (another underrated track)

10 Catch My Breath (such an addictive song)

08 People Like Us (should've been a hit)

07 Don't Rush (another great country duet)

06 Tie It Up (good solo country song)

10 Underneath The Tree (modern Christmas classic!)

08 Wrapped In Red (Beautiful)

06 Heartbeat Song (there were better songs to lead the album, Nostalgic comes to mind)

06 Invincible (2nd least favourite single)

10 Piece By Piece (that idol performance though :cry: )

08 It’s Quiet Uptown (prefer this to Never Enough, broadway covers album/EP please?)

07 Second Hand Heart (still listen to this from time to time)

08 Love So Soft (underrated bop)

07 Christmas Eve (bop, but not as good as UTT)

10 I Don't Think About You (this song is personal to me so a high favourite)

08 Heat (a grower for me, a great track!)

07 Never Enough (not heard the original so can't really compare, but she smashes it!)

06 Broken and Beautiful (good song for the movie, haven't listened much)

 

 

 

 

Sorry for commenting on each song, but yeah Kelly is my favourite artist :wub:

Edited December 26, 20195 yr by Prettylittlebry

Don't apologise. I love that you did :D

 

Not feeling your feelings towards Heartbeat Song though! A banger *.*

Don't apologise. I love that you did :D

 

Not feeling your feelings towards Heartbeat Song though! A banger *.*

 

 

I do like the song and it is a bop but there's still better :P

 

 

Just realised Tie It Up isn't on the list, should I remove that from my rate?

Where's Sober 😭

Where's Sober 😭

 

 

I was wondering this as it was technically a single!

I was wondering this as it was technically a single!

I thought it was too but wasn't 100 percent sure

THE SONGS:

6.5 A Moment Like This

9.0 Miss Independent

8.5 Low

10.0 The Trouble With Love Is

9.0 Since U Been Gone

10.0 Behind These Hazel Eyes

10.0 Because Of You

9.5 Walk Away

8.5 Breakaway

10.0 Never Again

9.0 Don't Waste Your Time

11.0 Sober

7.0 My Life Would Suck Without You

7.5 I Do Not Hook Up

8.5 Already Gone

8.5 Don't You Wanna Stay (w/ Jason Aldean)

8.5 Mr. Know It All

9.0 Stronger (What Doesn't Kill You)

10.0 Dark Side

9.0 Catch My Breath

8.0 Don't Rush (w/ Vince Gill)

8.5 People Like Us

10.0 Underneath the Tree

9.5 Wrapped In Red

7.0 Heartbeat Song

10.0 Invincible

6.5 Second Hand Heart (w/ Ben Haenow)

10.0 Piece By Piece

7.5 Its Quiet Uptown

7.5 Love So Soft

8.0 Christmas Eve

8.5 I Don't Think About You

8.0 Heat

8.0 Never Enough

7.0 Broken & Beautiful

Edited December 24, 20195 yr by Lukuzz

I was wondering this as it was technically a single!

Was it? :o

Was it? :o

 

It was a radio single in the US. A lot of the controversy with the album had a lot to do with its release and performance.

Ok. I'll add it. If you and Lukuzz wanna edit your scores to include Sober after Don't Waste Your Time, then feel free to do so!

Edited and added 😊

08.0 A Moment Like This
08.5 Miss Independent
06.0 Low
05.0 The Trouble With Love Is
10.0 Since U Been Gone
10.0 Behind These Hazel Eyes
10.0 Because Of You
08.5 Walk Away
09.5 Breakaway
09.0 Never Again
07.0 Don't Waste Your Time
08.0 Sober
11.0 My Life Would Suck Without You
04.5 I Do Not Hook Up
07.5 Already Gone
06.5 Don't You Wanna Stay (w/ Jason Aldean)
09.0 Mr. Know It All
10.0 Stronger (What Doesn't Kill You)
07.0 Dark Side
10.0 Catch My Breath
05.5 Don't Rush (w/ Vince Gill)
06.5 People Like Us
10.0 Underneath the Tree
06.0 Wrapped In Red
06.0 Heartbeat Song
04.0 Invincible
03.5 Second Hand Heart (w/ Ben Haenow)
10.0 Piece By Piece
05.0 It's Quiet Uptown
07.0 Love So Soft
07.0 Christmas Eve
08.0 I Don't Think About You
06.5 Heat
09.0 Never Enough
07.0 Broken & Beautiful

Edited December 24, 20195 yr by SamJudd

If you’re adding Sober then you should add It’s Quiet Uptown as well :P it was at least released to radio

07.0 A Moment Like This > This is cute as a winners single. <

08.0 Miss Independent > I've come to really appreciate this over the years <

08.0 Low > The song that I believe that was responsible for 'Breakaway' happening tbh. <

07.0 The Trouble With Love Is > Gorgeous vocals. <

10.0 Since U Been Gone > A classic! So anthemic! <

10.0 Behind These Hazel Eyes > Very under appreciated with the general public! <

10.0 Because Of You > Absolutely, heartbeakingly gorgeous. <

09.0 Walk Away > Incredibly infectious and catchy! <

09.0 Breakaway > Inspiring and powerful! Stunning. <

08.5 Never Again > Underrated in general tbh. <

07.5 Don't Waste Your Time > Cute. But didn't deserve the single treatment over a few others on 'My December' imo. <

11.0 Sober > Devastatingly beautiful. The tenderness in her vocals and the heartbreaking lyrics... One of my all time favourite songs. <

10.0 My Life Would Suck Without You > A lesson in how to create a pop masterpiece. Incredible. <

07.0 I Do Not Hook Up > Although good, I can't help but feel that this could be better somehow. <

10.0 Already Gone > This > Halo. <

08.5 Don't You Wanna Stay (w/ Jason Aldean) > So beautiful. I'd love an album full of this type of country for her! <

09.0 Mr. Know It All > A forgotten gem! The lyrics are great. <

09.5 Stronger (What Doesn't Kill You) > A pop classic! Irresistably catchy <

07.0 Dark Side > I always found this to be a weak single choice. I've grown to appreciate it recently though, even if there were still better single choices *cough* I Forgive You *cough*. <

08.0 Catch My Breath > I don't know why I love this one so much, I just get caught up in it when I hear it. <

05.5 Don't Rush (w/ Vince Gill) > Nice enough. Pretty bland though. <

09.0 People Like Us > This really deserved to do better. SO good! <

10.0 Underneath the Tree > A modern day Christmas classic! I can't believe this is SIX years old! <

07.5 Wrapped In Red > This is cute. I prefer over half the album though, but still a lovely song! <

10.0 Heartbeat Song > WHAT. A. BANGER. I love this so much! It surprisingly GOES OFF on a night out! <

06.5 Invincible > Pretty beige, but nice enough. I'd have picked at least 3 more songs to be singles over this though. <

07.0 Second Hand Heart (w/ Ben Haenow) > A cute song. It deserved to be a bigger hit. <

10.0 Piece By Piece > The build is what really makes this song special. There's a sense of triumph with it. Such a great song! HEr Idol performance is gorgeous! <

07.5 Love So Soft > THAT note *.* <

09.0 Christmas Eve > Very catchy and the closest thing to UTT sonically! <

10.0 I Don't Think About You > The best she has ever sounded on record, imo. FLAWLESS! <

08.5 Heat > It's a shame the era was dead by the time this could do anything. A great song! I'd argue that it should have been the lead tbh. <

08.0 Never Enough > It's very reminiscent of her 'It's Quiet Uptown' (from Hamilton) cover. Beautiful. <

07.0 Broken & Beautiful > For a kids soundtrack song, this is uplifting and powerful! <

 

---

 

Ugh. What a talent D:

If you’re adding Sober then you should add It’s Quiet Uptown as well :P it was at least released to radio

OMG is this true? Coz I just assumed it was just made for the mixtape? I added Never Enough coz it charted here in the UK. But if IQU was released to radio I'll add it in!