Posted May 2, 20205 yr Hi all!! I'm in charge of picking the Ellie songs for each round of AF Idol on my own, but I need your help. I've got some choices pencilled in but as we want Ellie to go as far as possible, I want to hear what you think!! Round 1 is free choice, so any Ellie song can be sent. Ideally, we'll save the big guns until later, so what do you guys think would be a good, safe choice for round 1?
May 3, 20205 yr If Burn is considered now what exactly is “big guns” isn’t that one of her biggest hits? :lol: Starry Eyed is a great idea I think!
May 3, 20205 yr If Burn is considered now what exactly is “big guns” isn’t that one of her biggest hits? :lol: Starry Eyed is a great idea I think! Yeah but no-one loves it, I don't think it would fair well against other AF's 'big gun' at all.
May 3, 20205 yr Agreed with Liam! I think 'Burn' could be a smart choice for round one. I'd say 'Starry Eyed' would be quite safe a bit later on?
May 3, 20205 yr will never be used *.* Ngl I'd probably vote for it :') On a serious note, I could see Starry Eyed doing well later on, I thought it was one of her most popular songs? Of her most recent stuff I'd put Something in the way you Move or Close To Me/Sixteen
May 7, 20205 yr Author We made it to round 2! We've got four options: Under the Sheets Anything Could Happen On My Mind Close to Me I'd be swayed to Anything Could Happen tbh!
May 7, 20205 yr That or Close To Me? It's recent which helps it but I don't think it's one of her most loved at all and is more of a 'now or never' choice while Anything Could Happen could have some milage in the future! Ik On My Mind is polarising as well but at this stage it probs would get through tbh
May 7, 20205 yr I love love love Under The Sheets personally, but I think On My Mind and ACH would both get through
May 7, 20205 yr Anything could happen is the strongest Under the Sheets is nice too but not sure if people know it Close to Me might polarise people, not a big fan myself but it's ok On My Mind is horrible, I wouldn't even vote for it myself
Create an account or sign in to comment