Posted May 31, 20205 yr Roman Kemp and his sidekicks at Capital recently completed a Tier Jerker of 1D singles, and the results were as follows: GOAT TIER What Makes You Beautiful, Best Song Ever TOP TIER History, Steal My Girl, Drag Me Down GOOD Story of My Life, Live While We're Young AVERAGE You & I, Gotta Be You OVERRATED Little Things, Kiss You Do you agree with any of the choices? Do you strongly disagree with any of them? Are there any notable exclusions that you feel should be there in place of some that are? :o
May 31, 20205 yr 'Kiss You' is top tier. I get why WMYB is GOAT tier but I'm SO happy they put Best Song Ever there too *.* 'Drag Me Down' and 'Steal My Girl' are definitely overrated for me. 'Story Of My Life' deserves to be one category higher and placed in top tier, too! Average (a.k.a not liked enough to be considered "overrated" but definitely not as good as those) is definitely those two. Basically: GOAT TIER What Makes You Beautiful, Best Song Ever TOP TIER Kiss You, Story of My Life GOOD Little Things, History, Live While We're Young AVERAGE You & I, Gotta Be You OVERRATED Steal My Girl, Drag Me Down
May 31, 20205 yr Wow, he was pretty close to getting that one right! Best Song Ever obviously shouldn't be GOAT tier but What Makes You Beautiful definitely deserves its place there, History is a bit too high and could be swapped with either of the two from the 'good' tier, and they certainly got the bottom two correct!
