I have to say I am not a massive fan of either of them (I know, shame on me), but I do like quite a few Mariah and Whitney singles. While Celine is maybe the best vocalist out of the three, she has never really 'clicked' with me bar a few of her most famous songs.

 

I'd probably say Mariah is my favourite out of the three, although Whitney's My Love Is Your Love era singles run is legendary- all the five songs are literally classics for me. I have never heard a full studio album of her though.

Thanks for all that info Jay*!

 

So appreciated to see you mention all that :wub:

I don't like the majority of what I know from all 3 of these artists

 

I think Whitney probably has the highest ratio of songs I can at least tolerate xx

All 3 have had big sales at various periods in the UK.

In the later years All I Want For Christmas Is You has kept Mariahs name out there.

Best vocals - Whitney

Best albums - Mariah

Best singles - Whitney

Least favourite - Celine

Favourite - Whitney

 

As much as I like Celine and her vocals are still great to this day, I don't quite appreciate her in the same way as the other two in this poll. Celine likes to do quite a lot of covers, while Mariah and Whitney don't have quite as many under their belt. Before anyone says it, I'm aware that Mariah and Whitney both have two of their biggest UK hits as covers, while Celine's are original songs so I'm talking about their singles collections as a whole.

 

I grew up with a lot of Whitney and I've seen The Bodyguard musical about 5 times, so I might be slightly biased but I'd say almost all of Whitney's top 40 singles are MOMENTS. How can one woman have the quality of "Saving All My Love For You", "How Will I Know", "I Wanna Dance With Somebody", "One Moment In Time", "I'm Your Baby Tonight", "I Have Nothing", "It's Not Right But It's Okay (Thunderpuss Remix)" and "Million Dollar Bill" in their singles discography? The bops jumped out.

 

However, as much I love Whitney, I think Mariah has the stronger catalogue of albums. I got into Mariah around "The Emancipation Of Mimi", "E=MC2" and "Memoirs of an Imperfect Angel" so I love lots of album tracks from those three. ("Circles", "Migrate", "Side Effects", "Love Story", "Standing O", "More Than Just Friends") I haven't listened to them in a lnog while, but from her debut up to "Butterfly" her albums are pretty strong too. I think she's lost her quality a bit the last few years, but I would say "Caution" was a pretty decent album so there's still hope.

This is close! Each of them leading one poll :wub:

EDIT: I’ve come back to this as my opinions have changed since I first created the poll.

Celine is still my favourite overall but Mariah has overtaken Whitney now in my affections and might have better peak albums for me although Celine is the one I gre ! Of the three Whitney is the one I listen to least and even then I still rate her highly! I also have Celine tickets for next year and will hopefully see Mariah at some point if I can snag Xmas tickets for the UK shows she’s doing.

(Xtina still clears all three though xx)

Almost no voted as I didn't think I listened to any of their albums but think I have actually with Celine (maybe a Mariah album too though can't remember now lol).,

Anyway

Celine for vocal

Celine for Albums Discography

Celine for Singles (though I like a lot Mariah's too and a select small amount of Whitney's).

Whitney for Least Fave Overall

Mariah for overall Fave

10 hours ago, Roba. said:

Celine for vocal

Celine for Albums Discography

Celine for Singles (though I like a lot Mariah's too and a select small amount of Whitney's).

Whitney for Least Fave Overall

Mariah for overall Fave

Mariah still the overall fave despite Celine winning every category. That’s what I call camp x