ROUND 05

 

FREE CHOICE

> Any song by your artist <

 

What do we go for? :w00t:

Our options include:

 

Papa Don't Preach

La Isla Bonita

Vogue

Ray of Light

Sorry

 

:thinking:

 

Frozen and Like A Prayer need to be saved if we get through to the next half of the competition!

Do you think Madge is comfortable here? She's been easily in the top half of every round so I'd be inclined to go slightly risky and send something the fans of the forum love at this point whilst there's hopefully no fear of being knocked out

American Life would show another side to the pop queen's artistry

Do you think Madge is comfortable here? She's been easily in the top half of every round so I'd be inclined to go slightly risky and send something the fans of the forum love at this point whilst there's hopefully no fear of being knocked out

I think she is safe but also the overall winner will be decided on an average across all the rounds, so it depends if we want to allow for discoveries or go for the win!

I'd be happy to send any of those choices and I think all would do really well. I agree with Dandy though that we could afford to play it less safe given it's pretty likely we're going through to the next stage of the competition.

 

Have we ever sent 'Get Together' in AF Idol? It's proved to be a big fan favourite here but is also a less obvious choice to go with and could be a nice discovery for other members.

We haven't sent Get Together before and it's in my top 5 Madge singles so of course I would support it getting some love! :o

I think she is safe but also the overall winner will be decided on an average across all the rounds, so it depends if we want to allow for discoveries or go for the win!

Is each round from here on still overall averages then? That does make a difference :(

Is each round from here on still overall averages then? That does make a difference :(

Yeah </3 i also wanted to send new discoveries but not sure that's what the general vibe is across other artists :(

'Get Together' would be a fine pick! Such a great song.

Any other support for Get Together or any of the other options? :dance:

Power of Goodbye under-performed (despite still being in top half).

 

I would say go for something very well known, so out of the choices...

 

Papa Don't Preach or Vogue.

 

My fave is Ray of Light, but it's not so well known.

 

Get Together isn't a good choice, in my opinion.

Ray of Light or Vogue would definitely get high points from me. But Get Together probably would too :drama:

Send Get Together, Love Profusion, Spanish Lesson from Hard Candy, or Tell Me

 

Shocked at those results !!!!!

 

 

Send Get Together, Love Profusion, Spanish Lesson from Hard Candy, or Tell Me

Not Spanish Lesson ffs, what you trying to do to us :rofl:

I'm having doubts over Get Together as a choice today, it's not the most immediate of tracks for new listeners to pick up on. I'm now thinking maybe we should play safe with either Vogue, Sorry or Ray of Light, especially as the later rounds aren't really geared towards them.

yes Sorry or Vogue would work :o

zero fan of Get Together myself

Oh no! :drama: what shall we do help!!

In theory Vogue should smash it but I'm never quite as confident in her older hits even if they are absolute classics. It may stand out against all the newer songs that will be invariably included though so could get support on that basis?

 

How have the songs faired when we've sent them before? Do we have a record of them?