Jump to content

AF Idol 3.0 • Madonna Discussion Thread

HausofMayhem
in Madonna

Featured Replies

  • Author

In the last AF idol this is how a few of these songs did:

 

R O U N D • 04

> FREE CHOICE <

08. MADONNA - VOGUE [43 out of 77]

R O U N D • 01

> FREE CHOICE <

=09. MADONNA - RAY OF LIGHT [43 out of 75]

R O U N D • 02

> LEAD SINGLE <

10. MADONNA - PAPA DON'T PREACH [40 out of 75]

R O U N D • 08

> A SONG THAT CLOSED AN ERA <

05. MADONNA - LA ISLA BONITA [42 out of 70]

 

Not sure if this helps at all as they all did fairly similarly :lol:

  • Replies 202
  • Views 7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

None of them did amazingly well then and none of them poorly either. Argh the stats don't help!
  • Author

The debate is: do we go for a lesser known GEM or for a more well-known, safe number? I honestly can't decide.

 

Imma try a flash poll maybe~

 

:drama:

As a newcomer to this... this is how I vote..

 

I usually know some of which I will defo vote for.

I listen to 30 secs of each song on the playlist. I don't have Spotify, so that's all I can listen to.

I delete the ones I know I don't like.

I then delete the ones I am not familiar with that don't grab me from those 30 secs.

I delete until I get to 12.

 

So... I would always say go for something well known, as I think they have much more chance of getting a vote.

 

But then... not everyone votes using the process I do.

This is a killer round but Vogue seems to be doing kinda okay. I was worried that younger posters wouldn’t connect with it but it doesn’t seem to be too detrimental so far
The standard in this round is off the scale... I'm glad we sent Vogue!
Yeah it’s just a very competitive round, kinda glad we didn’t go for Get Together now. :’) I think Vogue being older than the rest is actually beneficial for it in this round as it stands out against all the other classics.
  • Author

1 47 Calvin Harris - We Found Love (with Rihanna)

2 45 Britney Spears - Oops!... I Did It Again

2 45 Lady Gaga - Rain on Me (with Ariana Grande)

2 45 Sugababes - About You Now

5 39 Spice Girls - Spice Up Your Life

6 38 Ariana Grande - One Last Time

6 38 Kylie Minogue - Can't Get You Out of My Head

6 38 Rihanna - Only Girl (In the World)

9 37 Little Mix - Touch

10 34 Girls Aloud - Untouchable

10 34 P!nk - Just Like A Pill

10 34 Taylor Swift - Style

13 33 Dua Lipa - Don't Start Now

14 31 Madonna - Vogue

15 29 Ava Max - Sweet But Psycho

 

I'm... OK with that!? It's the oldest song by far in the competition and still attracted over half of the votes! :cheer:

  • Author

Madonna makes it through to the next stages of AF idol 3.0 :cheer: Thanks to all those that have voted for her so far!

 

Spanish Lesson coming to win it all for her now :cheer:

  • Author

ROUND 06

 

FREE CHOICE

 

> But it must not have been sent to the contest before! <

 

So it can't be one of these:

 

4 Minutes (feat. Justin Timberlake & Timbaland) [AFI1: R5 | AFI2: R11]

Bitch I’m Madonna (AFI2: R5)

Don’t Tell Me (AFI1: R2)

Express Yourself (AFI1: R4)

Frozen (AFI2: R9)

Ghosttown (AFI2: R6)

Holiday (AFI2: R3)

Hung Up (AFI2: R12)

I Don’t Search I Find (AFI2: R13)

Intervention (AFI2: R7)

Into the Groove (AFI1: R6 | AFI2: R10)

La Isla Bonita (AFI2: R8)

Like A Virgin (AFI1: R7)

Oh Father (AFI2: R14)

Papa Don’t Preach (AFI2: R2)

Ray of Light (AFI1: R1 | AFI2:R1)

Sorry (AFI1: R3)

Vogue (AFI2: R4)

omg i didn’t realise like a prayer has never been sent before! 10000% that
Go to topic listing

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.