We will be discussing the most overrated songs on each album over the next few weeks! Which songs from the album do you think get too much time, attention and praise? Don't hold back!

 

Next up, Chromatica! Your choices:

 

Alice

Stupid Love

Rain On Me

Free Woman

Fun Tonight

911

Plastic Doll

Sour Candy

Enigma

Replay

Sine From Above

1000 Doves

Babylon

Love Me Right

 

1. Most overrated song on: The Fame

2. Most overrated song on: The Fame Monster

3. Most overrated song on: Born This Way

4. Most overrated song on: ARTPOP

5. Most overrated song on: Joanne

6. Most overrated song on: A Star is Born

Ready to FIGHT in this round x

My response to this is similar to a lot of others in that I don't know if the ones I don't care for as much are the most rated. I love all the singles and Alice, Replay, Babylon (aka the ones that get the most love from what I see).

 

I think it's going to have to be Sine From Above for me? I've just never been able to not find Elton's vocals a distraction, kinda makes me laugh on a song that's not meant to. I do like it, but it's probably in my bottom 5 for the album and the ones below it (Plastic Doll, 1000 Doves, Fun Tonight) aren't rated much at all.

 

I've also never heard Love Me Right but I can't imagine I'd ever answer that as I've never seen it "rated" much either.

Tbf I can accept your Sine shade but putting 1000 Doves in the bottom 5 in unforgivable xx

Could it be Babylon....?

Could it be Babylon....?

Nooooooo! Did you hear it live!? It's as good as it's made out to be :drama:

Yes but it's the only song I am not as keen as "most people"

Sour Candy

 

I'm trying not to be blinded by my dislike of it, but the fact it charted upon album release and people even put that in the top half of the album justifies my vote.

dreadful album

dreadful album

But which song is most overrated from it? :o

I think he clicked on the wrong thread.

Dannjohn dislikes Stupid Love, doesn't he?

Dannjohn dislikes Stupid Love, doesn't he?

Not sure, don't think he's ever mentioned :)

But which song is most overrated from it? :o

 

i went for babylon actually this time... although it's rumoured i dislike Stupid Love, Gaga pretending to be Madonna with Babylon is sheer dreadful

Toss up between 911 and Replay for me.

 

911 is only good for the transition from "Act II". Replay seems to have a bit of a cult following iirc. It's my least favourite on the album, by some distance, and I just don't understand the hype surrounding it.

 

I went for 911 though coz I think it's generally liked by more and is talked about and celebrated more than it perhaps should be.

I think Replay is probably higher rated than 911 after the video but teamed with Chromatica II I can see the 911 hype. I guess the music video helps raise the ratings of 911 whereas it's the tour that helps Replay after it became a highlight from that.

i went for babylon actually this time... although it's rumoured i dislike Stupid Love, Gaga pretending to be Madonna with Babylon is sheer dreadful

 

 

I chose Babylon too but for other reasons

Surprised that Sine is leading (or losing) this

I'm boting Sour Candy obvs xx