I like the way Liam sings in Wonderwall but it was probably a better idea for Noel to sing on Don't look back in anger.

OH, that's a really tough question. It's obvious Noel is the better vocalist but Liams voice is legendary if you ask me. :D

 

I agree, Liam coul'nt sing Don't look back in anger. I have been to an Oasis gig where Liam was sick so Noel had to sing all the songs and he did a superb job.

 

My fav B-side is possibly The masterplan which Noel's voice suits so well.

 

I think i have to vote Noel simply cause Liam's voice annoys me after listening to it for to long.

 

But i'm not fully convinced :rolleyes:

Tough question, but if I had to choose it would be Noel

Noel. He has the better voice and certain songs suit his voice really well, although Liam has a miles better stage presence.

Well I always end up liking songs that Liam sings on more so I'll for him.

Liam for me

 

 

 

Liam is a awful singer, but sounds really good Live, Noel doesn't sound so good Live but in the Studio songs he sounds great, especially on "Force of Nature" and "The Masterplan"

Edited April 12, 200619 yr by thefletch

Liam.

His voice is more distinctive and has more 'edge' to it. (IMO :) ).

Liam.

Noel

Noel for me, he is excellent when he sings DLBIA and TIOBI :)

Noel, I find Liams voice a bit droney after a while -_-

That's like asking do you prefer Oasis or the Beatles. One pisses all over the other.

 

(Liam > Noel that is)