Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Replies 56
  • Views 4.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Madonna could fart for 3 minutes and they'd A-list it!

 

It'd probably be better than her current offering, too!

Edited by RabbitFurCoat

RADIO 2's PLAYLIST:

 

SINGLE OF THE WEEK:

BEN's BROTHER - Stuttering (Kiss Me Again)

 

ALBUM OF THE WEEK:

COUNTING CROWS - Saturday Nights & Sunday Mornings

 

A LIST

 

LEONA LEWIS - Better In Time

BRYAN ADAMS - I Thought I'd Seen Everything

R.E.M. - Supernatural Superserious

DUFFY - ALBUM: Rockferry

ALPHABEAT - Fascination

BETH ROWLEY - Oh My Life

NEWTON FAULKNER - I Need Something

JAMES BLUNT - Carry You Home

ONE REPUBLIC - Stop And Stare

GABRIELLA CILMI - Sweet About Me

 

B LIST

 

ESTELLE - American Boy

*NEW* SCOUTING FOR GIRLS - Heartbeat

*NEW* ABC - The Very First Time

THE KOOKS - Always Where I Need To Be

AMY MACDONALD - Run

EAGLES - What Do I Do With My Heart

SUGABABES - Denial

JACK SAVORETTI - Gypsy Love

LEON JEAN MARIE - Bed Of Nails

SPARKADIA - Too Much To Do

VAN MORRISON - ALBUM: Keep it Simple

 

C LIST

 

RADIOHEAD - Nude

*NEW* HELEN BOULDING - Way To Go

PASSENGER - Table For One

*NEW* MARIAH CAREY - Touch My Body

NATE JAMES - Back To You

TOM BAXTER - Tell Her Today

*NEW* JAMIE LIDELL - Little Bit Of Feel Good

HOLLY ROSE - I Don't Care

 

 

 

have you heard Cahill?

 

I recognise the name...its on my iPod I think as part of a dance compilation...I'll have to give it a listen

"4 Minutes" is excellent. Great beat, great vocals and very catchy. I do not get what is so wrong with it?

 

Plus no-one can really judge it, there's no HQ yet and apparently the leaked version wasn't even the final mastered version, rather bits put together.

 

So I'd argue it's a little early to argue that it's terrible?

  • Author
I recognise the name...its on my iPod I think as part of a dance compilation...I'll have to give it a listen

 

Audio

  • Author
I think that Wiley song will huge, its been added quite early and its been supported by all kind of djs, a sort of rap-dance track.
"4 Minutes" is excellent. Great beat, great vocals and very catchy. I do not get what is so wrong with it?

 

Plus no-one can really judge it, there's no HQ yet and apparently the leaked version wasn't even the final mastered version, rather bits put together.

 

So I'd argue it's a little early to argue that it's terrible?

 

I'd argue it's a little early to A-list it.

The song has not already gained a nickname of "4 Minutes to write this turd" for nothing.

 

As one critic labelled it (the forthcoming album) makes Robbie Williams' Rudebox sould like The Beatles Revolver in comparison.

Are you out of your mind? Well either way, that critic must be. Every single review I have read, from The Observer to Rolling Stone (I think it was RS) has said that 4 Minutes is one of Timbaland's best moments of recent times and a totally gem. Regardless of fan reaction, critical response has been just brilliant.

I think that Wiley song will huge, its been added quite early and its been supported by all kind of djs, a sort of rap-dance track.

 

I agree entirely! Will be massive.

 

On the Madonna thing, it's less than 3 weeks until the download release, and the track is pretty much everything rolled into one that Radio 1 have playlisted of late of that genre! No real suprise it's gone straight onto the A-list considering it'll be avaliable to download very soon.

  • Author

songs A-listed immediately of the top of my head:

 

Madonna - Hung Up

Madonna - American Life (not sure)

Kylie - Slow

Red Hot Chili Peppers - Fortune Faded

Coldplay - Speed Of Sound

Red Hot Chili Peppers - Dani California

 

  • Author
I agree entirely! Will be massive.

 

On the Madonna thing, it's less than 3 weeks until the download release, and the track is pretty much everything rolled into one that Radio 1 have playlisted of late of that genre! No real suprise it's gone straight onto the A-list considering it'll be avaliable to download very soon.

 

Good point, just noticed now how soon the single is released, makes sense for it to be A-listed

Are you out of your mind? Well either way, that critic must be. Every single review I have read, from The Observer to Rolling Stone (I think it was RS) has said that 4 Minutes is one of Timbaland's best moments of recent times and a totally gem. Regardless of fan reaction, critical response has been just brilliant.

 

Actually it is The Word music magazine site where they have given it a bit of a deserved kicking.

 

To be fair they are using it to their advantage and asking posters to suggest other "dreadful" singles by major acts:

 

As for universal praise, here are just a mere handful of the comments about Madonna's new "masterpiece":

 

Good God, what was that c**p? No melody, incoherent "lyrics", monotonous... Ugh.

 

Now watch it skyrocket to number one, and all the Madonna freaks praise it as "her best yet". Whilst Radio 1 will bum it to death as is usually the case with every thing she does.

 

I'm sure Timba/Nate will be praised for this $h!t too.

Ehh, I'm not feeling it. There were a couple of okay bits but it's overall pretty boring. No energy at all and I'm a big Madonna fan for the past 20 years.

 

Ive said this on a Madonna forum so you can imagine what the sycophants had to say.

 

I've bought Madonna records since i was 13 way back in 84, have christ knows how many rmx's singles etc etc been to see her several times the last time paying over £380 for tickets so i think i can quite easily say i'm a fan.But this song.....Jesus its absolutely f***ing vile.

I really don't like it .. but I'll buy the album I'm sure..... too much $h!t going on for one song....

 

THIS SONG IS EVEN WORSE THAN THAT ONE. (reference to previous posters negative comments about Die Another Day)

 

I don't know what the hell she is saying. "You cold beep beep you could beep beep you could beep beep" or some $h!t.

 

The beat is kinda cool, old school rap sounding. Some cool synth sounds, I like the glocken and the tubular bells. A cool organ comes in too.

 

But her part, the singing, it goes nowhere. Not hooky at all.

 

Have to say, Britney's comeback album buries this piece of $h!t. It's so boring, it's hard to believe she is going to actually release this. Gimme More is like as catchy as the flu next to this bland bull$h!t.

I got no idea why this song is called 4 Minutes. Should be called "Unfinished borefest".

 

On the note of the song, however, wow, that was terrible. Made me think of Die Another Day, but even more repetitive and dull. I'm not sure any producer on the planet could have made that interesting. Then again, I felt Madonna hasn't done anything good really since Ray of Light, everything since then has been boring, uninspired electronica.

Personally i loved Confessions On A Dancefloor.....it was needed after American Life but this single....naw sorry doesnt cut it with me.There may be good stuff on the album but it'll be the first i download illegally lol

 

I honestly don't freckin' get what the track is trying to do/be...

 

And I'm a timbaland fan!!!

 

beep, bop a do-wop she bop a lu-wop...or something...

 

last track the tims did that gave me a boner was "ayo technology" with 50 cent...

 

this Madge track is sorely lacking...

 

 

So universal acclaim for Madonna's new single :rofl:

 

 

 

 

:o I didn't know that Love Like This was getting released here! Is the album Pocketful of Sunshine too :mario:
  • Author
:o I didn't know that Love Like This was getting released here! Is the album Pocketful of Sunshine too :mario:

 

Its gonna be released in the whole of Europe this Spring. Dunno how they'll release the album though

^^ :rolleyes:

 

Crazy Madonna fans are ALWAYS the same -_- Worship her to the high heavens but when she changes the style (With her its usually every album) they complain at first.

 

I remember the whole:

 

OMG SHE HAS JUST STOLE THE ABBA TUNE FOR HUNG UP.

 

A few weeks later they were still humping it. Madonna/Britney/Kelly Clarkson/Michael Jackson fans are always the same -_-

 

Anyway, "4 Minutes" is amaze :wub: Good on her i reckon.

Actually it is The Word music magazine site where they have given it a bit of a deserved kicking.

 

To be fair they are using it to their advantage and asking posters to suggest other "dreadful" singles by major acts:

 

As for universal praise, here are just a mere handful of the comments about Madonna's new "masterpiece":

So universal acclaim for Madonna's new single :rofl:

As I said back to my earlier no-one has heard the single yet properly. Some forumer's negative opinions don't exactly count as anything to do with universal critical acclaim. What does critical acclaim mean anyway? Doesn't make something good or bad, if anything critics tend to be elitist snobs. Without wishing to sound like a broken record you haven't heard the bloody HQ single version of the track. You're so negative based upon a clumsily put together MQ version of the track.

 

Some people are never going to accept that Madonna has turned R&B and you appear to be one of them.

  • Author
I wasnt impressed with the single at first but I quite like it now. I think the HQ will be amazing, and it still sounds quite poppy imo.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.