Jump to content

Which Is In Your Opinion The Most Disappointing Comeback Single Of Recent Years? 141 members have voted

  1. 1. Vote For The Most Disappointing Comeback Single In The 2007-2008 Era

    • 2 Hearts - Kylie Minogue
      28
    • Gimme More - Britney Spears
      5
    • 4 Minutes - Madonna
      18
    • Headlines- Spice Girls
      59
    • Taking Chances- Celine Dion
      13
    • Touch My Body- Mariah Carey
      12

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

Mariah's Touch My Body is AMAZING :w00t:

 

I voted '2 Hearts'

'In My Arms' is great though!

  • Replies 84
  • Views 4.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I'm glad to see Britney's got the least votes, ''Gimme More'' was one of the best pop songs of last year!
I'm glad to see Britney's got the least votes, ''Gimme More'' was one of the best pop songs of last year!

 

Agreed, it's in my top 3 songs of all time. :wub:

 

It's been in my top ten for about 8 months now :o

Ur absolutely right CrazyCrazy. I think she's brave for trying new things and still remain true to herself. Look at the tour, it only just started and its very succesfull already.

 

I'm so glad you agree, people shouldn't put restrictions on artists and what they can do, I'm glad the album done reasonably well in the UK, I've read that it's sold roughly 400,000 copies which I consider to be very good considering the switch in style and peoples perceptions of her. I'm glad the tours doing very well, I don't think there will ever come a day when Celine's tours don't do well, she's too sensational! :0

  • Author

the top 3 so far:

 

1.Headlines (Spice Girls) 47 votes

2. 2 Hearts (Kylie) 22 votes

3. Madonna, Celine Dion, Mariah Carey 10 votes

 

 

more votes to seperate the latter 3....

Edited by Big Mistake

I want to change my vote from Britney to Madonna. It's just awful in comparison.
Taking Chances for me, although i still really like it!

 

Why? Its an amazing song. Ok it didnt do well but still miles better than Spice girls, Madonna and Mariah's latest offerings.

I really don't get the 2 Hearts hate, I LOVED it LOL

 

I didnt like 2 hearts much at first but it has grown on me. I still don't think its one of Kylie's best but its a grower. I think alot of fans were expecting Kylie to come back with something bigger and more popular. There was alot of hype prior to the single coming out and because it didnt do as well as expected, Kylie's comeback has been labelled as a disappointment. I think the problem is the single wasnt very representative of the album X, in fact the style is quite different to anything she has done before. Perhaps people were expecting something more poppy along the lines of I believe in you.

Changed for you Adi. ^_^

Thanks Kelly. ^_^

Gimme More was the best choice for Britney's comeback single but it really doesn't stand up to Piece Of Me at all. :heehee:
Gimme More was the best choice for Britney's comeback single but it really doesn't stand up to Piece Of Me at all. :heehee:

 

For me it has. I'm now completely bored of 'Piece Of Me' after a period of totally loving it, whereas I'm still not completely bored of 'Gimme More'. :wub:

2 Hearts gets my vote. So awful.

 

I kinda liked Gimme More in a carcrash sort of a way, 4 Minutes is immense if not a little safe for Madge, Headlines...well I didn't expect anything of substance from then anyway, I don't remember the Celine comeback and Touch My Body is probably the best of the lot of them.

How can Gimme More be a bad comeback? It's Ms Spear's second biggest single of all time.

Edited by Oral Fixation

Erm "Headlines for me, "2 Hearts" I didn't think was THAT bad tbh. "Gimme More" was fantastic imo, and not something I would usually like tbh. "4 Minutes" is one of the worst songs of the year so far for me, "Taking Chances" was okay but not really my thing tbh, and I love "Touch My Body" haha.

2 hearts is not a bad comeback, it was never going to be another Can't Get You Out Of My Head, although i do wonder if WOW was released first would she have had a bigger comeback???hmmmmm.

 

Headlines gets my vote btw, it was like the song was thrown together in 5 minutes. just my opinion.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.