hmmmm..... its not her type of music to be honest she doesn't feel comfortable, she is more of a soul diva. 5/10

Alex - best performance of the night BUT why does she copy everyone!!!!!!!!!

Alexandra - Was a total copy of Christina's style with the song - it would have had more impact if she had personalised it a bit. However, she sang it very well, and was great to have a more modern song there. Best of the night so far. 8/10

Alex 2nd best of the night after Ruth only 2 ive really liked tonight :D

Ruth's performance was great. Like Simon said, it wasn't better than Leona's version but who cares?

 

Alexandra's performance was brilliant as always, and I like how Cheryl corrected Louis by saying Alex was never out of the race.

Ruth: How she was in the bottom two last week I don't know but this was a very strong performance and she really pulled it off. 8/10

 

Alexandra: Wow.......I love this song it really has loads of energy. Alex was astounding too she looked really comfortable singing the song too. The Choriogriphy was amazing too with all the movements and gestures. Just wow! 10/10

Edited October 25, 200816 yr by Sabrewulf238

What were the judges doing giving standing ovations to Laura and Eoghan?

 

Laura slurred her way through the song and I didn't understand a word! Eoghan was weak and flat.

i think the whole big band thing makes it hideously difficult to impress but Alex at least used a contemporary song so we could see what she might be able to do should she actually win

Eoghan was awful!!! Send him home!

 

He'll be sure to go through though - the mums would have been thinking 'aww he wasn't very good was he but I don't wanna see him go home'

I wanna SCREAM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

THERE WAS AN ERROR WITH THE PHONE LINES LAST WEEK - NO ONE COULD VOTE FOR RUTH FOR AN HOUR - IT WAS IN THE PAPERS YET NO MEANTION TODAYS SHOW....

 

They should get FINED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Poor Ruth!!!!!!!!!!!! - She probably got the most votes

I wanna SCREAM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

THERE WAS AN ERROR WITH THE PHONE LINES LAST WEEK - NO ONE COULD VOTE FOR RUTH FOR AN HOUR - IT WAS IN THE PAPERS YET NO MEANTION TODAYS SHOW....

 

They should get FINED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Poor Ruth!!!!!!!!!!!! - She probably got the most votes

Calm down :blink: I really don't think a weeny error made her bottom two last week LOL

Time for Austin! :D

I don't get the hype of Alexandra, she wasn't half as good as she usually is :unsure: Laura and Ruth were both really good though I hope Diana can blow them out the water like she usually does.

 

If Austin wants to be an 'artist' then why is he on the X Factor? :unsure:

Ruth did amazing. Such a feisty woman, stunning voice, stunning looks. She's just the t!ts! 10

 

Alexandra did total justice to that. Wonderful choreo and styling, but a slight shame she did that sing-half-the-line-then-let-the-backing-singers-do-the-rest trick which certain big-voiced divas are so fond of... 9

Calm down :blink: I really don't think a weeny error made her bottom two last week LOL

 

If you cant vote for someone for an hour I would say that would mess up the votes a fair bit!

I knew someone would do Mack the Knife :lol:

If you cant vote for someone for an hour I would say that would mess up the votes a fair bit!

I suspect her performance was factor too ;)

Designer Label, I hate to tell you this but you're coming across as a right nut.

 

I voted for Ruth last week, it didn't let me vote since they'd put the number up wrong, but two minutes later there was another recap with the right number. It really won't have cost her much, so keep your wig on!

Austin -------MAGNIFICENT :yahoo: :w00t: :yahoo:

Wow.. Austin was actually half decent for once!