Jump to content

Featured Replies

  • Replies 408
  • Views 22.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I have to say... why on earth wasn't 'Crashing Down' included on this album?! It's better than most of the tracks on there.

 

I know, and the album feels rather short anyways. i think crashing down and not good enough should have been added

To think, this album looks set to have a similar chart position to Sugababes, who would have thought?
I've heard Issues off the album and love it. Didn't like Work much though.
Well much as I like this album it certainly doesn't TOUCH Doll Domination or Catfights for quality. -_-

 

It's still very good though, especially for a debut. My favourite at present is 'Why Me, Why Now'. Just lovely.

 

Doll Domination and Catfights are hideous albums. =/

 

I mean the Saturdays album is poor, but it has one or two good tracks. DD and CaS have nil.

What utter c**p. Those albums have some direction (okay, maybe not DD. Catfights does). This is an album with some pop gems and some average pop songs, but it doesn't have a direction (and you wouldn't expect it to). To say those albums have no good pop songs and then acknowledge that this DOES is totally ridiculous. At least Nicole and the Sugababes contributed to the writing of their respective records... you know, were responsible for how they actually sounded instead of some record label boss deciding.

agree!

 

still like the first half of the album alot though

  • Author
I think i prefer this to Catfights really, but i still think the Sugababes have come up with a brilliant album. PCD not so much.
What utter c**p. Those albums have some direction (okay, maybe not DD. Catfights does). This is an album with some pop gems and some average pop songs, but it doesn't have a direction (and you wouldn't expect it to). To say those albums have no good pop songs and then acknowledge that this DOES is totally ridiculous. At least Nicole and the Sugababes contributed to the writing of their respective records... you know, were responsible for how they actually sounded instead of some record label boss deciding.

 

You mean Keisha! Heidi has no writing credits and Amelle has 1! -_-

^ I was just going to say that! :lol:

Though, Heidi also has one... She wrote on "Sunday Rain"

Edited by PeytonDavis

You mean Keisha! Heidi has no writing credits and Amelle has 1! -_-

Still more than The Saturdays will ever be capable of! Infact their best album was their first one and that was all wrote by them! Even Girls Aloud have A LITTLE say in their direction where as this album isn't just very poor (well apart from the title track, that one is ok) it's just all put together by a record company which is one of my many out of date and stuck in the late 90's things about this group! They're everything Girls Aloud and Sugababes aren't in many ways!

But Sugababes and Girls Aloud are established enough now to have a say in what they do. The Saturdays are newbies if you like! :lol:
What utter c**p. Those albums have some direction (okay, maybe not DD. Catfights does). This is an album with some pop gems and some average pop songs, but it doesn't have a direction (and you wouldn't expect it to). To say those albums have no good pop songs and then acknowledge that this DOES is totally ridiculous. At least Nicole and the Sugababes contributed to the writing of their respective records... you know, were responsible for how they actually sounded instead of some record label boss deciding.

Just because someone doesn't agree with your opinion really doesn't mean you can call it c**p. There's a thing called respect, you should try showing some ;)

But Sugababes and Girls Aloud are established enough now to have a say in what they do. The Saturdays are newbies if you like! :lol:

Yeah and Girls Aloud still hardly have a say but at least the material they were given was always good and despite being put together by viewers of a TV show they were actually quite good as a group and they have a bit of personality. The whole going 'HELLOOOOOOOOOOOOO!' on the radio at the same time just screamed out of date 90's style girl group with lots of mone spent on them to me. The only reason I have such a strong issue tbh is because of them being shoved down my throat everywhere and their massive popularity here because they're a group who logically I really SHOULD like but I absolutely hate them and having them shoved down my throat with all their hype PLUS that is really annoying me for some reason. :lol: Yet I do find reading the threads on here fascinating hmmmmm.

  • Author
But Sugababes and Girls Aloud are established enough now to have a say in what they do. The Saturdays are newbies if you like! :lol:

 

Exactly. Girls Aloud didnt have any writing credits until the second album and i doubt they had any direction on the first album either, even to this day they dont have any credits on anything more than the weaker album tracks. As for the Sugababes, Keisha has credits on most if not all of the Catfights anf Spotlights tracks, the other 2 are credited on abot one track. I also dont see why a fuss has to be made on if they write the songs or not, the singing is why they are there so i really coudnt care less what say they have on the music as long as i like it.

The Saturdays are performing at the Christmas Lights Switch-On in Birmingham next Saturday (8th Nov). It's free to attend at begins at 3pm for anybody interested. ^_^
Im loving the song 'Set Me Off' at the min, aly sent me it the other night and ive not stopped listening to it. I really should check out the rest of the album..
Dont forget, they're on Radio 1's Live Lounge tommorow from around 11.30.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.