My fave Performances tonight!

 

01| Diana - Girlfriend

02| Alexandra - Don't Stop the Music

03| Diana - White Flag

04| Alexandra - Unbreak My Heart

05| Eoghan - Year 3000

06| Eoghan - Does Your Mother Know

07| JLS - I'm Already There

08| JLS - Umbrella

 

From my choices I'd be saying goodbye to JLS tonight. But I fear for Diana this week after reading all the stuff Tip has posted and everything :unsure:

Alexandra will go home tonight, final of Diana, Eoghan and JLS

 

Alexandra is a class above any singer left in the competition but the same people who kicked Ruth out last week after 2 amazing performances still have access to phones :( bye bye Alexandra)

First time I posted in this bit of the forum... Anyway I loved Alexandra, and JLS weren't that bad :) Diana and Eiogh... erm... Ogre were awful as usual IMHO. Alexandra FTW!

Alexandra: Alex FTW! Her performance wasnt as good as Listen but still she did brillantly IMO. 9/10

 

JLS: Much much improved from Umbrella and one of their best in weeks. 7/10

I don't recognise the song JLS just did... who did the original?

I don't recognise the song JLS just did... who did the original?

Lonestar

 

I didn't recognize it either tbh.

Alexandra will go home tonight, final of Diana, Eoghan and JLS

 

Alexandra is a class above any singer left in the competition but the same people who kicked Ruth out last week after 2 amazing performances still have access to phones :( bye bye Alexandra)

 

People are voting for their favourites ;) So it's because people aren't voting for Alex if she goes... ;)

Tonight Rankings

 

1. Alexandra - 9+8.5=17.5

2. Diana 8+9=17

3. JLS 4+7=11

4. Eoghan 5+3=8

If Diana and Eoghan stay then there is something seriously wrong with the public!

Diana - cringe! first song was terrible, 2nd song was ok

Eoghan - both songs were terrible, 1st one was better though

JLS - loved both songs, especially the first one

Alex - should win this if theres any sense..

Here are my standings for the second song:

 

1. Alexandra

2. Diana

3. JLS

4. Eoghan

 

and overall:

 

1. Alexandra - Don't stop the music

2. Alexandra - Unbreak my heart

3. Diana - White Flag

4. JLS - I'm already there

5. JLS - Umbrella

6. Diana - Girlfriend

7. Eoghan - Year 3000

8. Eoghan - Does your mother know

 

For the first time I think I liked Eoghan's first performance but overall the others were better I think.

Edited December 6, 200816 yr by Sabrewulf238

My ideal final Diana and Alex :w00t: I won't mind who wins then :wub:

Im sky+ it, so ive not seen it all yet, but my top 4 for the first songs;

 

01 | Diana :wub:

02 | Eoghan :mellow: :blush:

03 | Alexandra

 

 

 

04 | JLS

If Diana and Eoghan stay then there is something seriously wrong with the public!

Diana - cringe! first song was terrible, 2nd song was ok

Eoghan - both songs were terrible, 1st one was better though

JLS - loved both songs, especially the first one

Alex - should win this if theres any sense..

 

My sentiments exactly..... Diana couldn't hold a tune if her life depended on it.... Dido's a bad enough singer - but even she can hold a tune as easy as White Flag - Diana is simply out of her league.... awful. In fact, worse than awful. The first song was rancid - utterly appalling. Cheesy and embarrassing.

 

JLS...once again... they're comprised of a singer with a very average backing band. They always mess up the harmonies week after week - they're never ever in sync and tonight was as ropey as every other week for them.

 

Orville - the singing Gonk continues to make my toes curl - if 15 year old girlies are keeping this abomination in XFactor - then they should start having a minimum age of 16 before you're considered wise enough to vote. He's possibly the worst ever XFactor contestant.....

 

Alexandra.... she won't win this contest, and this week really wasn't her finest week (I hate that Rihanna song when it's sang by Rihanna.... by Alex it was just pointless - she's worth more than fluff like this and shame on Cheryl for giving her such a terrible song to sing). The second song was better.... but I think Alex would shine if she was given a song by a real old soul singer like Aretha Franklin, Minnie Riperton or Anita Baker. Also, her vocal histrionics and her ghastly Mariah-lite warblings (you only need top sing one note, love... don't overplay your hand) spoiled tonight for her. But still, she's clearly in a different league to the other contestants.

 

Diana, Orville or JLS to go tonight..... they're all as bad as each other - but Diana is the more cringeworthy of the 3...so I'd like to see the back of her tonight.

LMAO! They're actually calling Eoghan "Eggnog" on the Xtra Factor :rofl:

My overall rating:

 

01 | Alexandra - Unbreak My Heart

02 | Diana - Girlfriend

03 | JLS - Song (I forget :( )

04 | Diana - White Flag

05 | Eoghan - Year 3000

06 | Alexandra - Dont Stop The Music

07 | Eoghan - Does Your Mother Know

08 | JLS - Umbrella

01 Alexandra - Unbreak My Heart

02 Alexandra - Don't Stop The Music

03 JLS - Umbrella

04 Diana - Girlfriend

05 JLS - I'm Already There

06 Eoghan - Year 3000

07 Diana - White Flag

08 Eoghan - Does Your Mother Know

Alexandra is the only decent one left - Eoghan's and Diana's second songs were terrible! JLS are ok, but I just like them at all.

 

I bet Alexandra goes now - why was Cheryl already acting like she was going??

Nice and quick this week only 30 minutes between the live show and the results show, less time to vote, quite strange really.

i have a feeling diana might go although id like jls or eoghon to go

 

definitly alexandra to win now

If Eoghan is through, he will be the First or 2nd act to get mentioned, as he was bottom 2 last week...