Aaargh Alexis went. Ok not a great song choice but wrong decision. It shud have been Michael even though i like him but he was worse out of 2 for me. Anyways Allison, Danny or Adam FTW :D

I've merged the two American Idol threads, it was getting a bit messy. I hope it's no problem. If you wish to start another poll, try to keep it about who you want to win and keep the discussion of the live shows etc. in here please. ^_^

This Thursday the full show without being split now that the Paris Hilton rubbish has finished :cheer:

Song spoilers:

 

 

Matt Giraud - “Let’s Get it On” by - Marvin Gaye

Kris Allen - “How Sweet it Is” by - Marvin Gaye

Scott MacIntyre - ”You Can’t Hurray Love” by - Supremes

Megan Joy Corkrey - “For Once in My Life” by Stevie Wonder

Anoop Desai - “Ohh Baby Baby” by - Smokey Robinson and The Miracles

Michael Sarver - “Ain’t Too Proud to Beg” by - Temptations

Lil Rounds - “Heatwave” by - Martha and the Vandellas

Adam Lambert - “Tracks of my Tears” by - Smokey and the Miracles

Danny Gokey - “Get Ready” by - Temptations

Allison Iraheta - “Papa was a Rolling Stone” by - Temptations

 

Allison was awesome again this week.

 

Now Alexis has gone - Allison and Adam for the final - Allison to win

 

Simon got it absolutely right this week in not saving Michael Sarver. Again he was consistantly bad. He should never have made the final 12 - 13

 

Hope it's Matt, Danny or Kris that goes next week. They're distinctly average.

Edited March 31, 200916 yr by Euro Music

Allison was awesome again this week.

 

Now Alexis has gone - Allison and Adam for the final - Allison to win

 

Agreed on all of that :D

 

Adam did a fab job last night and Allison was great again as always :D

I'm sorry but I think the quality of the singing this season is very avaerage, at best. I'll be astonished if Adam doesn't win it.

glad Michael has gone! hopefully its Scott next week

Scott or Megan next week. Or maybe Lil Rounds, I do think she acts really stuck-up and really isn't nearly as good singer as she thinks she is.

This week's song choices - Spoilers

Popular iTunes Downloads

 

 

Kris Allen - Ain't No Sunshine (Bill Withers)

Anoop Desai - Caught Up (Usher)

Matt Giraud - You Found Me (The Fray)

Danny Gokey - What Hurts the Most (Rascal Flatts)

Allison Irahetta - Don't Speak (No Doubt)

Megan Joy - Turn Your Lights Down (Lauryn Hill & Bob Marley)

Adam Lambert - Play That Funky Music (Wild Cherry)

Scott McIntyre - Just the Way You Are (Billy Joel)

Lil Rounds - I Surrender (Celine Dion)

 

 

Next Week - The year they were born.

Edited April 1, 200916 yr by Euro Music

Usually I really don't like the Group performances much. But their performance of 'Don't Stop Believing' this week was REALLY good! :o Was really impressed!

Wow what an crazy but good performance from Lady Gaga although she hasn't been feeling too well :(

 

Megan going over Anoop was wrong i thought as Annop well he's $h!t and Scott is awful too these both need to go ASAP :arrr:

Edited April 3, 200916 yr by Blazing Rob

Been watching this (huge fan actually - go Danny :heart:), and read the spoiler that Anoop was in the bottom 3. I really wish he had gone rather than Megan. Megan was the best of the bottom three tonight. Scott isn't $h!t, he's just bland. Gaga performance absolutely kickass though :wub:

Disagree on nearly all. Thought GaGa was appalling but that's not really AI based so.

 

- Megan deserved to go. Absolutely dire, although she was diifferent, she didn't capitalise on it well.

- Anoop, while he had a bad week, has more to offer if last week is to be believed

- Allison never deserved bottom three

- Scott and Danny have good parts of songs but are largely unremarkable

- Kris is probably the most consistently good one.

- Lil is the one I always think can do better than she is doing

- Adam is top of his game always, if a little odd.

- Matt was the best this week IMO.

 

Top three: 1. Kris 2. Matt 3. Adam

Allison and Megan in bottom 3 :w00t:

 

My bottom 3 this week were

1. Anoop

2. Matt

3. Scott

 

My final 3 have to be:

Allison - Adam - Lil -- with Allison to win.

They are the only 3 left I like now.

 

Poor season this year with the best going early on.

Alexis - Megan - Jasmine

 

I think Anoop, Matt, Scott & Kris - not in the league of guys from past finalists (apart from Taylor Hicks) at this stage.

IMO Michael Sarver should have gone at the beginning with Jorge Nunez

 

Both Lady Gaga and David Cooke were brilliant last night. Only thing I didn't like was Lady Gaga's wig.

None of the guys have anywhere near as much talent as David Cooke (except Adam). They're so bland and uninteresting.

My top three is now:

 

1. Adam - by far the best

2. Matt

3. Allison

4. Danny

 

Next to go: Anoop and Scott. And I also really don't like Lil that much, she doesn't seem to take the critique very well at all and even thou she sings the choruses ok the verses are terrible.

My top three is now:

1. Adam - by far the best

2. Matt

3. Allison

4. Danny

 

I agree those 4 would be my top 4 as well. But this is my order

 

Top 2 is intensely close though

 

1-Adam

2-Allison

3-Danny

4-Matt (Great performance last night)

Performances ths week Allison>Matt>Adam>Lil>Danny>Kris>Anoop>Scott

But overall Matt>Kris>Adam>Allison>Lil>Anoop>Danny>Scott

Am I the only person who absolutely DESPISES Adam? :arrr: Arrogance to the MAX.

I'm not a big fan. Gay as the day is long and all (he makes ME look straight... :kink:)

 

Danny still my fav, but Alison was pretty good this week. I love Lil but she was disappointing this week. Didin't deserve to go though I would have rather seen Anoop go than Scott.

 

By the way, how weird was the performance of Can't Get You Out Of My Head? :blink: