Posted September 3, 200915 yr Just thought it'd be a good idea to start it again. ^_^ First up is RnB diva Beyoncé and considerably less successful 'Goodies' singer Ciara. I personally prefer Ciara, she knows how to produce real good RnB songs as well as that her personality is much more appealing and I know it sounds weird but I actually prefer her voice over Bey's too! Who is it for you?
September 3, 200915 yr Ciara! - LOVED every single she's released to date! ESPECIALLY 'Oh' and 'Work'! :wub: Looking back at Beyonce's discography (solo) she is actually overrated! :( BAR 'Irreplaceable', 'Listen', (A few off of 'I Am...')! 'Crazy In Love' = good at the time but got old fast.
September 5, 200915 yr Beyonce. Her albums arent up to much i know but her singles are all basically heaven - she can even manage to turn the dullest of album tracks into killer singles. Ciara on the othe hand just screams MEDICORITY! Pleasantly suprised to see Beyonce leading the poll
September 5, 200915 yr ciara's not overrated, and her songs don't get old as quick. therefore, ciara.
September 5, 200915 yr I hate to pick the obvious overrated one, but it's Beyoncé for me. I just find her much more consistent, she's got good ballads and good uptempos. I find that Ciara mostly goes over my head, her voice doesn't really do it for me, she's best on songs where the voice doesn't matter too much ("Goodies", "1, 2 Step", "Work" etc.) for me. She got a nice tone to her but not the vocals for me, I only obsess over about 10 Ciara songs.
September 6, 200915 yr are we having a laugh here. You're comparing the best in the business with a butlins singer. Beyonce, for sure.
September 8, 200915 yr Author She can sing though? Some of her performances of 'Never Ever' show this too. Besides, it's not all about voice anyway ... Ciara seems much more likeable personality wise and has stronger material, in my opinion of course.
Create an account or sign in to comment