Posted October 5, 200915 yr Pop Soundclash Two LILY ALLEN http://justwilliam1959.files.wordpress.com/2009/02/lily-allen-gq-05.jpg Biggest Hits Smile - #1 The Fear - #1 Not Fair - #5 LDN - #6 NATALIE IMBRUGLIA http://www1.pictures.gi.zimbio.com/Brit%20Awards%202009%20Inside%20Arrivals%20vn5O7OP2yljl.jpg Biggest Hits Torn - #2 Big Mistake - #2 Smoke - #5 Shiver - #8[/b] Previous Winners Lily Allen - #1
October 5, 200915 yr Author CRAP!! Will a mod please add a poll. I totally forgot mod's couldn't do this!!
October 5, 200915 yr I added a poll, and added in a vote for each to count OYS and Chris' votes. Natalie Imbruglia for me, it'll be quite a joke if she doesn't win this.
October 5, 200915 yr Lily. Natalie will only ever have one amazing song in 'Torn' (Although I prefer that to pretty much everything Lily has done) but I prefer Lily alot more as a whole...
October 5, 200915 yr Natalie will only ever have one amazing song in 'Torn' It greatly annoys me whenever anyone says this (or more ludicrously I have heard people claim her to be a "one hit wonder"). Why do people forget about such classics like 'Big Mistake', 'Smoke', 'Wishing I Was There', 'Wrong Impression' etc.
October 6, 200915 yr Nat. Lily Allen is just a talentless hag who talks her songs. At least she is a funny songwriter.
October 6, 200915 yr Lily. Natalie will only ever have one amazing song in 'Torn' (Although I prefer that to pretty much everything Lily has done) but I prefer Lily alot more as a whole... :o Did you forget about Shiver? :mellow:
October 6, 200915 yr I'm not keen on Natalie's work... I know a lot more Lily than Natalie. So... I won't vote on this one, I'm afraid. Nat. Lily Allen is just a talentless hag who talks her songs. At least she is a funny songwriter. Then, she's talented when it comes to songwriting so if she is talentless, then her songs won't be that umm... funny? :P Edited October 6, 200915 yr by FM11
October 6, 200915 yr Hmm I dunno, I love both actually although I don't think much of Natalie's latest stuff tbh even though I absolutely adore 'Torn', 'Big Mistake', 'Shiver' and 'Counting Down The Days'. I'll still have to go for Lily though as she's been more consistent for me.
October 6, 200915 yr It greatly annoys me whenever anyone says this (or more ludicrously I have heard people claim her to be a "one hit wonder"). Why do people forget about such classics like 'Big Mistake', 'Smoke', 'Wishing I Was There', 'Wrong Impression' etc.We don't forget them. We just don't like them all that much, and she will never come close to beating 'Torn'. That's just my opinion :P :o Did you forget about Shiver? :mellow:'Shiver' I found to be OK. Nothing more, nothing less...
October 6, 200915 yr Natalie. She's got a much more consistent back catalogue than Lily - I personally find the latter to be very hit and miss. I liked LDN, hated Littlest Thing, loved The Far, was indifferent to Not Fair... However I have yet to hear a Natalie single I didn't like. That Day wasn't an immediate hit, but did grow on me...
October 7, 200915 yr Natalie, overall she is the best IMO But the new single/album is absolute cack :P
October 7, 200915 yr Author New leader! I will close this after midnight tonight when I'm back from work.
Create an account or sign in to comment