Who do you think will triumph? Suppose most people will say Robbie but I think as JLS are so popular they may just beat him!

Hmmm not sure, either wouldnt surprise me. I reckon jls will take no1 though.

Thanks to whoever added the poll. Wanted to add one after I'd posted but wasn't sure how! :(

Edited November 3, 200915 yr by Crazy Chris

JLS :)

I'm actually unsure.

 

I'd normally say Robbie, but I don't feel the hype for this as I have his previous albums, plus the "comeback" seems to have worn off since "Bodies." JLS aren't really established, but they have some ranging stans, plus five versions of their album to buy.

 

I think Robbie will do it, but at the same time I won't be surprised if JLS pip him to it.

Robbie Williams. He is a massive album seller while JLS are the newbies. Besides, looking at Cheryl and Alexandra, the album sales are much lower than single sales. So, Robbie.

Good god 4 different slipcases and a group album for JLS, now who on earth is going to spend 45 quid on them :blink:

 

http://hmv.com/hmvweb/simpleMultiSearch.do...tring=jls+album

Good god 4 different slipcases and a group album for JLS, now who on earth is going to spend 45 quid on them :blink:

 

http://hmv.com/hmvweb/simpleMultiSearch.do...tring=jls+album

 

What a ridiculous thing to do. Its not even like they are known for having individual personalities yet. Crazy.

This is hard... Robbie? He's a big album seller. But momentum is wearing off for him. JLS could sell more, as they are basically the relevant act at the moment. I'll say JLS.

I wouldnt be surprised if JLS clinch it. However Robbie has the potential from past performance to wipe the floor with them. It could go either way.

a #2 comeback album would be a disaster for Robbie...luckily I think he will beat JLS although both should easily sell north of 100k

I think Robbie - the album has been number 1 on pre-orders for about 4 weeks.

I'd really like it Robbie to get #1 but I think he'll loose out to X Factor again.. :mellow:

I think JLS will top 200k with mega fans buying for different copies because of the slip cases.

Robbie!!!!!!! he's a massive album seller, Robbie will be #1 were he belongs! the other band probably will sell less than Cheryl and Alexandra albums....

I think Robbie will secure it, but not by miles.

might be close! but Robbie will sell more I suppose.

I am certain that JLS album will be as disappointing as Robbie's so DOES IT MATTER? :lol:

 

But i guess Robbie will do it.

Robbie will get number 1 easily, and will possibly stay there for a few weeks until Leona's album's released. I can't see very many people buying 4 JLS albums just because it has a different covers :huh:

 

Plus I rekon that major stores such as Tesco's and Asda will sell Robbie's album cheap as chips during it's first week, just like Take That's The Circus was £5.00 in Asda in it's first week

Edited November 3, 200915 yr by GAV

Robbie, quite easily I would have thought. He's had excellent promo with X Factor & his broadcasted Roudhouse gig. He also has a slot of Jonathon Ross further showcasing 2 album tracks & a few more available again on the red button.

Edited November 3, 200915 yr by truly talented