:mellow: This will break her top 3 streak in my personal chart (TEOG peaked at 2, all the other singles got 1) and might miss top 10 in the UK/US charts... I can't say I didn't see it coming though! But I suppose releasing a weaker track 4th is good as Scheisse or Marry The Night could still be huge as a 5th/6th single, whereas if You & I is left until then it'd flop SO badly.

 

I'll raise you 'LoveGame'!

I'd give LoveGame a 9, I prefer it to You & I (which I'd give 8).

Ugh why this? i dont mind the song, and i know its very personal to her, but its not a good choice for a single, granted its already peaked at #33 in the US, its not gonna make the top 10, i don't get why she would pick this when there are so many other epic moments on this album. I really hope we get Schiesse 5th then.

 

 

 

Yoü and I makes commerical sense, it debuted at #36 in the US from album cherry picking, was covered on American Idol, and it's a sing-along, potentially massive cross over hit. Look at Paul O' Grady and Radio 1's Big Weekend to see how much of a reaction it gets when she performs it live, let alone at her concert shows. It's the only option left that I think will guarantee her another big radio hit in the US; which would help keep the momentum going - it's not a good time for a risky release. Marry the Night is the only other clear commerical single, and I hope that gets a winter release; Americano for 2012. Seeing as how we are supposed to get 9 singles this era that's going to last until 2013, it's safe to say Sheiße will gets its moment aswell as a full on Hair campaign.

 

Bloody Mary would indeed be a disaster single, even if it's given a novelty halloween release as some fans seem to want; it didn't work for Judas at Easter did it?

Edited July 14, 201113 yr by Daniel II

I don't know...

I think it's going to be Americano :-)

I think it'll be "Bloody Mary" or "You & I".

Edited July 14, 201113 yr by dannjohn3

@ladygaga

 

Next video in just days. So passionate about the concept. Can't sleep. Visions of a surreal love. #YuyiIsReal. If you want her to be. -MM

Davidson said in the iTunes thread that Lady Gaga has apparently confirmed Y&I at a gig in Australia :(

Right now, I'd be very shocked if we were to find out the fourth single isn't 'Yoü and I'. It's a great song, but it just doesn't seem right to be a single. :(

She has all this choice and goes with You and I. Mental.

Is You and I confirmed then? :/

Is You and I confirmed then? :/

I don't know, I was just bringing what Davidson said in the iTunes thread here, which was that Gaga herself apparently confirmed it at a concert in Australia but a Google search yields nothing so I'm not sure it has.

Pleased, I love "Marry The Night" but she needs something wildly different out there to sell the album. I can see Y&I getting massive radio play, maybe even "Alejandro" levels.

Geez, You and I as the next single. It lacks catchiness and a hook, something which is important for the charts. I really don't think it will do a Rolling In The Deep...

You & I would be a stupid choice. She really should go for Hair which is a surefire smash.

Yoü & I should be the last single to close the album. I say GH, FOHL, BK or Americano

If it is indeed You and I, i really hope its a US only single, and she releases Scheisse internationally! :)

We will wait for the video I guess to see what is the next single

So 'You & I' isn't definitely the next single? I'd rather it be something else, as I find it quite similar to 'The Edge Of Glory', and it feels like the perfect song to end the era. Hopefully we get 'Scheibe' and 'Americano' at some point :D

She has to release Scheisse!

You & I would be a stupid choice. She really should go for Hair which is a surefire smash.

 

It didn't exactly smash worldwide as a promo single. It's not that great IMHO, You And I is better but I really want Americano or Bloody Mary.