Jump to content

Cheryl vs Dannii 82 members have voted

  1. 1. Better judge

    • Cheryl
      16
    • Dannii
      63
  2. 2. Better mentor

    • Cheryl
      28
    • Dannii
      51

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

That's because she always gets the catagory with the most talent. She hasn't had the Overs or the Groups yet.
  • Replies 29
  • Views 4.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Hmm... I voted Dannii on both. As a judge, sorry to say it BUT Cheryl adds very little to input and has a very narrow mind when it comes to musical perforances etcetc.

Dannii is a twat nowadays.

 

Always going on about it being a 'singing competition'

 

No Dannii, it is not! It is X Factor and most people in the charts can't sing so who gives a f*** about singing.

 

Anyway, her Aiden sings $h!t

  • Author
Dannii is a twat nowadays.

 

Always going on about it being a 'singing competition'

 

No Dannii, it is not! It is X Factor and most people in the charts can't sing so who gives a f*** about singing.

 

Anyway, her Aiden sings $h!t

 

To be honest, I think you're thinking more of Louis... Dannii rarely mentions it being a 'singing competition'... Personally, though, I give a f**k about singing. It gave me more pleasure to pay £70 to see Lady GaGa sing live on tour than it did to watch Cheryl Cole mime on TV for free... Before anyone brings up dance routines, GaGa's dance routines were *far* more athletic and impressive and she still managed to sing live. Pathetic excuse, given how she is judging other people on their singing...

  • 1 month later...

I really like both, but better judge/mentor, got to be Danni, wasnt a fan of hers untill 2009/2010 though. :)

That said though, i think if i was a contestant myself i'd rather have Cheryl for some reason :lol:

Really, i like both, but they could find better singers/artists to be judges of the biggest show in the UK in all fairness.

Edited by Merry Christmas!

Danni ... on both counts. She cares about her charges (and continues to do so afterwards .... Stacey Solomon as proof).

 

Kath

  • 2 weeks later...
ruth lorenzo aswell, dannii and ruth are still in contact and actually have hung out together, dannii is by the far the best judge and certianly the most genuine.
  • 1 month later...
cheryl is the best mentor she is just soo caring.

 

Katie Waissel has reportedly said that she has not heard from her former X Factor mentor Cheryl Cole since the programme finished.

 

Waissel was voted out of the reality talent contest in the eighth week of last year's show as part of a double elimination.

 

Asked if Cole should have guided her through the aftermath of her exit, Waissel told Star: "No, not really. Call me controversial, but she's doing her thing.

 

"She's an artist herself, she had her Christmas break and I don't expect anything from her."

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.