May 9, 201114 yr I've heard its either Frankie Sandford or Tulisa from N-Dubz Either would be a vast improvement on Alesha don't you think? Kath
May 9, 201114 yr LOL is that a joke Kathy? I can't think of a single person on the planet with less charisma than Frankie Sandford. Alesha would be great on the X Factor - she's perfectly qualified. Yeah she's not quite a great fit for Strictly but that doesn't mean jack in relation to how good she could be on the X Factor. She's an entertainer and most importantly a singer (a bloody good one) after all. I think the final panel will definitely include Gary Barlow, Dannii and Louis. Just not sure who the fourth judge might be. Not a chance Lily Allen will do it.
May 9, 201114 yr LOL is that a joke Kathy? I can't think of a single person on the planet with less charisma than Frankie Sandford. Alesha would be great on the X Factor - she's perfectly qualified. Yeah she's not quite a great fit for Strictly but that doesn't mean jack in relation to how good she could be on the X Factor. She's an entertainer and most importantly a singer (a bloody good one) after all. I do not jest Jark. Apart from one song - Alesha has hardly set the music world on fire has she. At least as a member of The Saturdays Frankie's had a lot more chart success than Alesha (who quite frankly - is vastly overrrated as a singer!) I actually think she's ok on SCD (I thought she was a great dancer) I just can't stand her voice - its pants! Honestly - I'd rather have a Saturday's album than one by Alesha Dixon any day of the week (even if its not a Saturday). Alesha does have a great, raucous laugh though! Kath Edited May 9, 201114 yr by Kathyp
May 9, 201114 yr I'm surprised the Aussie one is still running, wasn't its ratings dire? I'm not sure, I haven't seen ratings for it.
May 9, 201114 yr Alesha being on the judging panel would be a stupid idea. Not only would it smack of Cowell trying to get one over on their main competitors by stealing one of their judges, she's not exactly a big name anymore (her own music career has completely failed, I think its safe to say) and although I don't watch Strictly, I've never heard anything positive about her ability to judge. She's also not exactly the most interesting person either, so they can't claim she's going to add a bit of "spark/personality" to the panel because I don't think she would. Gary Barlow I'm half on board with. Hugely successful singer/songwriter who has been huge in almost everything he's tried (minus his own solo career, obv). He'd definitely deserve to be there. He's also as dull as dishwater and has a voice which could cure insomnia, so like I say I'm HALF with him, half without. I heard the other day that Simon had said he didn't know who Frankie Sandford was. Thank the LORD if that's the case because she is, in my humble opinion of course, just a dim girl who fell into a successful girlband. People are saying this makes her akin to Cheryl but Cheryl is opinionated, funny, intelligent - I have never seen Frankie display any of these attributes. If we want a judge who can laugh cutely and act dumb, get PIXIE LOTT. Of course, I am a big Cheryl fan so it'll be tough for them to replace her with someone I will LOVE but I'm happy to be impressed if they just choose someone suitable. (Nicole Scherzinger would've been good.)
May 9, 201114 yr Frankie would be an even worse judge- what judging credentials would she have exactly? and what personality does she have? I have yet to see either Tulisa was apparently stopped as she kept swearing :lol: I don't think she was ever confirmed though, she would have been even worse Gary Barlow is a worthy judge and has been been in the industry a long time (although he's hardly that exciting admittedly), Alesha would be a bit WTF as she isn't a very popular judge on SCD (and isn't that relevant musically any more), so that would be a pretty bland panel :( I'd say they'd need at least one judge with a bit of personality (and judging credentials of course)
May 9, 201114 yr I could see Katy Perry being the 4th judge...Alesha Dixon would be stupid. As its already been said - smacks of Cowell's ego. Would be a terrible move.
May 10, 201114 yr Tulisa :wub: I think she'd be a surprisingly good choice! She won't take any $h!t. :lol:
May 10, 201114 yr I would LOVE it to be Alesha! OMG ME 2!!! She was only part of the most successful girl group IN THE WORLD, she has a well EXCITING PERSONALITY, and she is fukking musically gifted! Alesha plz!!!! <3
May 10, 201114 yr I'm really pleased the 'big stars' Cheryl Cole and Simon Cowell have left, it should be the beginning of the end for this stupid and destructive TV show.
May 10, 201114 yr It won't be Tulisa. She had a screen test and apparently swore too much. :lol: I'd rather have Tulisa's swearing than Alesha's cackling. Kath
May 10, 201114 yr What about Adele ? :kink: She would make the best judge ever, with her funny and witty comments. Plus she was in the X Factor USA crowd yesterday ... was she anticipating a future role on X Factor UK ?
May 10, 201114 yr Get Gary Barlow and Pixie Lott in as the judges. Ah yes, Dull and Duller! What a spiffing idea for judges on the countries biggest TV show. They need someone with a big personality, especially if Barlow has got the gig. They are going to need to make up for his lack of one and pack enough star power to draw the viewers. Lily Allen would be perfect. I'd love to see Keisha Buchanan, but she's admitted she'd be scared to say mean things :lol:
May 10, 201114 yr I think Alesha would be perfect. I do agree with Slick's point that it would be Cowell getting one over on Strictly, but I think she'd be a brilliant judge. She obviously CAN sing, has a brilliant, bubbly personality from what I've seen and of course, the laugh. That alone would make the X Factor much more watchable! To be fair though I wouldn't really mind anyone except for Tulisa or Pixie f***ing Lott.
May 10, 201114 yr I think Alesha would be perfect. I do agree with Slick's point that it would be Cowell getting one over on Strictly, but I think she'd be a brilliant judge. She obviously CAN sing, has a brilliant, bubbly personality from what I've seen and of course, the laugh. That alone would make the X Factor much more watchable! To be fair though I wouldn't really mind anyone except for Tulisa or Pixie f***ing Lott. For me, the laugh is the only thing that Alesha has got going for her. She's an incredibly weak vocalist (although I'll admit TBDN is one of the best songs of the last few years) and her comments would have no substance ... she's too nice! No ... they should think outside the box for the fourth judge and the only person for me is ....... 'Ooh, Ooh, Ooh Miss Grace'!!! http://fashion-stylist.net/blog/wp-content/uploads/image/grace-jones2.jpg Personality, style, talent, impact ... and she could knock seven kinds of crap out of anyone who disagreed with her! Kath
Create an account or sign in to comment