http://www.thisisrnb.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/10/Kelly-Rowland-Elle-2.jpg

 

Hello ladies and gentleladies of Buzzjack! I hate to drag your attention away from Lady of the Hour, Beyoncé, but as promised, here is a Kelly rate of her UK singles discography.

 

Here is a few background rules/tips:

- Any song that charted in the UK singles chart, with Kelly as the main of featured artist on will be included in the rate.

- All songs must be rated between 0 (worst), and 10 (best); posters are allowed the option to give a -1 to the song they feel is the lowest point of Kelly's career, and an 11 to the song they think is her career highlight.

- If you do not know or remember a song, you may mark it with a "?", although it would be preferable for you to give any you're not sure of a listen via the emporium that is THE INTERNET.

 

I'll give posters two-three weeks to rate, and then will commence with the results, depending on how many people rate (I am aiming for at least 15 - although I hope there'll be more!).

 

Enjoy rating, and here are the singles from beginning to present:

 

'Dilemma' (with Nelly) [2002]

'Stole' [2003]

'Can't Nobody' [2003]

'Train On A Track' [2003]

'Here We Go' (with Trina) [2006]

'Like This' (with Eve) [2007]

'Work' (Freemasons Remix) [2008]

'Daylight' (with Travis McCoy) [2008]

'When Love Takes Over' (with David Guetta) [2009]

'Commander' (with David Guetta) [2010]

'Forever And A Day' [2010]

'Invincible' (with Tinie Tempah) [2011]

'Gone' (with Nelly) [2011]

'Motivation' (with Lil' Wayne) [2011]

'What A Feeling' (with Alex Gaudino) [2011]

 

GO GO GO!

Edited June 29, 201113 yr by THEO.

09.5 'Dilemma'

09.0 'Stole'

11.0 'Can't Nobody'

08.5 'Train On A Track'

05.5 'Here We Go'

10.0 'Like This'

09.5 'Work'

10.0 'Daylight'

09.0 'When Love Takes Over'

07.5 'Commander'

05.0 'Forever And A Day'

04.0 'Invincible'

06.5 'Gone'

06.0 'Motivation'

06.5 'What A Feeling'

I don't actually KNOW what that Trina song is, so I'll rate in the morning, for the record.

09.0 'Dilemma'

09.0 'Stole'

07.5 'Can't Nobody'

08.5 'Train On A Track'

08.5 'Here We Go'

07.5 'Like This'

11.0 'Work'

06.0 'Daylight'

09.0 'When Love Takes Over'

07.0 'Commander'

05.0 'Forever And A Day'

06.0 'Invincible'

06.0 'Gone'

07.0 'Motivation'

07.0 'What A Feeling'

 

Her recently charted stuff really hasn't made much of a mark on me at all :( I like the Trina duet, it's lovely and chilled but retains a melody, although Train On A Track does the same thing just as well I guess. I don't 'get' her middle-ground dance stuff of late, it's all been downhill since When Love Takes Over on that front.

-1.0 'Dilemma' (with Nelly) [2002]

08.0 'Stole' [2003]

02.5 'Can't Nobody' [2003]

03.0 'Train On A Track' [2003]

01.0 'Here We Go' (with Trina) [2006]

03.0 'Like This' (with Eve) [2007]

11.0 'Work' (Freemasons Remix) [2008]

04.5 'Daylight' (with Travis McCoy) [2008]

10.0 'When Love Takes Over' (with David Guetta) [2009]

09.5 'Commander' (with David Guetta) [2010]

07.5 'Forever And A Day' [2010]

08.5 'Invincible' (with Tinie Tempah) [2011]

01.0 'Gone' (with Nelly) [2011]

10.0 'Motivation' (with Lil' Wayne) [2011]

06.5 'What A Feeling' (with Alex Gaudino) [2011]

 

As you can tell i wasn't much of a fan of her early stuff (bar stole) and anything involving nelly haha. i feel bad giving Forever And A Day a 7 but it's just because the rest are a lot better

Edited June 29, 201113 yr by 152chris

10.0 'Dilemma'

09.0 'Stole'

09.0 'Can't Nobody'

07.5 'Train On a Track'

06.5 'Here We Go'

08.0 'Like This'

11.0 'Work'

10.0 'Daylight'

10.0 'When Love Takes Over'

09.5 'Commander'

07.0 'Forever and a Day'

05.0 'Invincible'

06.5 'Gone'

08.0 'Motivation'

10.0 'What a Feeling'

 

07.5 'Dilemma' (with Nelly) [2002]

08.0 'Stole' [2003]

08.5 'Can't Nobody' [2003]

06.0 'Train On A Track' [2003]

04.0 'Here We Go' (with Trina) [2006]

08.0 'Like This' (with Eve) [2007]

09.0 'Work' (Freemasons Remix) [2008]

04.0 'Daylight' (with Travis McCoy) [2008]

-1.0 'When Love Takes Over' (with David Guetta) [2009]

07.0 'Commander' (with David Guetta) [2010]

05.0 'Forever And A Day' [2010]

07.0 'Invincible' (with Tinie Tempah) [2011]

05.0 'Gone' (with Nelly) [2011]

11 'Motivation' (with Lil' Wayne) [2011]

04.0 'What A Feeling' (with Alex Gaudino) [2011]

 

'Motivation' is by far her best single imo! Love 'Work' and 'Can't Nobody' too though.

Depise 'When Love Takes Over'.

11.0 'Dilemma'

09.0 'Stole'

08.0 'Can't Nobody'

07.5 'Train On A Track'

10.0 'Here We Go'

09.5 'Like This'

04.0 'Work'

06.5 'Daylight'

10.0 'When Love Takes Over'

05.0 'Commander'

04.0 'Forever And A Day'

09.0 'Invincible'

03.0 'Gone'

07.0 'Motivation'

06.0 'What A Feeling'

Hard to pick an 11 but...

 

09.0 'Dilemma'

11.0 'Stole'

08.0 'Can't Nobody'

08.0 'Train On A Track'

06.5 'Here We Go'

10.0 'Like This'

09.5 'Work'

09.0 'Daylight'

10.0 'When Love Takes Over'

10.0 'Commander'

09.0 'Forever And A Day'

10.0 'Invincible'

06.0 'Gone'

10.0 'Motivation'

07.5 'What A Feeling'

 

11 was pretty close between WLTO, Commander and Stole, but Stole is so underrated, it deserves it :wub:

Edited August 13, 201113 yr by Liаm

06.0 'Dilemma'

05.0 'Stole'

06.0 'Can't Nobody'

04.0 'Train On A Track'

06.0 'Here We Go'

07.5 'Like This'

10.0 'Work'

09.0 'Daylight'

09.0 'When Love Takes Over'

11.0 'Commander'

10.0 'Forever And A Day'

04.0 'Invincible'

02.0 'Gone'

06.0 'Motivation'

08.0 'What A Feeling'

Edited June 30, 201113 yr by Johnkm

09 'Dilemma'

10 'Stole'

09 'Can't Nobody'

08 'Train On A Track'

05 'Here We Go'

07 'Like This'

11 'Work'

06 'Daylight'

10 'When Love Takes Over'

06 'Commander'

02 'Forever And A Day'

03 'Invincible'

?? 'Gone'

?? 'Motivation'

05 'What A Feeling'

The middling scores for Like This kill me. You lot have no souls.

10.0 'Dilemma'

11.0 'Stole'

08.0 'Can't Nobody'

07.5 'Train On A Track'

06.5 'Here We Go'

08.0 'Like This'

08.5 'Work'

09.0 'Daylight'

10.0 'When Love Takes Over'

09.5 'Commander'

07.5 'Forever And A Day'

07.0 'Invincible'

07.5 'Gone'

08.5 'Motivation'

08.5 'What A Feeling'

The middling scores for Like This kill me. You lot have no souls.

IKR?! :( It's incredible. It's the sort of Urban song Kelly should stick too. None of this 'Motivation' stuff! :(

 

Also, where's 'Rose Colored Glasses' in the rate, Theo? :(

07.5 'Dilemma' (with Nelly) [2002]

09.5 'Stole' [2003]

08.5 'Can't Nobody' [2003]

07.0 'Train On A Track' [2003]

06.5 'Here We Go' (with Trina) [2006]

08.5 'Like This' (with Eve) [2007]

08.0 'Work' (Freemasons Remix) [2008]

08.5 'Daylight' (with Travis McCoy) [2008]

10.0 'When Love Takes Over' (with David Guetta) [2009]

11.0 'Commander' (with David Guetta) [2010]

07.5 'Forever And A Day' [2010]

06.5 'Invincible' (with Tinie Tempah) [2011]

05.0 'Gone' (with Nelly) [2011]

07.5 'Motivation' (with Lil' Wayne) [2011]

07.0 'What A Feeling' (with Alex Gaudino) [2011]

'Dilemma' (with Nelly) [2002] 9 - No denying how huge this song was!

'Stole' [2003] 10 - So Underrated.

'Can't Nobody' [2003] - 8

'Train On A Track' [2003] - 6

'Here We Go' (with Trina) [2006] - 7

'Like This' (with Eve) [2007] - 8

'Work' (Freemasons Remix) [2008] - 8

'Daylight' (with Travis McCoy) [2008] - 7

'When Love Takes Over' (with David Guetta) [2009] - 9

'Commander' (with David Guetta) [2010] 9.5

'Forever And A Day' [2010] - 5

'Invincible' (with Tinie Tempah) [2011] - 8

'Gone' (with Nelly) [2011] - 6

'Motivation' (with Lil' Wayne) [2011] 11 Becoming my fav Kelly track and is already my fav video!

'What A Feeling' (with Alex Gaudino) [2011] - 7

Also, where's 'Rose Colored Glasses' in the rate, Theo? :(

"Rose Colored Glasses" wasn't released in the UK. :P

10.0 'Dilemma'

10.0 'Stole'

08.5 'Can't Nobody'

07.5 'Train On A Track'

06.0 'Here We Go'

08.0 'Like This'

10.0 'Work' (Freemasons Remix)

08.5 'Daylight'

11.0 'When Love Takes Over'

10.0 'Commander'

07.5 'Forever And A Day'

07.5 'Invincible'

07.0 'Gone'

08.5 'Motivation'

08.5 'What A Feeling'

 

A very strong (singles) discography, with a forgotten chorus being pretty much the lowest point.

Edited August 14, 201113 yr by THEO.

10 'Dilemma' (with Nelly) [2002]

10 'Stole' [2003]

07 'Can't Nobody' [2003]

07 'Train On A Track' [2003]

05 'Here We Go' (with Trina) [2006]

09 'Like This' (with Eve) [2007]

11 'Work' (Freemasons Remix) [2008]

08 'Daylight' (with Travis McCoy) [2008]

09 'When Love Takes Over' (with David Guetta) [2009]

09 'Commander' (with David Guetta) [2010]

10 'Forever And A Day' [2010]

04'Invincible' (with Tinie Tempah) [2011]

08 'Gone' (with Nelly) [2011]

08 'Motivation' (with Lil' Wayne) [2011]

07 'What A Feeling' (with Alex Gaudino) [2011]

 

10 | 'Dilemma' (with Nelly) [2002]

11 | 'Stole' [2003]

09 | 'Can't Nobody' [2003]

08 | 'Train On A Track' [2003]

08 | 'Here We Go' (with Trina) [2006]

06 | 'Like This' (with Eve) [2007]

09 | 'Work' (Freemasons Remix) [2008]

09 | 'Daylight' (with Travis McCoy) [2008]

10 | 'When Love Takes Over' (with David Guetta) [2009]

08 | 'Commander' (with David Guetta) [2010]

07 | 'Forever And A Day' [2010]

08 | 'Invincible' (with Tinie Tempah) [2011]

06 | 'Gone' (with Nelly) [2011]

07 | 'Motivation' (with Lil' Wayne) [2011]

07 | 'What A Feeling' (with Alex Gaudino) [2011]

 

She started off very strong but has got much weaker recently. 'Gone', 'What A Feeling' and 'Motivation' are all so lifeless.