June 6, 201213 yr I'm going to add something in (if it helps). The lyrics for the Monrose's Hot Summer and f(x)'s Hot Summer is different (once the f(x) version is translated into English). The only same parts are the chorus really. It could be said that it's more of a large sample than a cover if the lyrics to everything but the chorus is the same. Monrose - Hot Summer Hot, hot, hot, hot Hot, hot, hot, hot Hot, hot, hot, hot Hot, hot, hot, hot They're placing me here in the bad girls section I got a new dress that looks perfection I'm introduced to a hot producer But I can tell he's just a stuck up loser I keep it composed Just wanna rip off my clothes I wanna give out a toast To do so freakin a mode I got a feeling and I just can't let it go Now I can't stop it baby let's get physical Just wanna get up in a good vibration And I can feel it in the air It's gonna be a hot summer A hot, hot summer Hot summer A hot, hot Gonna be a hot summer A hot, hot summer Hot summer A hot, hot Gonna be a Hot, hot, hot, hot Hot, hot, hot, hot I need somebody To release this tension And that club is such a good invention It makes me rid of all these complications From here I know That we can rock this nation Thank you to phone Tonight I'm claiming my throne You got me into the zone And now this party is on I got a feeling and I just can't let it go Now I can't stop it baby let's get physical Just wanna get up in a good vibration And I can feel it in the air It's gonna be a hot summer A hot, hot summer Hot summer A hot, hot Gonna be a hot summer A hot, hot summer Hot summer A hot, hot Gonna be a Beach lake Convertible Short dress Here we go Rooftop Party on Can't stop until the morn' Laundries Short skirts Good times Can't hurt I keep it composed Just wanna rip off my clothes I wanna give out a toast To do so freakin a mode I got a feeling and I just can't let it go Now I can't stop it baby let's get physical Just wanna get up in a good vibration And I can feel it in the air It's gonna be a hot summer A hot, hot summer Hot summer A hot, hot Gonna be a hot summer A hot, hot summer Hot summer A hot, hot Gonna be a Hot, hot, hot, hot Hot, hot, hot, hotf(x) - Hot Summer Hot Hot Hot Hot Summer Hot Hot Hot Hot Hot Hot Hot Hot Summer Hot Hot Hot Hot I can't take this anymore I'm going to take care of this somehow I don't know anything but your old style If I were to produce you, do you have any idea how cool you can be? Come on, come out from the classroom, From the office desk, from your uncleaned room Sunglasses protecting my eyes from the hot, Blinding, slightly stinging sunlight rays The tingling feeling of biting the ice in your mouth The sky is clear and blue Hot Summer Ah Hot Hot Summer Hot Summer Ah Hot Hot so hot Hot Summer Ah Hot Hot Summer Hot Summer Ah Hot Hot, this is definitely my taste Hot Hot Hot Hot Summer Hot Hot Hot Hot Hot Hot Hot Hot Summer Hot Hot Hot Hot Even if it isn't the Malibu beach The waves still sparkle like gold dust I brush off my feet before entering an ice cream shop With uninteresting gossip broadcasting on the TV Come on let's play in the water from the Han River And at the water park in the east sea Hot Hot Hot Hot Summer Hot Hot Hot Hot Hot Hot Hot Hot Summer Hot Hot Hot Hot Hot Summer Ah Hot Hot Summer Hot Summer Ah Hot Hot so hot Hot Summer Ah Hot Hot Summer Hot Summer Ah Hot Hot, this is definitely my taste Let's show the sweating foreigners here If it's too hot, wear something black and long Yeah! It must be burning Cause I got you sweating in this weather All them heads be turning, true that You know I got it Sunglasses protecting my eyes from the hot, Blinding, slightly stinging sunlight rays The tingling feeling of biting the ice in your mouth The sky is clear and blue Hot Summer Ah Hot Hot Summer Hot Summer Ah Hot Hot so hot Hot Summer Ah Hot Hot Summer Hot Summer Ah Hot Hot, this is definitely my taste Hot Summer Ah Hot Hot Summer Hot Summer Ah Hot Hot so hot Hot Hot Hot Hot Summer Hot Hot Hot Hot Summer Edited June 6, 201213 yr by Oricon
June 6, 201213 yr I don't see why f(x) should have to be changed, I know rules are rules but if 4 people have voted already then it's a bit much to change and everything. I suppose it would depend how many of the 4 have voted for f(x), although obviously Pav can't divulge that information unless it's not in the contest anymore. EDIT: That's true Oricon, but iirc the rule extends to samples/adaptations as well :( Edited June 6, 201213 yr by Liаm
June 6, 201213 yr Author I suppose it would depend how many of the 4 have voted for f(x) It doesn't as I would have to ask all people who voted if they want to include the new Daehun's entry in their votes, if Oricon was asked to change his entry. :(
June 6, 201213 yr Ah yeah, that too! Didn't think of that :( Obviously we wait for the mods, but if it was me then I'd say go on ahead because it's too late now to change.
June 6, 201213 yr I'm going to add something in (if it helps). The lyrics for the Monrose's Hot Summer and f(x)'s Hot Summer is different (once the f(x) version is translated into English). The only same parts are the chorus really. It could be said that it's more of a large sample than a cover if the lyrics to everything but the chorus is the same. what? Then next time I can send this as it has a different lyrics? -JROcLrbu-I Definitely NOT!
June 6, 201213 yr One of the voters was Oricon himself and personally, I'm not too bothered listening to a different song. I know my opinion is useless but I agree with Alex Banan that rules shouldn't be changed during a contest.
June 6, 201213 yr EDIT: That's true Oricon, but iirc the rule extends to samples/adaptations as well :( Oh I see, never realised that applied too :lol: what? Then next time I can send this as it has a different lyrics? -JROcLrbu-I Definitely NOT! You do have a point I guess, I'll see what the mods final judgement is and happily accept what they given me.
June 6, 201213 yr If a rule doesn't make much sense to begin with it's a pretty non-logical line to take that you should cause a greater inconvenience just to stick to that rule.
June 6, 201213 yr what? Then next time I can send this as it has a different lyrics? -JROcLrbu-I Definitely NOT! I don't even know what that is, so I don't really see why that would be some obvious violation of the spirit of the contest. -x- Since when did the rule apply to samples and adaptations? So far as I'm aware that's never been the case.
June 6, 201213 yr People are going so OTT on this, does it REALLY matter if te Since when did the rule apply to samples and adaptations? So far as I'm aware that's never been the case. I'm sure I remember somebody telling me that before :unsure: You being an ex-mod though I'm sure you know more than I do, I just thought I remember being told that it applied to samples and adaptations as well. But if not, then Hot Summer isn't a DIRECT cover if the lyrics are different so the rule shouldn't really apply?
June 6, 201213 yr Rules: Songs with samples are permitted, unless the sample is from a previous BJSC or Eurovision entry.
June 6, 201213 yr Author Faye-gate, tiny vetoing-gate, Hot Summer-gate. All in the span of one week. Gotta love Pavel-hosted contests :D Edited June 6, 201213 yr by Pavel
June 6, 201213 yr Oh, and how many more 'scandals' can we have this contest? I guess some controversy was going to arise with the huge number of participants though. This does reinforce that everyone should check the previous entries thread before sending songs though.
June 6, 201213 yr This does reinforce that everyone should check the previous entries thread before sending songs though. I guess it wasn't really possible for Oricon to notice though, because Hot Summer was under Monrose alphabetically, something which he wouldn't have been able to check as he didn't know it was a Monrose cover. Of course, for normal cases then yes it does reinforce this.
June 6, 201213 yr I guess it wasn't really possible for Oricon to notice though, because Hot Summer was under Monrose alphabetically, something which he wouldn't have been able to check as he didn't know it was a Monrose cover. Of course, for normal cases then yes it does reinforce this. Same song name though?
June 6, 201213 yr Oh, and how many more 'scandals' can we have this contest? I guess some controversy was going to arise with the huge number of participants though. This does reinforce that everyone should check the previous entries thread before sending songs though. I would, but I had no idea f(x) even covered Monrose's track in the first place so picking "Hot Summer" from a whole list of song is pretty hard to pick out :lol:. Maybe next time I should check all my entries on somewhere like Wikipedia so it's safe from being a cover of a previous entry. :P
June 6, 201213 yr Same song name though? Yeah, but the list of previous entries is listed alphabetically on artist, so it would have been hard to pick out one song title from all of those previous entries.
June 6, 201213 yr I would, but I had no idea f(x) even covered Monrose's track in the first place so picking "Hot Summer" from a whole list of song is pretty hard to pick out :lol:. Maybe next time I should check all my entries on somewhere like Wikipedia so it's safe from being a cover of a previous entry. :P Oh, I agree this would have been tricky one to spot. It's not the simplest situation!
Create an account or sign in to comment