Jump to content

Featured Replies

Posted

These sort of topics have always fascinated me on here but I've never ever seen one on artists springboarded to fame via one of the many reality pop shows we've had in the UK for the last 12 years or so. With this in mind I thought it'd be a good idea to open up to Buzzjack users and find out who is the 'ultimate' one of these. Below I've compiled a list of 60 artists, organised by the shows we first saw them on. My criteria has been to include artists that have, since the show they were on finished, released at least one single or album that has charted in the UK top 100.

 

From this list, I want you to vote for your individual top 10 from the 60 nominated here. The artist you put 1st on your list will be awarded 10 points, 2nd awarded 9 points, and so on until the 10th artist on your list is awarded 1 point. I'll leave voting open for two weeks and close it on Good Friday (29th March). I'll then run down the top 50 on this same page once I've added up all the votes. Have fun :)

 

The Ultimate Reality Popstar: Nominations - **VOTING NOW CLOSED**

 

POPSTARS/POPSTARS: THE RIVALS

Hear'Say

Liberty X

Warren Stacey

Girls Aloud

One True Voice

The Cheeky Girls

Javine

Clea

Phixx

 

POP IDOL/AMERICAN IDOL

Will Young

Gareth Gates

Darius Campbell

Zoe Birkett

Rosie Ribbons

Jessica Garlick

Sarah Whatmore

Michelle McManus

Sam & Mark

Kelly Clarkson

Carrie Underwood

Jennifer Hudson

Jordin Sparks

 

FAME ACADEMY

David Sneddon

Sinead Quinn

Lemar

Malachi Cush

Ainslie Henderson

Alex Parks

Alistair Griffin

James Fox

 

THE X FACTOR

Steve Brookstein

G4

Shayne Ward

Andy Abraham

Journey South

Maria Lawson

Leona Lewis

Ray Quinn

Ben Mills

The MacDonald Brothers

Avenue

Leon Jackson

Rhydian Roberts

Same Difference

Alexandra Burke

JLS

Diana Vickers

Eoghan Quigg

Joe McElderry

Olly Murs

Jedward

Matt Cardle

Rebecca Ferguson

One Direction

Cher Lloyd

Little Mix

Marcus Collins

Amelia Lily

Misha B

James Arthur

Edited by ThePensmith

  • Replies 148
  • Views 10.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Well I could have easily made a Top 20, was tough getting it down to 10 but here goes -

 

1. Girls Aloud

2. Kelly Clarkson

3. Leona Lewis

4. Jennifer Hudson

5. Carrie Underwood

6. Liberty X

7. Will Young

8. Shayne Ward

9. Olly Murs

10. One Direction

 

The top 2 are my 2 favourites ever not just reality stars, and I'm a Huge fan of 3-6.

Edited by Lukuzz

1. Kelly Clarkson

2. Girls Aloud

3. Leona Lewis

4. Carrie Underwood

5. One Direction

6. Jordin Sparks

7. Little Mix

8. Liberty X

9. Will Young

10. Alexandra Burke

 

The top four are four of my all time favourite acts, incredible :wub:

1. Kelly Clarkson

2. Girls Aloud

3. Leona Lewis

4. Carrie Underwood

5. One Direction

6. Jordin Sparks

7. Little Mix

8. Liberty X

9. Will Young

10. Alexandra Burke

 

The top four are four of my all time favourite acts, incredible :wub:

 

You have a wonderful top 2 artists of all time :wub: :lol:

My favourite song in brackets!

 

01 Kelly Clarkson (Because Of You)

02 Carrie Underwood (Before He Cheats)

03 Girls Aloud (Biology)

04 Little Mix (DNA)

05 Olly Murs (Troublemaker)

06 Jordin Sparks (Battlefield)

07 Leona Lewis (Run)

08 Alexandra Burke (Hallelujah)

09 Rebecca Ferguson (Teach Me How To Be Loved)

10 Jennifer Hudson (And I Am Telling You)

 

My top 2 artists of all time there :wub: Alex would be just above Little Mix if Heartbreak On Hold wasn't so disappointing!

Edited by Liаm

01. Girls Aloud

02. One Direction

03. Will Young

04. Olly Murs

05. Little Mix

06. Kelly Clarkson

07. Alexandra Burke

08. JLS

09. Amelia Lily

10. Liberty X

 

 

1. One Direction (best)

2. Carrie Underwood

3. Girls Aloud

4. Diana Vickers

5. Alexandra Burke

6. Leona Lewis

7. Kelly Clarkson

8. Rebecca Ferguson

9. Cher Lloyd

10. Maria Lawson

Edited by JosephAloud

1. Leona Lewis

2. Girls Aloud

3. Liberty X

4. Kelly Clarkson

5. Will Young

6. Cher Lloyd

7. Shayne Ward

8. Little Mix

9. Alexandra Burke

10. Lemar

01. Kelly Clarkson

02. Leona Lewis

03. Girls Aloud

04. Olly Murs

05. Cher Lloyd

06. Little Mix

07. Jordin Sparks

08. Liberty X

09. Alexandra Burke

10. Diana Vickers

 

No one touches Queen Kelly, reality TV star, or not. Olly Murs, Cher Lloyd and Little Mix are fast coming for the top 3 though! In particular Little Mix. I think in a couple of years, they'll take over Girls Aloud, definitely.

 

ALSO:

 

TAKE POINTS AWAY FROM: Rebecca Fergusson please. THANKS ;D

1 Kelly Clarkson

2 Lemar

3 Jennifer Hudson

4 Olly Murs

5 Little Mix

6 Will Young

7 Maria Lawson

8 Carrie Underwood

9 Shayne Ward

10 Alexandra Burke

  • Author
Thanks for all your votes thus far everyone...some interesting choices! (I mean that in a good way) :)

1. Cher Lloyd

2. Kelly Clarkson

3. Carrie Underwood

4. Girls Aloud

5. Diana Vickers

6. Misha B

7. Leona Lewis

8. Alexandra Burke

9. Little Mix

10. Jordin Sparks

1. Matt Cardle

2. Kelly Clarkson

3. Olly Murs

4. Carrie Underwood

5. Girls Aloud

6. Amelia Lily

7. Alexandra Burke

8. Jennifer Hudson

9. Leona Lewis

10. Sam & Mark

 

My poor brave Sa and Mark :snif: not enough love for them.

01 Kelly Clarkson

02 Girls Aloud

03 Liberty X

04 Alexandra Burke

05 Leona Lewis

06 Jordin Sparks

07 Little Mix

08 Lemar

09 Cher Lloyd

10 Amelia Lily

01 Kelly Clarkson

02 Same Difference

03 Alexandra Burke

04 Jordin Sparks

05 Little Mix

06 Girls Aloud

07 Olly Murs

08 Leona Lewis

09 Matt Cardle

10 JLS

 

Best of a list that is mostly very uninspiring.

Here is my Top 10, with my comments about the acts and their best and worst singles respectively in the brackets.

 

01 Leona Lewis (I still can't believe how much I loved Leona Lewis before 2009. She was amazing! :wub:) (A Moment Like This / I Got You)

02 Little Mix (SHOCK HORROR. LITLLE MIX ARE ABOVE GIRLS ALOUD. But at least Little Mix have made more than a few essential songs. *.*) (DNA / Wings)

03 Girls Aloud (For a band that have had a lot of hits, very few of them have been execptional. But I still like Girls Aloud! :D) (Biology / Call The Shots)

04 Olly Murs (He has made some epic tunes but he has also made one of the worst songs of all time. :() (Troublemaker / Army Of Two)

05 One Direction (This band have got better as they have progressed! They still have the ability to make crap songs though.) (Kiss You / Little Things)

06 Jordin Sparks (BRILLIANT. No Air is one of my favourite songs of all time. :wub:) (No Air / SOS (Let The Music Play))

07 Jennifer Hudson (Similarly, she has also been brilliant like Joridn Sparks. She has two essential songs though, with Spotlight, And I Am Telling You I'm Not Going and I Remember Me!) (Spotlight / If This Is Love)

08 Alexandra Burke (She also has some brilliant tunes to her name, such as Hallelujah, The Silence and Elephant. *.*) (Hallelujah / All Night Long)

09 Will Young (Yay, he's always been a very good recording artist. ^_^) (Leave Right Now / Switch It On)

10 JLS (Eyes Wide Shut and One Shot are anthems of my life. :wub:) (Eyes Wide Shut / She Makes Me Wanna)

 

Phew, that was hard! :drama: :lol:

01 Kelly Clarkson

02 Alexandra Burke

03 Jordin Sparks

04 Leona Lewis

05 Girls Aloud

06 Jennifer Hudson

07 JLS

08 Shayne Ward

09 Olly Murs

10 Javine

 

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.